Refusing to sign a Peace Bond after an Ontario judge orders you to do so is a severe legal mistake. Under Section 810 of the Criminal Code, refusing to enter into this recognizance allows the judge to sentence you to up to 12 months in jail immediately.
Being served with an application for a Peace Bond in Ontario can be an infuriating and stressful experience. Whether the application stems from a bitter neighbourhood dispute in Mississauga, escalating workplace harassment in Hamilton, or a highly contested family breakdown, you might feel that the allegations against you are entirely false. Many individuals, driven by principle and a sense of innocence, walk into the Ontario Court of Justice determined to fight the claims and flatly refuse to sign any document that limits their freedom.
While you have every right to defend yourself during the hearing, your options change drastically once the judge makes their final decision. ⚠ A Peace Bond is not a request; it is a court-ordered recognizance requiring you to keep the peace and be of good behaviour. It is a preventative measure, not an admission of guilt. If the judge reviews the evidence and officially orders you to sign it, refusing to put your pen to paper triggers immediate, harsh penalties under Canadian criminal law. In this guide, we will explore the step-by-step hearing process, why judges order these bonds, and the severe consequences of defiance.
Step-by-Step Process of a Peace Bond Hearing in Ontario
Navigating the Ontario Court of Justice requires an understanding of criminal procedures. A Peace Bond (governed by Section 810 of the Criminal Code) is unique because it is often used when a full criminal offence cannot be proven, but someone still has a reasonable fear for their safety.
Step 1: Receiving the Summons and Appearing in Court
The process begins when you are served with a summons to appear in criminal court. 📬 At your first appearance, you will be asked if you are willing to enter into the Peace Bond voluntarily. Many defence lawyers advise clients to agree to the bond at this stage to avoid a trial, as voluntarily signing it means you do not admit any wrongdoing and you avoid a criminal record.
Step 2: Proceeding to the Show Cause Hearing
If you refuse to sign voluntarily, the matter is set down for a hearing. The applicant (often represented by the Crown Attorney if police were involved) must present evidence to prove they have “reasonable grounds” to fear you will cause personal injury to them, their spouse, their child, or damage their property. You and your law firm will have the opportunity to cross-examine their witnesses and present your own defence.
Step 3: The Judge’s Final Determination
After hearing all the evidence, the judge or Justice of the Peace will make a ruling. 🔍 If they find the applicant’s fear is unjustified, the application is dismissed, and you walk away. However, if the judge believes the fear is reasonable, they will formally order you to enter into the recognizance (the Peace Bond) for a period of up to 12 months, complete with specific conditions like a no-contact order.
Step 4: The Consequence of Refusing the Judge’s Order
This is the critical moment. If the judge orders the bond and you look at the bench and say, “I refuse to sign,” you are in direct violation of the Criminal Code. The law is explicit: the presiding justice may immediately commit you to a provincial jail (such as the Central East Correctional Centre) for a term not exceeding 12 months. You will remain incarcerated until you agree to sign the bond or until your sentence expires.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
The financial aspect of a Peace Bond is often misunderstood. The bond itself is a financial pledge, but fighting it in court can be extremely costly. 💵
| Expense / Requirement | Estimated Cost (CAD) | Details |
|---|---|---|
| The Recognizance Pledge | $0 Upfront (Pledge $500+) | You do not pay to sign. You only pay the pledged amount if you breach the conditions. |
| Hiring a Criminal Defence Lawyer | $3,000 – $8,000+ | Cost to have a law firm represent you during a contested Peace Bond hearing. |
| Bail / Release if Arrested | Variable | If you were initially arrested for harassment, bail conditions may require sureties. |
| Loss of Income | Severe | Refusing to sign and going to jail will immediately impact your employment. |
It is vastly more economical to hire proper legal representation to fight the bond on its merits during the hearing, rather than attempting to defy the judge after the ruling has been made.
How Long Does the Process Take?
If you are fighting the application, getting a trial date at backlogged Ontario courts can take 3 to 8 months. ⏰ However, the consequence of refusing to sign is instantaneous. If the judge makes the order today and you refuse, you will be taken into custody from the courtroom that exact same day. The Peace Bond itself, once signed, remains active for a maximum of 12 months before it automatically expires.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does signing a Peace Bond mean I admit I did something wrong?
No. A Peace Bond is a preventative court order, not a criminal conviction. Signing it simply means you agree to abide by the judge’s conditions (like staying away from the person) and keep the peace. It is not an admission of civil or criminal liability.
Will a Peace Bond show up on a criminal background check?
It will not result in a criminal record. However, while the 12-month bond is active, it will typically show up on a Vulnerable Sector Check or enhanced police record checks. Once it expires, it is generally removed from these standard checks.
What happens if I sign it, but then accidentally break a condition?
Breaching a Peace Bond is a severe criminal offence (either a summary conviction or an indictable offence). If you accidentally run into the person at a grocery store, you must leave immediately. If you intentionally violate the terms, you face arrest, jail time, and a permanent criminal record.
Can I appeal a Peace Bond if I think the judge was wrong?
Yes. If you believe the judge made a legal error, you can appeal the decision. However, your lawyer will advise you to sign the bond first to avoid jail time, and then file the appeal afterward.
Will this affect my ability to cross the border into the USA?
It might. US Customs and Border Protection have broad access to Canadian police databases (CPIC). Even though a Peace Bond is not a conviction, border agents can see the active court order and may question you or deny entry at their discretion.
Leave a Reply