If your loved one died during a police interaction in Ontario, the Special Investigations Unit (SIU) launches a mandatory probe. As executor, you must secure the estate through the Superior Court of Justice while coordinating with civil litigators to preserve evidence for a potential wrongful death lawsuit under the Family Law Act.
When a family member dies as a result of an interaction with law enforcement, the emotional shock is overwhelming. In cities like Toronto, Thunder Bay, and Brampton, these high-profile tragedies trigger an immediate, mandatory investigation by a civilian oversight agency. 📍
In Ontario, this agency is the Special Investigations Unit (SIU). While the SIU investigates the criminal liability of the police officers involved, the executor of the deceased’s estate has a completely separate, heavy burden. You must simultaneously manage the traditional probate process and safeguard the family’s right to pursue civil litigation against the police department. 💼
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
Administering an estate intertwined with an SIU investigation is highly complex. Most applicants in this province rely on a dual legal strategy involving both an estate law firm and a civil litigation team. ⚔️
Step 1: Understand the SIU Mandate
The SIU is a provincial agency invoked any time police conduct results in death, serious injury, or allegations of sexual assault. The SIU operates independently of the local police. As the executor, you will have an SIU family liaison assigned to keep you updated, but you must remember that their goal is a criminal probe, not recovering financial compensation for the estate. 📜
Step 2: Obtain Probate at the Superior Court of Justice
To have the legal authority to sue on behalf of the deceased, you must be officially recognized by the courts. You will apply for a Certificate of Appointment of Estate Trustee at the Superior Court of Justice. This allows you to manage the deceased’s bank accounts, pay their final bills, and legally act as the plaintiff in a lawsuit. 📈
Step 3: Preserve Critical Evidence
Time is of the essence in police-involved deaths. Your civil litigation lawyer will immediately issue “spoliation letters” to the local police department, demanding they preserve body-cam footage, dash-cam videos, and dispatch audio. You should also secure the deceased’s personal phone and social media accounts. 💰
Step 4: Await the Coroner and SIU Reports
You cannot effectively launch a civil trial without the full facts. The estate must wait for the Chief Coroner of Ontario’s autopsy report and the final published report from the SIU Director. These documents form the evidentiary foundation for proving excessive force or negligence. 🏦
Step 5: Initiate a Civil Claim (Wrongful Death)
Under Ontario’s Family Law Act, surviving dependents can sue for loss of care, guidance, and companionship, as well as financial losses. The executor acts on behalf of the estate to file this civil lawsuit against the police board and the individual officers, seeking damages for the tragic loss of life. 📑
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Navigating an SIU-involved estate combines standard probate fees with high-stakes civil litigation costs. Here is a breakdown of what to expect in CAD: 💵
- Estate Administration Tax (EAT): You still pay $15 per $1,000 on the deceased’s personal assets over $50,000.
- Estate Law Firm Fees: Probate applications and estate administration typically cost $3,000 to $7,000 CAD.
- Civil Litigation Fees: Most wrongful death lawyers in Ontario work on a contingency fee basis (taking 25% to 33% of the final settlement), meaning the estate pays no upfront legal fees for the lawsuit.
- Expert Witnesses: In civil trials, hiring independent forensic experts or use-of-force analysts can cost $10,000 to $25,000+, usually advanced by your litigation lawyer.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Patience is absolutely critical. The SIU investigation alone routinely takes 6 to 18 months to conclude. Once the civil lawsuit is filed, navigating the Ontario court system, discovery phases, and reaching a settlement or trial verdict can take an additional 2 to 5 years. The estate remains open this entire time. ⏱️
SIU Criminal Investigation vs. Civil Lawsuit
| Feature | SIU Criminal Investigation | Estate’s Civil Lawsuit |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Goal | Determine if a criminal offence occurred. | Secure financial compensation for the family. |
| Burden of Proof | Beyond a reasonable doubt. | Balance of probabilities (easier to prove). |
| Decision Maker | SIU Director / Crown Attorney. | Judge or Jury at the Superior Court. |
| Financial Outcome | No money is awarded to the family. | Damages paid to the estate and dependents. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What happens if the SIU clears the officers of criminal charges?
You can still sue. The burden of proof in criminal court is much higher than in civil court. Many families successfully win financial settlements for negligence even after the SIU determines there are no grounds for criminal charges.
Is there a time limit to sue the police in Ontario?
Yes. The general statute of limitations in Ontario is 2 years from the date of death. You must officially file your Statement of Claim within this window, even if the SIU has not finished their report yet.
Are SIU reports released to the public?
Yes, the SIU Director’s final report is published online to maintain transparency. Your lawyer will meticulously review this report to identify inconsistencies in police testimony for the civil trial.
Can the estate sue for the cost of the funeral?
Yes. Under the Family Law Act, actual out-of-pocket expenses resulting from the wrongful death, including funeral and burial costs, are standard claims included in the civil lawsuit against the police.
Who receives the lawsuit settlement money?
Damages awarded for pain and suffering generally go directly to the surviving dependents (spouse, children, parents). Any damages awarded for the deceased’s lost wages or property damage flow into the estate to be divided according to the Will.
Leave a Reply