To get criminal charges stayed in Nova Scotia, a lawyer must convince the Crown prosecutor that there is no “realistic prospect of conviction” or that pursuing the case is not in the “public interest.” A stay pauses the prosecution indefinitely, meaning you will not face a trial or a criminal record.
Facing a criminal charge in Halifax or anywhere in Nova Scotia is a terrifying experience that can threaten your career, your family, and your freedom. However, just because the police have laid charges against you does not mean a trial is inevitable. The Nova Scotia Public Prosecution Service (PPS) holds the ultimate authority on whether a case moves forward. In many situations, an experienced lawyer can negotiate to have the charges “stayed.” 🚨
A stay of proceedings (often referred to simply as a “stay”) essentially stops the criminal process in its tracks. While it is not exactly the same as an acquittal or a withdrawal, the practical result is often identical: you walk away without a criminal conviction. In this article, we will break down the standards used by Crown counsel in Nova Scotia and explain how defence lawyers successfully advocate for stayed charges.
Step-by-Step Process in Nova Scotia
Getting charges stayed is rarely automatic. It requires strategic advocacy, a deep understanding of the Criminal Code, and careful negotiation with the local Crown prosecutors at the courthouse. 📄
Step 1: Requesting and Reviewing Disclosure
The first step in any criminal case is obtaining your disclosure. Disclosure is the complete package of evidence the police have collected against you, including officer notes, witness statements, and video surveillance. Your lawyer will meticulously review this package. To get a stay, your lawyer is actively looking for fatal flaws in the police investigation, contradictory witness statements, or a lack of essential evidence required to prove the specific indictable offence or summary conviction charge.
Step 2: Identifying Charter Breaches
One of the most common reasons the Crown stays charges is due to violations of your rights under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. For example, if the Halifax Regional Police searched your vehicle without a valid warrant (a Section 8 breach) or delayed allowing you to speak to a lawyer (a Section 10 breach), that evidence could be excluded at trial. If the evidence is excluded, the Crown’s case may collapse.
Step 3: Analyzing the Crown’s Standard of Proof
In Nova Scotia, Crown prosecutors are bound by strict guidelines. They use a two-part test to decide if they should proceed: First, is there a realistic prospect of conviction? Second, is it in the public interest to prosecute? If your lawyer can draft a compelling argument showing that the evidence is too weak to meet the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard, the Crown is ethically obligated to stay or withdraw the charges. ⚖
Step 4: Crown Pre-Trial Resolution Discussions
This is where the heavy lifting happens. Your lawyer will schedule a Crown Pre-Trial (CPT) meeting with the assigned prosecutor. During this confidential negotiation, your lawyer will point out the evidentiary weaknesses, highlight any Charter issues, or present mitigating factors about your personal background. If the prosecutor agrees that the two-part test is no longer met, they will direct a stay of proceedings on the record at your next court appearance.
How Much Does it Cost in Halifax?
The court itself does not charge you a fee to have your charges stayed. The costs associated with this process are strictly the legal fees paid to your criminal defence lawyer to negotiate on your behalf. 💰
| Legal Service | Estimated Cost (CAD) | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Consultation | $0 – $350 | Many Halifax law firms offer a free or low-cost initial meeting to assess your case. |
| Disclosure Review & CPT | $1,500 – $3,500 | Block fee for analyzing evidence and conducting early negotiations with the Crown. |
| Complex Litigation/Charter Focus | $3,500 – $10,000+ | If extensive legal briefs or expert opinions are required to convince the Crown. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
A stay of proceedings can happen at almost any stage before the judge renders a verdict, but it usually occurs during the pre-trial phases. ⌖
- Receiving Initial Disclosure: Typically takes 2 to 6 weeks after your first court appearance.
- Negotiation Phase: Crown Pre-Trial meetings usually happen within 2 to 4 months of the charges being laid.
- Final Resolution: Most stays are secured within 3 to 8 months. If the stay is granted, the case is paused immediately.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the difference between a stay of proceedings and a withdrawal?
Practically, they are very similar, as both mean you do not go to trial and do not get a criminal record. However, a withdrawal legally ends the charge permanently. A stay pauses the charge, and the Crown technically has up to one year to restart the prosecution (though reviving a stayed charge is extremely rare in Nova Scotia).
Does getting charges stayed mean I am proven innocent?
No. A stay does not mean a judge declared you innocent. It simply means the Crown has decided to halt the prosecution, usually because they cannot prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt or because it is not in the public interest to proceed.
Will a stayed charge show up on a criminal background check?
A stayed charge will not show up on a standard criminal record check because there is no conviction. However, the arrest record may still appear on a Vulnerable Sector Check. You can apply to the local police to have your fingerprints and photographs destroyed after a certain waiting period.
Can I just talk to the Crown prosecutor myself?
While self-represented accused individuals can speak to the Crown, it is highly risky. Anything you say could be used against you. It is strongly advised to hire a local lawyer who understands the nuances of the Criminal Code to negotiate a stay.
Leave a Reply