In Canada, withdrawing a guilty plea before sentencing is incredibly difficult. You must prove to the judge that your original plea was fundamentally flawed-meaning it was uninformed, involuntary, or coerced. Hiring a new criminal defence lawyer to file a formal application is generally required to navigate this heavy legal burden.
Standing in a Canadian courtroom and pleading guilty to a criminal offence is a life-altering moment. 😞 The pressure of the justice system can be overwhelming. Sometimes, defendants panic, receive poor advice, or feel pressured into taking a plea deal just to make the nightmare stop. Later, as the sentencing date approaches, they realize they made a terrible mistake and want to take it back.
Under the federal Criminal Code of Canada, a guilty plea is treated as a final, binding admission of guilt. Whether you are facing a minor summary conviction or a serious indictable offence, the court assumes you knew what you were doing when you said “guilty.” Therefore, judges do not allow you to change your mind simply because you have “buyer’s remorse” or fear a harsh sentence. To successfully withdraw a plea in Toronto, Calgary, Winnipeg, or anywhere else in Canada, you must prove that a serious miscarriage of justice occurred during the plea process.
Step-by-Step Process in Canada
Reversing a guilty plea requires a formal legal application. 📑 Because criminal law is federal but administered provincially, the steps are generally the same whether you are in the Ontario Court of Justice, the Court of King’s Bench in Alberta, or the Provincial Court of British Columbia.
Step 1: Recognizing the Legal Grounds
You cannot simply tell the judge you changed your mind. To withdraw your plea, you must establish valid legal grounds. The three most common grounds are: your plea was not voluntary (someone threatened or coerced you), your plea was not informed (you did not understand the nature of the charges or the permanent consequences, like a criminal record or deportation), or you did not unequivocally admit to the facts presented by the Crown Prosecutor.
Step 2: Hiring a New Criminal Defence Lawyer
If you are claiming that your previous lawyer gave you terrible advice or pressured you into the plea, you cannot use that same lawyer for this application. 🤝 You must hire a new law firm. Your new lawyer will review the court transcripts and the Crown’s disclosure to determine if your previous counsel provided ineffective assistance, which is a common argument for withdrawing a plea.
Step 3: Filing the Formal Application
Your new lawyer will file a formal written application with the court to withdraw the plea. This application must be filed before the judge formally sentences you. Once a sentence is passed, the only way to reverse the plea is through a formal appeal to a higher court (like the Court of Appeal), which is an even more complicated and expensive process.
Step 4: The Evidentiary Hearing
The judge will schedule a hearing to listen to the evidence. 🗣️ You will likely have to take the stand and testify under oath about why you pleaded guilty and what you understood at the time. The Crown Prosecutor will cross-examine you. If you are claiming your previous lawyer made a mistake, that lawyer may also be called to testify, requiring you to waive your solicitor-client privilege.
Step 5: The Judge’s Decision
After hearing the evidence, the presiding judge will make a ruling. If the judge believes your plea was legally invalid, they will strike the guilty plea from the record. The case will then revert to the trial phase, and you will have to defend against the original charges. If the judge denies your application, you will proceed to a sentencing hearing based on your original guilty plea.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Fighting to withdraw a guilty plea is complex litigation, and it requires significant financial resources. 💰 While court filing fees for criminal matters are usually non-existent, professional legal fees add up quickly.
| Service / Expense | Estimated Cost (CAD) |
|---|---|
| Lawyer Retainer (New Counsel) | $3,500 to $10,000+ (To review the file and draft the application) |
| Court Transcripts | $100 to $500 (Required to review what was said during the plea) |
| Evidentiary Hearing Fees | $1,500 to $3,500 per day (Lawyer’s daily trial rate) |
| Appeal Costs (If denied) | $10,000 to $25,000+ (Taking the matter to the Court of Appeal) |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Delaying a sentencing hearing to argue this application adds significant time to your case. ⏱️ Ordering transcripts from the courthouse usually takes 3 to 6 weeks. Once your new lawyer files the application, scheduling the evidentiary hearing can take 2 to 4 months, depending on how backlogged your local courthouse is. Overall, attempting to withdraw a plea can delay the final resolution of your criminal charges by 4 to 8 months.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I withdraw my plea if I didn’t know I would be deported?
Yes, this is a valid legal argument. If you are not a Canadian citizen and your lawyer failed to inform you that a guilty plea would trigger deportation under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA), you may be able to argue that your plea was not fully informed.
What happens if I successfully withdraw my plea?
If the judge allows you to withdraw the plea, your case basically hits the reset button. The guilty plea is erased, a “not guilty” plea is entered, and your case will be scheduled for a full trial where the Crown must prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
Will Legal Aid cover a new lawyer to withdraw my plea?
If you qualify financially for provincial Legal Aid (such as Legal Aid Ontario or Legal Aid BC), they may issue a new certificate for a change of solicitor. However, Legal Aid will closely review the merits of your case before approving funding for a complex application.
Can the Crown Prosecutor use my withdrawn plea against me at trial?
No. If the judge rules that your guilty plea was legally invalid and allows you to withdraw it, the Crown Prosecutor is generally not permitted to mention that withdrawn plea to the judge or jury during your subsequent trial.
Leave a Reply