If you are fired in Ontario, you generally have a legal duty to seek comparable employment to mitigate your common law notice damages. Under the 2026 Williamson precedent, your employer cannot reduce your payout unless they prove both that you failed to make reasonable efforts and that comparable vacancies actually existed in the market. Crucially, your ESA statutory minimums are completely exempt from mitigation and can never be reduced.
Understanding the Duty to Mitigate in Ontario
Losing your job is an incredibly emotional experience, and facing unexpected job loss can feel overwhelming during such a difficult time. However, employment law in Ontario generally expects you to actively look for a new job while you are resolving your wrongful dismissal dispute with your former employer. 💼
This critical legal requirement is known as the duty to mitigate your damages in Ontario. In simple terms, the law dictates that you cannot just sit back, do nothing, and wait for a massive settlement cheque to arrive. You must make reasonable, continuous, and documented efforts to replace your lost income. However, it is essential to distinguish between your statutory minimums under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) and your additional common law reasonable notice. Pursuant to the Ontario Court of Appeal’s ruling in Brake v. PJ-M2R Restaurant Inc., 2017 ONCA 402, your ESA minimums (up to 8 weeks’ termination pay and up to 26 weeks’ severance pay) are statutory entitlements, not damages. Therefore, they are strictly exempt from the duty to mitigate and can never be reduced, regardless of whether you search for work or secure a new job.
The duty to mitigate applies strictly to your common law severance claims. However, the burden of proving you failed to mitigate is highly demanding for your former employer. Under the landmark Court of Appeal for Ontario decision in Williamson v. Brandt Tractor Inc., 2026 ONCA 272, the employer bears a strict two-part burden of proof: they must prove both that you failed to make reasonable efforts to search for work, and that comparable work was actually available on the market that you likely would have secured. If the employer fails to prove that actual comparable positions existed, the court cannot reduce your common law notice period damages, even if you did not search for work at all. 📈
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
When you are terminated, the clock starts ticking immediately on your duty to mitigate. Here are the general steps most legal professionals suggest you follow to protect your legal rights and maximize your chances of a fair settlement in Ontario. 📋
Step 1: Understand What “Comparable Employment” Means
You are not legally expected to apply for just any available job. The primary goal is to find comparable employment, which means a position with a similar salary, job title, level of responsibility, working conditions, and professional status. For instance, if you were a specialized IT director in Ottawa, you generally do not have to accept an entry-level technical support job just to earn a paycheque.
Step 2: Start Keeping a Detailed Job Search Diary
This is arguably the most critical step in the entire mitigation process. You must document every single effort you make to find work to prove your case later. Create a spreadsheet or dedicate a specific notebook for this purpose. You should record the date you applied, the name of the company, the specific job title, the method of application, and the final outcome. Always keep copies of all emails, cover letters, and formal rejection notices in a safe, backed-up location. 📒
Step 3: Utilize Networking and Recruiting Agencies
Simply clicking “apply” on online job boards is often not enough to satisfy the courts that you are making a full effort. It is highly recommended to reach out to professional contacts, update your LinkedIn profile, and register with local recruitment agencies in your specific Ontario city or region. Keep a written record of every recruiter you speak with, the networking events you attend, and the informational interviews you conduct.
Step 4: Apply for Employment Insurance (EI)
Filing for Employment Insurance (EI) through Service Canada is an excellent way to support yourself financially while you look for your next role. Furthermore, since Service Canada requires you to regularly report your job search efforts to continue receiving your bi-weekly payments, this serves as official, additional proof that you are actively trying to mitigate your damages. 💰
Step 5: Track Your Mitigation Expenses
Looking for a job can cost money, and the law recognizes this reality. Keep all your receipts for expenses directly related to your job search. This can include costs for a professional resume writer, upgrading your LinkedIn to a Premium account, travel expenses for interviews, or taking a short course to update your skills. In many Ontario wrongful dismissal claims, these mitigation expenses can be claimed back from your former employer.
Step 6: File Your Claim at the Local Court
If your employer absolutely refuses to offer a fair severance package despite your best negotiation efforts, you may need to escalate the matter legally. For claims valued under $50,000, you will generally file your claim at your local Small Claims Court. For severance amounts above this threshold, you must file at the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. For example, if you live in the Greater Toronto Area, you might file at the main civil courthouse located at 393 University Avenue, Toronto, but you should always verify the correct jurisdiction and find the courthouse closest to your municipality.
