Terminating an employee on sick leave in Ontario is extremely risky. To avoid violating the Ontario Human Rights Code, employers must conclusively prove the dismissal is entirely unrelated to the employee’s disability, such as a genuine, widespread corporate restructuring.
One of the most dangerous intersections in Ontario employment law is where corporate operational needs meet human rights protections. When an employee takes a medically supported sick leave, their job is highly protected under both the Employment Standards Act (ESA) and the Ontario Human Rights Code. Terminating them during this vulnerable period raises an immediate “red flag” for discrimination. The burden of proof shifts heavily onto the employer to demonstrate that the medical leave played absolutely no factor in the decision to terminate.
Whether your business operates in the financial district of Toronto or manufacturing in Windsor, the rules are uniform and unforgiving. Firing a sick employee because their absence is “inconvenient” is illegal and can lead to severe financial penalties. However, if a company is legitimately closing a department or conducting a mass layoff, employees on leave are not totally immune to job loss. This guide breaks down how to navigate this perilous process legally and ethically.
Step-by-Step Process for Terminating During a Leave in Ontario
Because the legal stakes are incredibly high, you should never attempt this process without rigorous documentation and legal strategy. Most businesses immediately retain an experienced employment lawyer to assess the liability before finalizing the termination.
Step 1: Conduct a Strict Business Case Assessment
Before any termination paperwork is drafted, you must establish an ironclad business reason for the dismissal. Ask yourself: Why are we firing this person right now? If the answer is related to their absence, stop immediately. Valid reasons include the complete elimination of their specific role due to a merger, bankruptcy, or a documented, company-wide downsizing. You must compile financial records, organizational charts, and emails proving this decision was made independently of their medical status.
Step 2: Consult with an Employment Lawyer
Given the risk of human rights damages, consulting an Ontario employment lawyer is not optional; it is essential. The lawyer will review your business case to determine if an adjudicator would find it credible. They will also assess whether the company has met its duty to accommodate up to the point of “undue hardship.” If there is even a 1% chance the disability influenced the decision, a lawyer will generally advise against the termination.
Step 3: Prepare the Severance Package
If the termination is purely for restructuring, you must still provide the employee with their full entitlements. An employee on sick leave is entitled to the same notice period or severance pay as an active employee. Under common law, depending on their age, tenure, and role, this could mean providing several months of pay. Crucially, their severance must be calculated based on their regular active salary, not their reduced sick pay or long-term disability (LTD) rate.
Step 4: Deliver the Termination Compassionately
Terminating someone who is already dealing with a health crisis requires profound empathy. Arrange a virtual meeting or a phone call, depending on their medical capacity. Be direct, clear, and ensure you explain that their role is being eliminated due to broader restructuring. Follow up immediately with a written termination letter and the severance offer. Do not rush them to sign the release; give them ample time to review it with their own legal counsel.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
The financial impact of firing an employee on sick leave can be massive, especially if you handle the process incorrectly and trigger a legal dispute.
- Severance Pay: Under Ontario common law, severance can reach up to 24 months of full pay for long-tenured employees.
- Human Rights Damages: If the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario (HRTO) finds that the termination was discriminatory, they can award damages for injury to dignity, feelings, and self-respect. These awards frequently range from $15,000 to $50,000 CAD, completely separate from severance pay.
- Lost Wages Liability: The HRTO can order you to pay the employee the wages they would have earned had they not been fired, potentially spanning years.
- Legal Fees: Defending a human rights complaint and wrongful dismissal lawsuit can easily cost an employer $20,000 to $50,000 CAD in legal fees alone.
How Long Does the Process Take?
📄 The timeline heavily depends on whether the employee challenges the termination.
- Internal Preparation: Gathering the business case and consulting legal counsel usually takes 2 to 4 weeks.
- Severance Review Period: Employees should be given at least 1 to 2 weeks to review their severance offer with a lawyer.
- Litigation Timeline: If the employee files a human rights complaint or sues for wrongful dismissal, the legal process in Ontario courts or the HRTO typically takes 1.5 to 3 years to reach a resolution or settlement.
Legal Comparison: Discriminatory vs. Legitimate Termination
| Scenario | Risk of Liability | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Firing an employee because their return date is unknown | Extremely High | Direct violation of the Human Rights Code. You must accommodate to the point of undue hardship. |
| Terminating due to poor performance prior to the leave | High | Highly suspicious timing. Courts often view this as using performance as a pretext to fire a sick worker. |
| Closing the entire Ottawa branch due to financial losses | Low | A genuine operational restructuring affecting all staff equally, proving no discriminatory intent. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is “undue hardship” in Ontario?
Undue hardship is the legal limit to an employer’s duty to accommodate a disabled employee. It is a very high threshold to meet. In Ontario, adjudicators only look at three factors: the financial cost of the accommodation, outside sources of funding, and health and safety requirements. Mere inconvenience or minor financial costs do not qualify.
Can we terminate them if their doctor says they can never return to work?
In rare cases, if medical evidence conclusively proves there is no reasonable prospect of the employee ever returning to any form of accommodated work, the employment contract may be legally “frustrated.” However, asserting frustration of contract is legally complex and typically requires the employee to be absent for years. Always seek legal counsel before declaring this.
What happens to their benefits when we terminate them on leave?
You must maintain their health, dental, and life insurance benefits during the statutory notice period required by the ESA. Furthermore, if they are currently receiving Long-Term Disability (LTD) benefits from your insurer, the termination must not interfere with their ongoing approved claim.
Can we hire a permanent replacement while they are on sick leave?
Generally, you should hire a temporary contract worker to cover the absence. Hiring a permanent replacement implies you do not intend to bring the sick employee back, which can trigger a human rights complaint and constructive dismissal claims.
Leave a Reply