If a foreign worker is detained by the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) for a prolonged period, Canadian employers generally have the right to terminate employment. Under provincial labour laws, an indefinite detention often leads to “frustration of contract,” meaning the employer can legally end the relationship without paying standard termination pay or severance.
Employing temporary foreign workers is an excellent way for Canadian businesses to bridge critical labour shortages. Whether your company operates out of a tech hub in Vancouver, a manufacturing plant in Ontario, or the resource sectors of Alberta, managing international talent is standard practice. However, human resources departments face a unique and highly sensitive dilemma when an employee is suddenly detained by federal immigration authorities.
When an employee is placed in an Immigration Holding Centre by CBSA-usually due to an expired work permit, alleged misrepresentation, or a pending deportation order-they are physically unable to report to work. ⚠ For the employer, this creates an immediate operational void and complex legal questions regarding employment law, severance obligations, and the issuance of a Record of Employment (ROE).
Step-by-Step Process for Employers Handling Detained Staff in Canada
While immigration is entirely a federal matter handled by IRCC and CBSA, employment law is primarily provincial. You must navigate your specific provincial legislation, such as the Employment Standards Act (ESA) in Ontario or the Employment Standards Code in Alberta, alongside federal payroll rules.
Step 1: Confirming the Employee’s Detention Status
Before taking any permanent administrative action, you must verify the situation. 📞 Often, an employee’s family member or an immigration lawyer will contact HR to explain the absence. In Canada, an individual detained by CBSA is entitled to a detention review before the Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB) within 48 hours, followed by another at 7 days, and then every 30 days. You should ascertain if the employee is likely to be released quickly on a bond.
Step 2: Evaluating “Frustration of Contract”
If the IRB refuses to release the worker and they face prolonged detention or imminent deportation, you must assess the employment contract. In Canadian employment law, “frustration of contract” occurs when an unforeseen event-which is not the fault of the employer-makes it permanently impossible for the employee to fulfill their duties. Incarceration or prolonged immigration detention generally meets this legal threshold.
Step 3: Proceeding with Formal Termination
If you determine the contract is frustrated, you must officially terminate the employment relationship. 📧 Draft a clear, professional termination letter stating that the employment is ending due to frustration of contract resulting from their indefinite unavailability for work. Because the contract is frustrated, you are generally not legally required to provide common law reasonable notice or statutory severance pay under provincial laws.
Step 4: Issuing the Record of Employment (ROE)
By federal law, you must issue a Record of Employment (ROE) to Service Canada within 5 calendar days of the interruption of earnings. When filling out the ROE for a detained employee, it is crucial to use the correct code. Typically, Code E (Quit) or Code M (Dismissal/Other) is used, but you should explicitly note “Absent from work due to incarceration/detention” in the comments section. Consult with your payroll provider to ensure strict compliance.
Termination for Cause vs. Frustration of Contract
| Feature | Termination for Just Cause | Frustration of Contract (Detention) |
|---|---|---|
| Reason for Dismissal | Employee engaged in serious workplace misconduct (e.g., theft). | An outside event (CBSA detention) makes working impossible. |
| Severance / Notice Pay | None required by law. | None required by law. |
| Employer Liability Risk | High risk of wrongful dismissal lawsuit if cause is not proven. | Lower risk, provided the detention is objectively lengthy. |
How Much Does It Cost the Employer in Canada?
Dealing with a detained employee involves indirect costs rather than direct government fees, primarily centered around legal advice and operational disruptions.
- Employment Lawyer Consultation: Before declaring a contract frustrated, consulting an employment lawyer typically costs between $350 and $800 CAD for an hour of expert advice.
- Severance Savings: By correctly categorizing the separation as frustration of contract rather than a standard termination without cause, employers can save thousands of dollars in statutory notice and severance pay.
- Recruitment Costs: The true cost lies in replacing the worker. Hiring and training a new employee can cost a business anywhere from $3,000 to $10,000+ CAD.
- New LMIA Fees: If you must hire another foreign worker to replace them, a new Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA) fee via Service Canada is $1,000 CAD.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Employers cannot wait forever, but they should also avoid acting prematurely. Adhere to these general Canadian timelines. 🕑
- Initial Wait Period: It is usually best practice to wait past the initial 48-hour and 7-day IRB detention reviews before terminating, in case the employee is swiftly released on bail.
- ROE Issuance: Mandatory within 5 days of the end of the pay period in which the employee stopped working.
- Final Paycheck: Any outstanding wages, vacation pay, and overtime must typically be paid out within 7 to 14 days of termination, depending on the province.
- Deportation Execution: If the worker is ordered removed, CBSA generally executes the deportation within 3 to 6 weeks.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Do we have to hold the job open for the detained employee?
No. Unless the employee is protected under a specific collective bargaining agreement, employers in Canada have no legal obligation to hold a position open indefinitely for an employee who is incarcerated or detained by CBSA.
Can we rehire them if they are eventually released?
Yes, but it depends entirely on their immigration status upon release. If they are released on an order that still permits them to work in Canada legally, you may choose to offer them a new employment contract. Ensure their work permit is valid and not expired or cancelled.
What happens to the LMIA if the worker is deported?
Employer-specific LMIAs are tied directly to that specific foreign national. If the employee is deported, that specific work permit and LMIA authorization essentially become void. You cannot simply transfer that same LMIA to a new candidate; you must apply for a new one.
Can the employee sue us for wrongful dismissal?
Anyone can initiate a lawsuit, but a claim for wrongful dismissal in this scenario is highly unlikely to succeed. Canadian courts have consistently recognized that long-term immigration detention legally frustrates an employment contract, removing the employer’s obligation to provide notice or severance.
Leave a Reply