In Canada, a plea resolution (or joint submission) occurs when the defence lawyer and the Crown prosecutor agree on an appropriate sentence in exchange for a guilty plea. Judges almost always accept these joint submissions, as they are legally bound to follow them unless the proposed sentence would bring the administration of justice into disrepute (known as the Anthony-Cook standard).
Going to trial for a criminal offence is an incredibly stressful, expensive, and unpredictable experience . Whether you are facing a summary conviction for a minor assault in Nova Scotia, or a serious federal indictable offence like drug trafficking in Alberta, the risk of a harsh sentence following a guilty verdict is a heavy burden. Because the Canadian justice system is heavily backlogged, courts strongly encourage early resolutions.
A plea resolution-commonly referred to in everyday language as a “plea bargain”-is a negotiated settlement 📍. Your criminal defence lawyer and the Public Prosecution Service of Canada (PPSC) or provincial Crown work together to find a fair compromise. This might involve the Crown dropping certain charges in exchange for your guilty plea on others, resulting in a joint submission for a specific sentence. Understanding how this process works can help you make an informed decision about your future.
Step-by-Step Process for Negotiating a Plea in Canada
Plea negotiations are not like the dramatic back-room deals seen on American television. In Canada, it is a highly structured, ethical process governed by legal precedents. Here is how a joint submission comes together.
Step 1: Reviewing the Crown Disclosure
Before any negotiations begin, your lawyer must review the “disclosure” . This is the complete package of evidence the police have gathered against you, including witness statements, video footage, and toxicology reports. Your lawyer will assess the strength of the Crown’s case. If the evidence is overwhelming, negotiating a plea is often the smartest strategy to minimize your sentence.
Step 2: The Crown Pre-Trial (CPT)
Your lawyer will schedule a formal meeting with the Crown prosecutor, known as a Crown Pre-Trial (CPT) 💬. During this confidential discussion, your lawyer will point out weaknesses in the police investigation, highlight your positive background (such as your job or family support), and propose a resolution. The Crown evaluates whether taking the matter to a full trial is in the public interest, considering court resources and the likelihood of conviction.
Step 3: Crafting the Joint Submission
If an agreement is reached, both law firms craft a “joint submission” on sentencing . For example, in exchange for a guilty plea to a lesser charge, the Crown might agree to ask the judge for a conditional discharge (meaning no permanent criminal record) instead of a jail sentence. You must completely understand and consent to this agreement before moving forward.
Step 4: Entering the Guilty Plea in Court
You will appear before a judge in provincial court (such as the Ontario Court of Justice or the Provincial Court of BC) ⚠️. The judge will ask you a series of mandatory questions (a plea inquiry) to ensure you are pleading guilty voluntarily, that you understand you are giving up your right to a trial, and that you admit to the essential facts of the offence. You cannot plead guilty if you continue to claim you are innocent.
Step 5: The Judge’s Final Decision
After hearing the agreed statement of facts, both lawyers will present the joint submission for sentencing. The judge reviews the proposal to ensure it is legally sound. Under the Supreme Court of Canada ruling in R. v. Anthony-Cook, trial judges must accept a joint submission unless it is so unhinged or unreasonable that it would cause the public to lose faith in the justice system. Rejections are extremely rare.
Common Outcomes of Plea Negotiations
Plea bargaining can result in drastically different outcomes depending on the severity of the offence and your criminal history.
| Type of Resolution | What Happens | Criminal Record? |
|---|---|---|
| Peace Bond (Section 810) | You agree to keep the peace for 12 months; charges withdrawn. | No record (not a conviction). |
| Absolute/Conditional Discharge | You plead guilty, but the court discharges you (often with probation). | Temporary record (purged after 1-3 years). |
| Suspended Sentence | You plead guilty, no jail time, but complete strict probation. | Yes, permanent record. |
| Conditional Sentence (CSO) | You serve your jail sentence under house arrest in the community. | Yes, permanent record. |
How Much Does it Cost to Resolve a Case?
Resolving a case early through a joint submission is significantly cheaper than running a full trial:
- Resolution Block Fees: Many criminal defence law firms offer a flat fee for taking a case from the initial disclosure stage to a guilty plea. This usually costs between $1,500 and $5,000 CAD, depending on the complexity of the charges.
- Trial Comparison: If plea negotiations fail and you proceed to a multi-day trial, legal fees can easily skyrocket to $10,000 to $30,000+ CAD.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Plea negotiations expedite the justice system, providing closure much faster than a trial:
- Disclosure Review: Receiving and reviewing the initial evidence from police takes 4 to 8 weeks.
- CPT Negotiations: Negotiating with the Crown usually happens within 2 to 4 months of your first court appearance.
- Finalizing the Plea: Once a joint submission is agreed upon, a plea and sentencing hearing can be scheduled within a few weeks, wrapping up the entire ordeal in under 6 months.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I plead guilty just to get it over with, even if I am innocent?
No. In Canada, a judge will not accept a guilty plea if you maintain your innocence. During the plea inquiry, you must formally admit that you committed the physical act and had the necessary criminal intent.
What happens if the judge rejects the joint submission?
If a judge feels the joint submission fails the Anthony-Cook test (meaning it is entirely unfit), they must warn the lawyers and allow them to make further arguments or potentially withdraw the plea before imposing a harsher sentence.
Can I withdraw my guilty plea later if I change my mind?
Withdrawing a guilty plea after it has been entered is incredibly difficult. You must prove to an appellate court that the plea was not voluntary, that you did not understand the consequences, or that you received ineffective legal assistance.
Does a plea bargain always mean I avoid jail time?
No. For serious federal offences, a joint submission might still involve a jail sentence. However, the negotiated sentence is usually on the lower end of the spectrum compared to what you might receive if you lost at trial.
Do I have to speak during the plea hearing?
Yes. The judge will ask you directly if you understand the plea and if you agree with the facts presented by the Crown. You may also be given the opportunity to speak before sentencing, which is often a good time to express remorse.
Leave a Reply