Getting bail after being sentenced to a federal penitentiary (2 years or more) is complex but possible under the Criminal Code. You must prove to a Court of Appeal judge that your appeal is not frivolous, you will surrender into custody when ordered, and your release will not harm the public interest.
Being convicted of a serious indictable offence and sentenced to a federal penitentiary is a devastating experience. In Canada, any sentence of two years or more means serving time in a federal facility, such as Collins Bay in Ontario or Bowden Institution in Alberta. If you believe the trial judge made a legal error, you have the right to appeal the conviction or the sentence. However, filing an appeal does not automatically pause your jail time. To stay out of custody while your case is reviewed, your lawyer must apply for “bail pending appeal.”
Unlike pre-trial bail, where you are presumed innocent, bail pending appeal places the burden of proof entirely on you. The trial court has already found you guilty, meaning the rules for release are exceptionally strict. 📈 Whether your case is heard by the Court of Appeal for Ontario or the Court of Appeal of Alberta, the process is heavily scrutinized. Working with an experienced Canadian criminal appellate lawyer from our catalogue is generally your best chance at securing your freedom while you fight to clear your name.
Step-by-Step Process for Bail Pending Appeal in Canada
Navigating the appellate courts requires precision and highly technical legal arguments. The process focuses on reviewing transcripts and written evidence rather than calling live witnesses.
Step 1: Filing the Notice of Appeal
Before you can ask for bail, you must officially start the appeal process. Your lawyer will file a formal Notice of Appeal with the provincial Court of Appeal. This document outlines the specific errors of law the trial judge allegedly made. You generally have a strict 30-day window from the date of sentencing to file this notice, though extensions can sometimes be granted.
Step 2: Preparing the Application and Affidavits
Once the appeal is active, your lawyer will draft the Bail Pending Appeal Application. This requires comprehensive sworn affidavits. You must submit a personal affidavit detailing your background, your ties to the community, and your promise to obey all rules. Furthermore, you will usually need affidavits from your proposed “sureties.” 👨👩👧👦 A surety is a responsible Canadian citizen (often a family member) who promises to supervise you and pledges a significant amount of money or property to the court.
Step 3: Satisfying the Three-Part Legal Test
Under Section 679 of the Criminal Code, your lawyer must convince the judge of three distinct elements. First, the appeal must not be “frivolous” (meaning it has at least some arguable merit). Second, you must prove you will surrender yourself into custody when the appeal is finished. Finally, you must demonstrate that your release is not contrary to the public interest. The Crown prosecutor will aggressively challenge this last point, especially if your initial conviction involved violence or a severe indictable offence.
Step 4: The Court of Appeal Hearing
The actual bail hearing is usually conducted before a single judge of the Court of Appeal. Unlike a jury trial, this hearing is heavily focused on legal precedents and constitutional rights. If the judge grants bail, you will be released under incredibly strict conditions. You may be placed under house arrest, required to wear an electronic GPS monitor, and ordered to surrender your passport to local police.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Appellate litigation is highly specialized and often involves significant legal fees and financial pledges.
- Lawyer Fees: Retaining an appellate lawyer for both the bail hearing and the main appeal typically ranges from $15,000 CAD to $50,000 CAD, depending on the complexity of the trial transcripts.
- Surety Pledges: Your surety does not usually pay cash upfront, but they must pledge assets (like home equity). For federal sentences, judges often require pledges between $10,000 CAD and $100,000 CAD.
- Transcript Costs: You must pay certified court reporters to produce the trial transcripts, which can cost $1,000 CAD to $5,000 CAD depending on the length of the original trial.
How Long Does the Process Take?
⏱ Time is of the essence when you are in a federal penitentiary. Preparing the bail application and securing a hearing date at the Court of Appeal generally takes 2 to 6 weeks. If bail is granted, you will be released while the main appeal is prepared. The actual appeal of your federal conviction can easily take 1 to 2 years to be heard and decided by a panel of judges.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I get bail if I was sentenced to life for murder?
It is legally possible under Section 679(3) of the Criminal Code, but it is extraordinarily rare. Because murder is the most severe indictable offence, proving that your release is not contrary to the public interest is a massive legal hurdle.
What happens if my appeal is denied later?
If the Court of Appeal ultimately dismisses your appeal, you will be given a specific date and time to surrender yourself at a designated local police station or federal institution to begin serving the remainder of your sentence.
Do I absolutely need a surety for federal bail?
In almost all cases involving a federal penitentiary sentence, the Court of Appeal will demand at least one, if not two, strong sureties to supervise you. Release on your own recognizance is highly unlikely for serious offences.
Can I travel outside of Canada while on bail pending appeal?
No. Standard bail conditions require you to remain within your specific province (e.g., Ontario or British Columbia) and surrender all travel documents. You will not be permitted to cross international borders.
Leave a Reply