In Ontario non-profits, offering a stipend, significant honorarium, or regular perks can transform a true ‘volunteer’ into an insurable ‘worker’ in the eyes of the WSIB. If an individual provides services in exchange for meaningful compensation, your organization is legally required to pay WSIB premiums for them.
Charities and non-profit organizations in Ontario rely heavily on the goodwill of their communities. 💙 Whether it is running a food bank in Toronto, organizing a community festival in Ottawa, or managing an animal shelter in London, volunteers are the lifeblood of these operations. However, many non-profits try to show their appreciation by offering small stipends or honorariums to their helpers.
This well-intentioned generosity can create a massive legal headache. ⚠️ The Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (WSIB) has very strict rules about who qualifies as a volunteer. If the WSIB determines that your “volunteers” are actually “workers” because of the compensation they receive, your non-profit could face steep retroactive premium bills and fines. Let us look at the exact legal test WSIB uses to tell the difference.
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
For non-profit directors and managers, understanding the line between a volunteer and an employee is crucial for compliance. 🏢 You must assess the relationship carefully before handing out any form of compensation. Here are the steps WSIB takes to evaluate the status of your personnel.
Step 1: Evaluating the Purpose of the Relationship
The first thing WSIB looks at is the core intention of the arrangement. 🔍 A true volunteer offers their time and energy purely out of civic duty, charity, or personal interest, without any expectation of financial reward. If the person only shows up because they know they will receive a cheque at the end of the month, they are likely a worker.
Step 2: Scrutinizing the Compensation Structure
This is the biggest trap for non-profits. 💰 WSIB closely examines any stipends, honorariums, or perks. Providing a free lunch or a $20 gas card to cover immediate expenses is usually fine. However, if you provide a flat $500 monthly stipend, or pay them an hourly rate (even below minimum wage), WSIB will classify them as a worker.
Step 3: Checking for a Contract of Service
WSIB will review any paperwork signed between the organization and the individual. 📝 If your onboarding documents mandate specific working hours, set out disciplinary procedures, or use words like “employment,” “wages,” or “termination,” WSIB will use this as evidence of an employer-worker relationship. Keep volunteer agreements simple and focused on community service.
Step 4: Assessing the Level of Control
The degree of control you exert matters. 👷 Volunteers generally have more flexibility to come and go, choose their tasks, or decline shifts. If you mandate that the individual must be at a specific desk from 9 AM to 5 PM every Tuesday, and reprimand them if they are late, they look much more like an employee under Ontario law.
Step 5: Applying for Optional Volunteer Coverage
If you determine your people are true volunteers, they do not automatically get WSIB protection if they get hurt. 👤⚕️ However, non-profits can proactively apply to WSIB for optional volunteer coverage. This protects the volunteer if they break an arm setting up an event, and it protects the charity from being sued in civil court.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Budgeting for WSIB is a major concern for cash-strapped non-profits. 💳 Knowing who needs coverage determines your yearly overhead. Here are the general costs associated with workers and volunteers in the non-profit sector:
| True Volunteers | $0 CAD (No mandatory WSIB premiums required). |
| Optional Volunteer Coverage | Premium is usually based on a nominal assigned earnings amount (e.g., minimum wage). |
| Classified Workers | Standard WSIB premiums must be paid per $100 of their insurable earnings. |
| Legal Audit Defence | $2,000 – $5,000+ CAD if an employment law firm is needed to fight a misclassification. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Setting up your WSIB account correctly from the start takes about 2 to 4 weeks. ⏱️ If you apply for optional volunteer coverage, the approval process is generally quite fast. However, if a volunteer is injured and WSIB launches an audit to determine if they were actually a secret “worker,” the investigation can easily take 3 to 6 months.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Are non-profit board members considered workers?
Generally, unpaid volunteer members of a Board of Directors are not considered workers under the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act. However, if they receive substantial compensation for their duties, their status could change.
Can we give volunteers gift cards at Christmas?
Yes, small, irregular tokens of appreciation, like a $50 coffee gift card during the holidays, are widely accepted and will not usually transform a volunteer into a worker. The problem arises with regular, expected cash-like payments.
What happens if an uninsured volunteer gets hurt?
If a true volunteer is injured and you do not have optional WSIB coverage, they cannot claim WSIB benefits. Instead, they could potentially file a civil lawsuit against the non-profit for negligence to cover their medical bills.
Does paying for a volunteer’s training make them a worker?
Usually, no. Covering the cost of a CPR course or specific safety training required for their volunteer role is considered a necessary expense, not personal compensation or wages.
Can CRA definitions help with WSIB classification?
While the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has its own rules for taxable benefits, WSIB uses its own distinct legal test. However, if CRA determines your stipend is taxable employment income, WSIB will almost certainly classify the person as a worker.
Leave a Reply