If convicted of Theft Under $5,000 in Ontario, criminal fines can reach up to $2,000 CAD, but first-time offenders are often eligible for diversion programs to avoid a criminal record. Additionally, stores at Square One frequently send “civil recovery letters” demanding you pay $300 to $500, which is entirely separate from the criminal charge.
A momentary lapse in judgment at a shopping centre like Square One or Erin Mills Town Centre can turn into a terrifying legal ordeal. 👮 Being stopped by loss prevention officers and arrested by the Peel Regional Police for shoplifting introduces you to two entirely different legal problems: the criminal justice system and civil demands for money.
Understanding the difference between a criminal fine and a civil recovery letter is crucial to protecting your future and your finances. ⚖ A conviction for “Theft Under $5,000” under the Criminal Code of Canada can leave you with a permanent criminal record, severely impacting your employment and travel prospects. Fortunately, there are established ways to defend yourself.
Step-by-Step Process in Mississauga
If you are accused of shoplifting, you will face a standardized process. Knowing what happens next can help reduce your anxiety and prepare you to take the right steps.
Step 1: The Arrest and Release
When store security stops you, they will usually call the Peel Regional Police. 📝 For minor theft, the police generally will not hold you in jail. Instead, they will issue you a Form 10 (Promise to Appear) with a date for fingerprinting at a local police division and a court date at the Brampton courthouse.
Step 2: Receiving a Civil Recovery Letter
A few weeks after the incident, you may receive a threatening letter from a private law firm representing the retail store. 📩 This letter typically demands between $300 and $500 CAD for “security costs” and “administrative fees.” It is important to know that this is a civil demand, not a criminal fine issued by a judge.
Step 3: Attending Court and Seeking Diversion
Your lawyer will attend the A. Grenville and William Davis Courthouse in Brampton to review the Crown’s evidence (disclosure). 🤝 For first-time offenders facing minor shoplifting charges, a lawyer will often negotiate for the Direct Accountability Program (DAP). If you complete this diversion program (such as doing community service or making a small charitable donation), the criminal charges are entirely withdrawn.
How Much Does it Cost in Mississauga?
The total cost of a shoplifting incident goes beyond the value of the items taken. 💵 Between potential criminal fines, civil demands, and legal representation, the expenses can add up. Here is a breakdown of what you might face:
| Potential Expense | Estimated Cost (CAD) | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal Fine (If Convicted) | $0 – $2,000 | Imposed by a judge if you are found guilty of Theft Under $5,000 (a summary conviction). |
| Civil Recovery Letter | $300 – $500 | A private demand from the store. Most criminal lawyers advise clients not to pay this without legal advice. |
| Lawyer Block Fee | $1,500 – $3,500 | The cost to hire a criminal defence lawyer to negotiate diversion and protect your criminal record. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
If your case qualifies for diversion (DAP), the matter can often be resolved within 3 to 6 months. ⏱ If the Crown prosecutor refuses diversion and the case proceeds to a full trial at the Brampton courthouse, it can take 12 to 18 months to reach a final resolution.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Do I have to pay the civil recovery letter from the store?
A civil recovery letter is simply a demand for payment, not a court order. Stores rarely sue individuals for $500 in Small Claims Court because the legal fees cost more than the recovery. Many criminal lawyers advise their clients to ignore these letters, but you should always seek formal legal counsel first.
Will shoplifting give me a permanent criminal record?
If you are convicted or plead guilty without a discharge, yes, you will get a criminal record. However, if your lawyer secures a withdrawal through diversion, or if you are granted an absolute or conditional discharge, you will avoid a permanent criminal conviction.
Can store security guards physically detain me?
Under the Criminal Code of Canada, a security guard or store employee can make a “citizen’s arrest” if they actually witness you committing a criminal offence on their property. They may use reasonable force to detain you until the Peel Regional Police arrive.
What happens if I accidentally forgot to pay for an item?
Theft requires “intent.” If you truly forgot an item in the bottom of your cart, you lacked the intent to steal (mens rea). An experienced lawyer can argue that it was an honest mistake, which is a valid legal defence in Canada.
Leave a Reply