In Ontario, courts strive to prevent children from testifying in open court during domestic violence trials. Lawyers and Crown Attorneys utilize video-recorded interviews, closed-circuit television (CCTV), and hearsay exceptions to present the child’s evidence while shielding them from trauma.
When domestic violence occurs in a family home, children are inevitably affected, either as direct victims or as silent witnesses. If the abuse leads to criminal charges or a bitter family court battle over decision-making responsibility, the child’s account of what happened is often a critical piece of evidence. However, forcing a child to stand in an Ontario courtroom, face their abuser, and answer aggressive questions from a defence lawyer can cause immense secondary trauma.
The Ontario justice system recognizes this vulnerability. 📋 Both the criminal courts and family courts have developed specific legal mechanisms-often referred to as ‘testimonial aids’ and hearsay exceptions-to protect young people. Whether you are dealing with the Crown Attorney in a criminal prosecution or working with a family law firm in the Superior Court of Justice, there are proactive steps you can take to ensure your child’s voice is heard without subjecting them to the terror of the witness stand.
Step-by-Step Process to Protect Your Child’s Testimony
Shielding a child requires early planning and specialized legal applications. If your child witnessed or experienced domestic violence in cities like Ottawa, Kitchener, or Oshawa, this is how their evidence is typically gathered and presented.
Step 1: Utilize a Child Advocacy Centre
If the police or Children’s Aid Society (CAS) become involved, do not interrogate your child yourself. 🚨 Law enforcement will usually arrange for the child to be interviewed at a specialized Child Advocacy Centre (CAC) or by a specially trained police officer. These interviews are conducted in a child-friendly room and are video-recorded using proven, non-leading interview techniques (often referred to as the Step-Wise guidelines).
Step 2: Introduce the Video as Evidence-in-Chief
In a criminal trial, the Crown Attorney can apply to have this video recording admitted as the child’s ‘evidence in chief.’ This prevents the child from having to tell the story from scratch in the courtroom. Under Section 715.1 of the Criminal Code, video recordings of victims or witnesses under the age of 18 are routinely admitted to reduce trauma. Unlike a ‘KGB statement’ (which is used under R. v. B. (K.G.) to introduce a prior inconsistent statement when a witness changes their story), a video recording under Section 715.1 is submitted directly as the child’s primary evidence-in-chief, requiring the child only to adopt the recording as true when they take the stand.
Step 3: Apply for Testimonial Aids (Section 486)
If the child still must face cross-examination, the Crown will apply for testimonial aids under Section 486 of the Criminal Code. 🛡️ Common aids include allowing the child to testify from a separate room via closed-circuit television (CCTV) or placing a privacy screen in the courtroom so the child cannot see the accused abuser. The judge will almost always grant these protections for minors.
Step 4: Use Hearsay Exceptions in Family Court
If you are in Family Court fighting for parenting time (formerly custody), the rules are different. Children rarely testify in family proceedings. Instead, your family lawyer will rely on exceptions to the hearsay rule. They can introduce the CAS reports, the police video, or sworn affidavits from therapists and social workers detailing what the child disclosed to them, completely removing the child from the courtroom.
Step 5: Appoint the Office of the Children’s Lawyer (OCL)
In highly conflicted Ontario family law cases, a judge may involve the Office of the Children’s Lawyer. 👤 The OCL will assign an independent clinical investigator or a lawyer to represent the child’s interests. The OCL clinician will interview the child privately and submit a comprehensive report to the judge, ensuring the child’s experiences and wishes are factored in without them ever testifying.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
The cost of managing child evidence depends heavily on which court system you are navigating.
| Service / Legal Avenue | Estimated Cost in CAD |
|---|---|
| Criminal Court Testimonial Aids | $0 CAD (Paid for and managed by the Crown/Province) |
| Police / CAC Video Interviews | $0 CAD (Public service) |
| Office of the Children’s Lawyer (OCL) | Often $0 (Funded by the Ministry of the Attorney General, subject to approval) |
| Family Lawyer to Draft Hearsay Motions | $1,500 to $4,000 CAD (Depending on complexity) |
Protecting a child’s mental health during litigation is priceless, and Ontario offers many free resources for victims of domestic violence. 💰
How Long Does the Process Take?
Securing testimonial aids takes coordination. In a criminal case, the video interview happens within days of the incident. However, under Rule 2.4(1) of the Criminal Rules of the Ontario Court of Justice, pre-trial applications for testimonial aids like CCTV or screens must be heard at least 60 days before the trial starts, which means they must be filed even earlier (typically at least 30 days before the scheduled hearing of the application itself). In family court, an OCL investigation can take 3 to 6 months to complete, meaning you and your lawyer must plan well in advance of any final trial dates.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
At what age is a child forced to testify?
There is no strict age cutoff in Canada. If a child is deemed capable of understanding the concept of telling the truth, they can testify. However, courts aggressively use video links and screens for any witness under 18.
Can the abuser cross-examine my child directly?
In criminal trials involving domestic violence, Section 486.3 of the Criminal Code specifically prevents a self-represented accused from personally cross-examining a witness under 18. The court will appoint a lawyer to ask the questions instead.
Can I just tell the judge what my child said?
Generally, no. This is considered ‘hearsay’ and is highly restricted. However, in Family Court, experienced lawyers can sometimes introduce out-of-court statements from a child under the ‘principled exception’ to the hearsay rule if the statement is deemed highly reliable.
Will my child have to be in the same room as the abuser?
Almost never. Testimonial aids like closed-circuit television (CCTV) allow the child to sit in a separate, secure room in the courthouse while their testimony is broadcast into the main courtroom.
Can a support dog be used in court?
Yes! Many courthouses in Ontario now offer facility dogs (like the ones from National Service Dogs) to sit quietly with a child witness in the CCTV room to provide comfort while they testify.
Leave a Reply