If you are convicted of shoplifting (Theft Under $5,000) in Ottawa, the criminal court fine can reach up to $2,000 CAD. However, many first-time offenders qualify for a diversion program, resulting in a $0 court fine and no criminal record. Additionally, stores often send a separate “civil recovery letter” demanding $300 to $500 CAD.
Getting caught shoplifting is a highly embarrassing and stressful event. Whether the incident occurred at the Rideau Centre, a local grocery store, or a pharmacy in Ottawa, a lapse in judgment can suddenly lead to police involvement and criminal charges. 🚨 Shoplifting falls under the Criminal Code of Canada as “Theft Under $5,000.” While it may seem like a minor issue, a criminal conviction can ruin your employment prospects and restrict your ability to travel internationally. Many people panic about the potential financial fines and wonder how to keep their record clean. In this guide, we will clarify the difference between criminal court fines and civil recovery letters, and explain how an Ottawa defence lawyer can help you protect your future.
Step-by-Step Process for Shoplifting Charges in Ottawa
If you are stopped by a Loss Prevention Officer (LPO) at a store in Ontario, the legal process will generally unfold in the following distinct stages.
Step 1: The Arrest and Police Involvement
When an LPO stops you, they will detain you in a back room and call the Ottawa Police Service. The police will formally arrest you, seize the stolen merchandise, and usually release you on an Appearance Notice. This document tells you exactly when and where you must go to the Ottawa Courthouse for fingerprinting and your first appearance.
Step 2: The Civil Recovery Letter
A few weeks after the incident, you will likely receive a letter in the mail from a law firm representing the retail store. 📬 This is called a “Civil Recovery Letter.” It will demand that you pay a sum, usually between $300 and $500 CAD, to cover the store’s security costs, even if they recovered the merchandise perfectly intact. This is a civil demand, entirely separate from your criminal court case.
Step 3: First Court Appearance and Disclosure
You or your defence lawyer will attend your first appearance at the Elgin Street courthouse. Here, you will receive the Crown’s disclosure, which includes the police report and the store’s security video footage. Your lawyer will immediately begin negotiating with the Crown Attorney to find an alternative to a criminal conviction.
Step 4: The Direct Accountability Program (Diversion)
If you are a first-time offender facing a minor shoplifting charge, your lawyer will advocate for your entry into the Direct Accountability Program (DAP). If accepted, you must complete a task, such as making a charitable donation or attending an online anti-theft workshop. Once completed, the Crown formally withdraws the criminal charge against you.
How Much Does it Cost in Ottawa?
The total cost of a shoplifting incident involves a mix of potential court fines, civil demands, and legal fees to protect your record. Here is what you can generally expect: 💲
- Criminal Court Fine: If convicted, the judge can order a fine up to $2,000 CAD. However, if your lawyer secures diversion (DAP), your court fine is exactly $0.
- Charitable Donation (Diversion): As part of a diversion deal, you may be required to make a modest donation to an Ottawa charity, usually between $50 and $200 CAD.
- Civil Recovery Letter: The store’s law firm will demand $300 to $500 CAD. Many Canadian defence lawyers advise clients to ignore this letter, as it is incredibly rare for a major retailer to actually sue an individual in Small Claims Court over $500.
- Lawyer Fees (Block Fee): Hiring an Ottawa criminal defence lawyer to handle a summary Theft Under $5,000 charge and secure a withdrawal typically costs a flat fee ranging from $1,500 to $3,500 CAD.
| Potential Cost Type | Is it Mandatory? | Estimated Cost (CAD) |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal Court Fine | Only if convicted | $0 – $2,000 |
| Diversion Charity Donation | If accepted into DAP | $50 – $200 |
| Civil Recovery Letter Demand | No (Unless successfully sued) | $300 – $500 |
| Defence Lawyer Fee | No, but highly recommended | $1,500 – $3,500 |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Fortunately, minor shoplifting charges are usually resolved relatively quickly in Ontario. If you are accepted into a diversion program, the entire process from your arrest to the final withdrawal of charges generally takes between 2 to 4 months. ⏱ However, if you have a prior record and the case must go to a full trial, it can take 9 to 12 months to resolve at the Ottawa Courthouse.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Do I legally have to pay the civil recovery letter?
A civil recovery letter is merely a demand for payment, not a court order. While you should always consult your lawyer for advice specific to your case, many defence lawyers advise clients not to pay it. Retailers rarely spend thousands of dollars in legal fees to sue someone in Small Claims Court for a $500 demand.
Will shoplifting under $5,000 give me a criminal record?
If you plead guilty or are found guilty by a judge, yes, you will receive a permanent criminal record. However, if your lawyer successfully negotiates your entry into a diversion program and the charges are withdrawn, you will not have a criminal conviction on your record.
What if I accidentally forgot to pay for an item?
Theft requires “mens rea,” meaning you must have actually intended to steal the item. If you genuinely forgot an item at the bottom of your cart, your lawyer can argue that you lacked the criminal intent, which is a strong defence against the charge.
Can I travel to the United States after a shoplifting charge?
Thefts are considered “crimes of moral turpitude” by U.S. Customs. If you are convicted, you will likely be denied entry to the United States. Even if your charges are withdrawn, border guards can see your arrest record. You should consult a lawyer about applying to destroy your police file once the case is over.
Leave a Reply