It is strictly illegal to fire an employee in Ontario as a reprisal for taking an approved statutory leave, such as Personal Emergency Leave or Sick Leave. You may be entitled to full severance, human rights damages, and potentially job reinstatement. Claims can be filed at the Superior Court of Justice, where the fee is $320 CAD.
Life is inherently unpredictable, and every worker will eventually face a sudden crisis. Whether it is an unexpected medical emergency, the sudden illness of a child, or the tragic loss of a family member, you should not have to choose between your job and handling a personal catastrophe. In Ontario, the Employment Standards Act (ESA) guarantees employees the right to take various forms of job-protected leaves. Unfortunately, some employers view these legal absences as an inconvenience and unlawfully terminate the employee either during the leave or immediately upon their return.
Firing someone for exercising their right to a statutory leave is known as a “reprisal.” 🚨 Whether you work in a warehouse in Brampton, a retail store in Ottawa, or a tech firm in Toronto, an employer who terminates you for taking approved emergency leave is breaking the law. Ontario courts and the Ministry of Labour take reprisal cases extremely seriously. If you have been victimized in this manner, you have multiple robust legal avenues to seek significant financial compensation or even force the employer to give you your job back.
Step-by-Step Process for Reprisal Claims in Ontario
When you are fired under these circumstances, the burden actually shifts slightly to the employer to prove that the termination had absolutely nothing to do with your leave of absence. Here is how you can build a strong case to enforce your rights.
Step 1: Document the Approval of Your Leave
The foundation of your claim is proving you had a legitimate, legally protected reason to be absent. 📂 Gather all text messages, emails, or medical notes you provided to your manager or human resources department when you requested the leave. If you informed them that you needed three days off because your spouse was in the hospital, and they replied “Okay,” you have documented proof of the leave.
Step 2: Do Not Sign a Release Agreement
Employers who know they have broken the law will often try to buy your silence quickly. They may offer you a modest severance package on the condition that you sign a full and final release. Do not sign it. Signing a release will legally prevent you from suing for human rights damages or the much larger common law severance you are likely owed due to the bad-faith termination.
Step 3: Consult an Employment Lawyer Immediately
Reprisal cases are complex because you have multiple legal options. An experienced Ontario employment lawyer will evaluate your case. 👨⚕️ They will look at the timeline; if you took an emergency leave on a Wednesday and were fired on a Friday, the timing alone creates a strong presumption of reprisal in the eyes of the law.
Step 4: Choose Your Legal Avenue
Your lawyer will help you decide the best path forward. You can file a civil lawsuit at the Superior Court of Justice for wrongful dismissal and bad-faith damages. Alternatively, you can file an application with the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario (HRTO) if the leave was related to a disability or family status, or file a formal reprisal complaint with the Ministry of Labour, which has the unique power to order the employer to reinstate you to your previous position with back pay.
Valid vs Invalid Reasons for Dismissal During Leave
| Reason for Termination | Legality in Ontario | Impact on the Employee |
|---|---|---|
| Because you took the leave | Strictly Illegal (Reprisal). | Entitled to severance, human rights damages, and possible reinstatement. |
| Because you missed a deadline due to leave | Illegal. Employer must accommodate the absence. | Full compensation and bad-faith damages apply. |
| A legitimate company-wide mass layoff | Legal, provided the layoff is genuine and not a cover-up. | Entitled to standard common law severance pay, but no reprisal damages. |
How Much Does it Cost to Fight a Reprisal?
Ontario provides accessible legal systems for vulnerable workers who have been unfairly targeted.
- Ministry of Labour / HRTO: Filing a reprisal complaint with the Ministry of Labour or an application with the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario is free of any government filing fees.
- Superior Court Filing: If your lawyer advises a civil lawsuit, the filing fee at the Superior Court of Justice is $320 CAD.
- Legal Representation: Most employment law firms take reprisal cases on a contingency basis, meaning they charge no upfront fees and only take a percentage (usually around 30%) of the financial settlement they win for you.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Employers generally want to avoid the severe penalties associated with human rights violations and reprisals. Once your lawyer sends a strong demand letter highlighting the illegal nature of the firing, a lucrative settlement can often be reached in 2 to 4 months. However, if the matter proceeds through the HRTO or the court system, it can take 12 to 24 months due to significant administrative backlogs.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What exactly qualifies as a Personal Emergency Leave?
In Ontario, the ESA provides job-protected leaves for various emergencies, including sick leave (for personal illness), family responsibility leave (for the illness of a close family member), and bereavement leave. These are generally unpaid, but your job is fully protected.
Can I really get my job back if I win?
Yes. The Ontario Ministry of Labour has the authority to order ‘reinstatement.’ However, many employees choose not to return to a toxic workplace and instead negotiate a larger lump-sum financial settlement with the help of a lawyer.
Do I need a doctor’s note for emergency leave?
Under current Ontario law, an employer can ask for ‘reasonable evidence’ of your emergency, which might include a doctor’s note. However, they cannot use your inability to get a note instantly (e.g., waiting at an ER) as an excuse to fire you on the spot.
Are the damages higher if the emergency was a disability?
Often, yes. If you were fired for taking leave due to a medical disability, it crosses into a Human Rights Code violation. You may be awarded additional ‘general damages’ for injury to your dignity and feelings, on top of your common law severance.
Leave a Reply