Scheduling a Crown Pre-Trial (CPT) meeting for theft charges at the Newmarket Courthouse usually takes two to four months after your arrest. During this confidential meeting, your criminal defence lawyer will negotiate with the Crown Attorney to have your charges reduced, withdrawn, or diverted.
Being charged with theft, such as shoplifting at Markville Mall or stealing from an employer, is a deeply stressful experience. Many people assume they will immediately have to stand in front of a judge to explain themselves. However, the Canadian criminal justice system is heavily focused on resolving matters outside of a formal trial. A trial is viewed as a last resort.
To avoid a trial, your criminal defence lawyer will request a resolution meeting, formally known in Ontario as a Crown Pre-Trial (CPT). This is a private, strategic negotiation between your lawyer and the Crown Attorney. Understanding the timeline and the exact steps leading up to this critical meeting can help alleviate the anxiety of an unknown future.
Step-by-Step Process for a Crown Pre-Trial in Newmarket
Because Markham does not have a criminal courthouse, your matter will be heard at the Ontario Court of Justice in Newmarket. Securing a resolution meeting involves a strict sequence of administrative steps.
Step 1: Your First Court Appearance
Your very first court date is not a trial; it is purely administrative. You or your lawyer will attend the Newmarket Courthouse simply to ask for the police evidence. This evidence package is called “disclosure.” The Crown will not negotiate your theft charge on this first day because your lawyer needs time to read and analyze the York Regional Police reports.
Step 2: Reviewing the Police Disclosure
Once disclosure is received, your defence lawyer will scrutinize it for weaknesses. Did the store security guard violate your Charter rights during the arrest? Is the video surveillance too blurry to clearly identify you? Your lawyer will prepare a robust defence strategy based on these findings before ever speaking to the prosecutor.
Step 3: Scheduling the Crown Pre-Trial (CPT)
After reviewing the evidence, your lawyer will formally request a CPT. Due to the heavy caseload at the Newmarket Courthouse, it can take several weeks for the Crown’s office to assign a prosecutor and find an available date for this meeting. You do not attend this meeting; it is strictly between the legal professionals.
Step 4: Negotiating the Resolution
During the CPT, your lawyer will present mitigating factors, such as your lack of a prior criminal record or the fact that the stolen item was of very low value. They will advocate for a positive outcome, such as the Direct Accountability Program (DAP) or a peace bond. If the Crown agrees, the theft charges are effectively withdrawn once you complete the agreed-upon conditions.
How Much Does Legal Representation Cost for a CPT?
Hiring a criminal defence lawyer is highly recommended for theft charges, as a conviction results in a permanent criminal record that severely impacts employment. Most lawyers charge predictable block fees for the pre-trial phase.
| Service Phase | Description | Estimated Cost (CAD) |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Consultation | Reviewing your charges and establishing a legal strategy. | Free to $300 |
| Pre-Trial Block Fee | Covers obtaining disclosure, multiple court appearances, and conducting the CPT. | $1,500 to $3,500+ |
| Trial Block Fee | Only charged if negotiations fail and you decide to fight the case in a formal trial. | $3,000 to $7,000+ |
A successful resolution at the CPT stage saves you the enormous cost and emotional toll of a full trial. 💰
How Long Does the Overall Process Take?
From the date of your arrest in Markham, it typically takes 4 to 8 weeks just to receive the complete disclosure from the York Regional Police. After that, scheduling the Crown Pre-Trial takes another 4 to 8 weeks. If an agreement is reached, such as making a charitable donation or paying restitution to the store, you are usually given 1 to 3 months to complete the tasks. Overall, you can expect the entire pre-trial resolution process to last between 4 and 7 months.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I speak directly to the Crown Attorney myself?
If you are unrepresented, you can request an early resolution meeting with the Crown. However, anything you say can be used against you. It is highly advisable to have a defence lawyer negotiate on your behalf to protect your legal rights.
What happens if the Crown refuses to drop the theft charges?
If the Crown Attorney is unwilling to offer a withdrawal or a diversion program, your lawyer will likely schedule a Judicial Pre-Trial (JPT) to involve a judge in the negotiations, or you will have to set a date for a trial.
Will the store owner be at the Crown Resolution meeting?
No. In Canada, criminal charges are prosecuted by the state, not the victim. The store owner or security guard does not attend the CPT, and they do not have the legal authority to simply “drop the charges.”
Is an offer made at a CPT a guilty plea?
Not always. If the Crown offers diversion (like the Direct Accountability Program), you are accepting responsibility, but you are not pleading guilty. Once completed, the charges are withdrawn, leaving you without a criminal conviction.
Leave a Reply