In Ontario, survivors of domestic violence often face two parallel justice systems. A criminal domestic assault case (handled by the Crown) typically resolves within 12 to 18 months. In contrast, the family law case resolving spousal support, property, and decision-making responsibility for children often takes 2 to 3 years. Lawyers usually advise pausing the final family trial until the criminal matter concludes.
When police are called to a domestic violence incident, the legal fallout immediately splits into two entirely separate legal tracks. The first is the criminal justice system, where the Crown Attorney prosecutes the abuser for committing an offence against the state. The second is the family court system, where you and your family lawyer must untangle your marriage, negotiate spousal support, and determine safe parenting time for your children. Navigating both systems simultaneously is incredibly overwhelming, as they operate under different rules, different burdens of proof, and drastically different timelines.
For survivors living in Markham, Windsor, or Sudbury, understanding how these timelines interact is vital for long-term safety and financial stability. 📈 A common point of confusion is why family lawyers often hit the “pause” button on finalizing a divorce or support agreement. Generally, anything said in family court can be used by the abuser’s defence lawyer in the criminal trial. To protect the integrity of the criminal prosecution-whether it is a summary conviction or a serious indictable offence-family litigation is frequently delayed until the criminal judge delivers a final verdict.
Step-by-Step Process for Navigating Parallel Court Systems in Ontario
Managing two overlapping legal battles requires immense coordination. Your family lawyer and the Victim Witness Assistance Program (VWAP) will generally guide you through this complex timeline to ensure your safety is never compromised.
Step 1: The Incident and Immediate Criminal Charges
The timeline begins the moment police arrest the abusive partner. 🚨 In Ontario, police have a mandatory charging policy for domestic violence; if they have reasonable grounds to believe an assault occurred, they must lay charges. The accused is usually held for a bail hearing within 24 hours. The Crown Attorney will request strict bail conditions, such as a complete “no-contact” order prohibiting the abuser from communicating with you or returning to the family home.
Step 2: Securing Immediate Family Law Protections
While the criminal bail conditions keep you temporarily safe, you must simultaneously initiate your family law case. Your family lawyer will file an urgent motion in the family court for an Order for Exclusive Possession of the Matrimonial Home. This legally ensures you and your children can remain in the house without fear of the ex-partner returning. You may also secure temporary orders for child and spousal support so you can survive financially while the cases pend.
Step 3: Navigating the Criminal Court Delays
The criminal case now moves through disclosure, Crown pre-trials, and judicial pre-trials. 📄 As the victim, you are not a party to this lawsuit; you are a witness for the Crown. This process is painfully slow. Your abuser’s criminal defence lawyer may request multiple adjournments. Unless the accused pleads guilty early on, waiting for an actual trial date for a domestic assault charge can take well over a year.
Step 4: Pausing the Family Law Discovery
During the criminal delays, your family lawyer will likely advise against conducting “Questioning” (examinations for discovery) in the family law case. If you provide sworn testimony in family court regarding the abuse, the criminal defence lawyer can subpoena those transcripts. If there is even a minor inconsistency between what you said in family court and what you told the police, the defence will use it to destroy your credibility at the criminal trial. Therefore, the family case often stalls at the temporary order stage.
Step 5: Finalizing the Family Case After the Verdict
Once the criminal trial concludes-whether it results in a conviction, an acquittal, or a peace bond-the family law case can aggressively resume. 🤝 If the abuser is convicted, your family lawyer can use that criminal conviction as indisputable evidence in family court to support claims for supervised parenting time, sole decision-making responsibility, or to seek civil damages under the tort of intimate partner violence. You will then proceed to a final family trial or negotiate a final settlement.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Engaging with the justice system has varying costs depending on the court. While participating in the criminal process as a victim is free, hiring a family lawyer to secure your financial future is a significant investment.
| Legal Service | Estimated Cost (CAD) | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal Prosecution (Crown) | $0 | The state prosecutes the abuser. You do not pay for the Crown Attorney or police investigations. |
| Victim Services / VWAP | $0 | Provincial programs providing emotional support and court updates to victims are completely free. |
| Urgent Family Court Motions | $3,000 – $7,000 | Lawyer fees to secure emergency exclusive possession of the home and temporary spousal support. |
| Final Family Law Trial | $15,000 – $35,000+ | The total legal cost to resolve contested property, support, and decision-making responsibility. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Patience is absolutely essential when facing parallel legal battles. The criminal justice timeline in Ontario is governed by the *Jordan* decision, meaning a summary conviction or lower-level indictable offence tried in the Ontario Court of Justice should generally conclude within 18 months from the date the charges were laid.
The family law timeline is much longer. ⌛ Because the family case is usually put on a slow track while the criminal case plays out, resolving the divorce, finalizing spousal support, and establishing permanent parenting schedules routinely takes 24 to 36 months. However, the temporary family court orders secured in the first month will legally protect you throughout this entire waiting period.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Why do my family lawyer and the Crown Attorney not talk to each other?
The Crown Attorney represents the public interest, not you personally. They must remain objective. While they may inform your family lawyer about bail conditions, they will not strategize with your family lawyer, as doing so could compromise the fairness of the criminal trial.
Does an acquittal in criminal court mean I lose my family case?
No. Criminal courts require proof “beyond a reasonable doubt,” which is a very high bar. Family courts use the “balance of probabilities” (more likely than not). An abuser can be found not guilty criminally, but a family judge can still rule that the abuse occurred and restrict their parenting time.
What happens to child visitation if there is a criminal no-contact order?
Criminal bail conditions trump family court orders. If bail conditions state the abuser cannot be within 100 metres of you or the children, all visitation stops immediately. Eventually, the bail conditions may be amended to allow third-party supervised drop-offs, but safety always comes first.
Can I drop the criminal charges to speed up my divorce?
In Canada, victims cannot “drop” criminal charges; only the Crown Attorney has the authority to withdraw them. The Crown rarely withdraws domestic violence charges simply because it is inconvenient for a family law proceeding, as their primary mandate is public safety.
Leave a Reply