A Section 31 application to the WSIAT determines if your workplace injury legally prevents you from suing an at-fault party in civil court. While there is no strict deadline to file the WSIAT application itself, you must initiate your civil lawsuit within the standard 2-year limitation period under Ontario law.
Understanding Section 31 Applications in Ontario
Getting severely injured in an accident is a life-altering experience. If your injury occurred while you were working-for example, you were driving a delivery truck in Toronto and were hit by another vehicle-you enter a highly complex intersection of personal injury law and the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act (WSIA). Under Ontario law, workers who are covered by the WSIB are often stripped of their right to sue other covered workers or employers in civil court.
This legal concept is known as the “statutory bar.” 💬 The logic is that the WSIB is a no-fault insurance system designed to replace the civil tort system for workplace accidents. If both you and the at-fault driver were in the course of employment for Schedule 1 employers, you generally cannot sue them for pain and suffering. Instead, your only recourse is claiming WSIB benefits. But what happens if it is unclear whether the other person was actually working at the time?
This is where a Section 31 application comes into play. Only the Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal (WSIAT) has the exclusive jurisdiction to decide if your civil lawsuit is blocked by the WSIA. Neither a civil court judge nor a regular WSIB adjudicator can make this final determination. Navigating the timeline between your ongoing civil lawsuit and the WSIAT process requires precision.
Step-by-Step Process for a Section 31 Application
Managing a Section 31 application is rarely something a worker does alone. Whether your accident happened in Mississauga, Ottawa, or Sudbury, a local personal injury law firm generally guides you through these concurrent legal steps.
Step 1: Issue the Statement of Claim (Civil Lawsuit)
Your absolute first priority is protecting your right to sue under the Limitations Act. You generally have exactly two years from the date of the accident to file your Statement of Claim in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. You must formally start the lawsuit, even if you suspect the defendant might eventually raise a WSIB defence. Missing this 2-year window destroys your civil case entirely.
Step 2: The Defendant Pleads the WSIA Defence
Once you serve the lawsuit, the defendant’s insurance company will investigate. 🔍 If they discover that both parties were working at the time of the crash, they will file a Statement of Defence specifically pleading that your lawsuit is “statute-barred” under the WSIA. This is the trigger that signals a Section 31 application is necessary to resolve the dispute.
Step 3: Pause the Civil Action and Apply to WSIAT
After the defence is raised, your lawyer will typically agree to pause (stay) the civil court proceedings. You or the defendant must then file a formal Section 31 application directly with the WSIAT. The application requires extensive documentation, including police reports, employment records, and discovery transcripts, to prove whether the at-fault party was genuinely in the “course of employment.”.
Step 4: Attend the WSIAT Hearing
The WSIAT will eventually schedule a hearing, often held via video conference. 💻 An impartial Vice-Chair will review the evidence, listen to witness testimony, and issue a written decision. If the Tribunal rules the lawsuit is barred, your civil case is dismissed, and you must proceed solely through WSIB. If they rule it is not barred, you return to the Superior Court to continue your lawsuit.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Fighting a Section 31 application involves specific legal expenses, usually tied into your broader personal injury claim:
- WSIAT Filing Fees: $0 CAD. The Tribunal does not charge application fees for a Section 31 hearing.
- Civil Court Fees: Filing a Statement of Claim in Ontario currently costs about $229 CAD in court fees.
- Lawyer Fees: Most Ontario personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis. You pay no upfront costs, and the law firm takes a percentage (usually 25% to 33%) of your final civil settlement. The work required for the WSIAT hearing is generally absorbed into this agreement.
- Cost Awards: Unlike civil court, the WSIAT rarely awards legal costs to the winning party. You will not usually have to pay the defendant’s legal bills if you lose at the Tribunal.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The timeline for a Section 31 application requires significant patience. It is important to remember that this process happens in the middle of a civil lawsuit, effectively putting your claim for damages on hold for a substantial period.
Once the application is fully submitted with all supporting transcripts and evidence, the WSIAT is currently experiencing significant backlogs. 🕙 It generally takes between 12 to 18 months just to get a scheduled hearing date. After the hearing concludes, you can expect to wait an additional 3 to 6 months for the Vice-Chair to release their written decision. In total, a Section 31 detour can easily add 2 years to your civil litigation timeline.
Understanding the Statutory Bar (Schedule 1 vs. Schedule 2)
| Scenario (Who was working?) | Right to Sue (Civil Lawsuit) | WSIB Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Schedule 1 Worker vs. Schedule 1 Worker | Lawsuit is completely barred. | Only WSIB benefits available. |
| Schedule 1 Worker vs. Schedule 2 Worker | Generally, you can sue. | Can elect WSIB or Civil Lawsuit. |
| Worker vs. Unemployed Driver | Yes, you can sue. | Can elect WSIB or Civil Lawsuit. |
| Worker commuting to work vs. Anyone | Yes (commuting is usually not “working”). | Not covered by WSIB. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I receive WSIB benefits while waiting for the WSIAT decision?
Yes, in many cases. If you initially filed a WSIB claim because you were clearly working, you can generally continue to receive medical and wage loss benefits while the WSIAT determines if you can also sue the third party. If you are later allowed to sue and win a settlement, you must repay the WSIB for the benefits they advanced to you.
What happens to my civil lawsuit if the WSIAT rules I cannot sue?
If the WSIAT determines that your civil claim is completely statute-barred under the WSIA, your civil lawsuit is effectively dead. You or your lawyer will be required to formally dismiss the action in the Superior Court of Justice, and your only source of compensation will be the WSIB system.
Do I need a lawyer for a Section 31 application?
It is incredibly risky to handle a Section 31 application without a lawyer. The legal arguments involve complex interpretations of employment status, independent contractor tests, and historical Tribunal case law. A skilled personal injury law firm is vital to protect your right to a potentially large civil settlement.
Is there a strict deadline to file the Section 31 application?
Unlike a standard WSIB appeal, which has a rigid 6-month deadline, there is no hard statutory deadline to bring a Section 31 application to the Tribunal. However, it must be brought before your civil lawsuit goes to trial, and deliberate, unreasonable delays may be penalized by civil court judges.
Can the WSIAT decision be appealed to a regular court?
Decisions made by the WSIAT are final and binding. You cannot simply appeal their decision to the Ontario Court of Appeal. The only way to challenge a WSIAT ruling is through a Judicial Review in the Divisional Court, where you must prove the Tribunal’s decision was legally unreasonable or breached procedural fairness.
Leave a Reply