In an Ontario parking lot slip and fall claim, liability is often shared between the commercial property owner and their hired snow removal contractor. To successfully sue, you must serve written notice of a snow or ice-related fall within 60 days, and prove that the parties failed to meet reasonable winter maintenance standards.
Winter weather in Vaughan can be notoriously brutal, frequently turning commercial parking lots into sheets of dangerous black ice. Whether you are running errands at a local plaza or arriving for work at an industrial park, slipping and falling on untreated ice can result in severe fractures, concussions, or spinal injuries. When this happens, injured individuals often wonder who is truly responsible for their medical bills and lost wages. Under the Ontario Occupiers’ Liability Act, the responsibility to keep a parking lot reasonably safe typically falls on the “occupier”-which can mean the property owner, the property management company, and even the contracted snow removal service.
A parking lot slip and fall claim is rarely straightforward. Because commercial landlords almost always outsource winter maintenance to independent snow removal contractors, these two entities will frequently point the finger at one another to avoid paying your claim. The landlord will claim the contractor failed to show up, while the contractor will argue the landlord refused to pay for extra road salt. Navigating this web of commercial contracts and insurance policies requires the expertise of a seasoned personal injury law firm to ensure all responsible parties are held accountable.
Step-by-Step Process for Parking Lot Claims in Vaughan
Filing a successful lawsuit for a winter-related fall involves strict procedural hurdles. Failing to identify the correct defendants or missing a deadline can result in your case being thrown out of the Superior Court of Justice.
Step 1: Identify All Potential Defendants
Your lawyer will conduct a corporate search to determine exactly who owns the parking lot where you fell. They will then request a copy of the winter maintenance log and the specific contract between the landlord and the snowplow operator. This contract dictates the “trigger depth” (e.g., the contractor must plow when snow reaches 2 inches) and whose job it is to apply salt to icy patches.
Step 2: Serve the Mandatory 60-Day Notice
In Ontario, you are legally required to send formal written notice of your injury via registered mail to the property owner and the independent contractor within exactly 60 days of the incident if it involved snow or ice. This notice must include the date, time, and precise location of the fall. If you miss this deadline without an exceptional excuse (like being in a coma), your claim will likely be barred.
Step 3: Review Maintenance Logs and Weather Data
To prove negligence, your legal team will gather historical weather data from Environment Canada for the Vaughan area on the day you fell. They will compare this data to the contractor’s logbooks. If it was freezing rain for six hours but the logbook shows no salt was applied, this is strong evidence of a breach of their duty of care.
Step 4: Issue the Statement of Claim
Once the evidence is compiled and your medical prognosis is clear, your law firm will officially file a Statement of Claim. In most parking lot scenarios, both the property owner and the snow removal company will be listed as co-defendants. Their respective insurance companies will then take over the defence and begin settlement negotiations.
Who Pays and How Much Does it Cost?
Understanding the division of responsibility helps clarify how settlements are eventually paid out.
| Responsible Party | Typical Liability Role | Insurance Coverage |
|---|---|---|
| Property Owner / Landlord | Must ensure overall safety; inspect premises regularly; hire competent contractors. | Commercial General Liability Policy (Usually high limits). |
| Snow Removal Contractor | Must plow and salt according to contract terms and industry standards. | Contractor’s Liability Policy (May be capped or highly restricted). |
| The Injured Person (You) | Must wear appropriate winter footwear and keep a proper lookout (Contributory Negligence). | Pays via out-of-pocket or receives final settlement minus lawyer contingency fees. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
After the initial 60-day notice is served, the actual litigation process can be quite lengthy. You have a two-year limitation period to formally file the lawsuit. Once filed, the discovery phase-where both sides exchange documents and question witnesses under oath-can take 12 to 18 months. A typical parking lot slip and fall claim in Vaughan will reach a negotiated settlement or proceed to trial within 2 to 4 years.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I sue if I was wearing running shoes in the snow?
Yes, you can still sue, but the defence will likely raise the issue of contributory negligence. If the court finds that your choice of footwear contributed to your fall, your total compensation may be reduced by a certain percentage (e.g., 20% to 30%).
Does it matter if the parking lot was free to use?
No. Under the Occupiers’ Liability Act, the duty of care applies regardless of whether you paid for parking or it was a free lot outside a grocery store. The owner still has a legal obligation to keep the premises reasonably safe for lawful visitors.
What happens if the snow was actively falling when I slipped?
This can make the claim more difficult. Ontario courts recognize that property owners cannot realistically keep a lot perfectly clear during an active blizzard. However, if there was pre-existing ice under the fresh snow that should have been salted days earlier, you still have a strong case.
What if I cannot figure out who owns the parking lot?
This is a common issue with large commercial plazas. Your lawyer can perform a specialized land title search through the Ontario land registry system to identify the exact corporate entity that holds the deed to the property.
Will my case definitely go to a trial?
Generally, no. The vast majority of personal injury cases in Ontario are settled out of court through mediation or direct negotiation. Trials are incredibly expensive and unpredictable, so insurance companies usually prefer to offer a fair settlement once the evidence is strong.
Leave a Reply