Comparing Job Search Efforts
Judges carefully review how an employee searches for work after being let go. Here is a general comparison of what is considered acceptable versus unacceptable when trying to mitigate your damages in Ontario. 🔍
| Feature | Good Mitigation Efforts | Poor Mitigation Efforts |
|---|---|---|
| Job Type Targeted | Applying for similar, comparable roles in your specific industry | Applying for random roles you are completely unqualified for |
| Record Keeping | Maintaining a daily spreadsheet and saving all application emails | Just verbally claiming “I looked online a few times a week” |
| Application Frequency | Treating the job search like full-time work; applying to multiple jobs weekly | Sending out one or two generic resumes a month |
| Interview Behaviour | Preparing well and acting professionally to secure the job offer | Sabotaging the interview on purpose so you are not hired |
How Much Does it Cost?
Failing to actively look for work can be the absolute most expensive mistake you make during a wrongful dismissal dispute. Here is a clear breakdown of the financial impacts and potential court fees associated with fighting for your severance and proving mitigation in Ontario: 💵
- Lost Severance Pay: If a judge ultimately decides you did not try hard enough to find a replacement job, they have the power to deduct thousands of dollars from your final settlement. In extreme cases, a total failure to mitigate could cost you your entire severance claim.
- Small Claims Court Fees: If your claim is relatively small and you are suing for less than $50,000, the initial filing fee is generally around $108, plus extra costs if you need to hire a professional process server to deliver the legal documents.
- Superior Court Fees: Issuing a formal Statement of Claim in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (for actions over $6,000) is governed by O. Reg. 293/92 under the Administration of Justice Act and is a fixed fee of exactly $243.
- Lawyer Fees: Many experienced employment lawyers in Ontario work on a contingency fee basis (meaning they take a percentage of your final win), while others may charge standard hourly rates ranging anywhere from $300 to $600+ per hour.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The timeline for successfully finding a new job and fully resolving a legal claim varies wildly depending on your specific industry, your seniority level, and your location in Ontario. 🕙
Generally speaking, finding a comparable executive or highly specialized role can easily take 6 to 12 months of active searching. If you need to officially take your former employer to court to get the severance pay you deserve, the legal process is rarely fast. Reaching a fair settlement through mediation often takes 4 to 8 months. However, if your case needs to go all the way to a full trial in the Ontario civil court system, it can take 1.5 to 2 years or even longer. Throughout this entire waiting period, your legal duty to mitigate continues uninterrupted.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What happens if the only jobs available pay much less than my old position?
If you have searched extensively and the only viable option is a lower-paying job, accepting it is still considered excellent mitigation. In Ontario, your former employer may still be legally responsible for paying the difference between your old salary and your new, lower salary during your reasonable notice period.
Do I have to look for a job if I am severely depressed or medically unfit to work?
Generally, if you have a valid, detailed medical note from a physician stating that you are completely disabled and unable to work due to physical illness or severe mental distress caused by the termination, your duty to mitigate may be temporarily paused. However, you must have rock-solid medical documentation to prove this inability to a judge.
Will finding a new job quickly ruin my severance claim?
No, finding a new job will never affect your statutory minimum entitlements (termination and severance pay) under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA). As established in Brake v. PJ-M2R Restaurant Inc., 2017 ONCA 402, statutory ESA minimums are guaranteed and cannot be reduced by mitigation. However, if you are claiming additional common law reasonable notice damages, any income actually earned from your new job during the notice period will be deducted from those common law damages, as confirmed by Williamson v. Brandt Tractor Inc., 2026 ONCA 272.
Can I decide to start my own business instead of looking for a traditional job?
Yes, starting your own business, consulting firm, or doing freelance work can be accepted by an Ontario judge as a perfectly valid form of mitigation. However, you must be able to prove that it was a reasonable career decision at the time and that you are actively working hard to make the new business profitable.
What if I decide to go back to school to retrain for a new career?
Retraining or going back to college can sometimes be considered reasonable mitigation, especially if your previous industry is rapidly shrinking or if it is nearly impossible to find comparable work without upgrading your technical skills. However, courts scrutinize this very closely, so it is best to consult an employment professional before committing to years of expensive tuition.
Should I accept an offer from my old employer to return to my previous job?
In some specific circumstances, if your employer realizes they made a mistake and offers your exact same job back with no loss of pay and no toxic work environment, refusing it might actually be seen as a failure to mitigate. This is a highly complex legal area and depends entirely on whether the workplace has become poisoned or hostile.
How many job applications per week is considered “enough” by the courts?
There is no magic number explicitly written in Ontario employment law. However, most legal practitioners suggest treating your job search exactly like a full-time job. Sending out 5 to 10 high-quality, targeted, and customized applications per week is generally viewed much more favourably than randomly mass-mailing 100 generic resumes without any follow-up.
Leave a Reply