In Ontario, the legal principle of “condonation” prevents an employer from firing you for cause over behaviour they previously allowed or ignored. If your boss accepted your constant lateness or casual dress for years, they cannot suddenly terminate you without providing a full severance package.
Understanding Condonation in the Workplace
Workplace rules are not always enforced evenly. 👥 In many offices across Ontario, from London to Markham, managers sometimes turn a blind eye to minor infractions like arriving 15 minutes late, taking extended lunches, or browsing the internet. However, problems arise when management suddenly decides to crack down, singling out an employee and firing them “for cause” over a habit that was historically ignored.
This is where the legal concept of condonation steps in to protect workers. ⚖ In Ontario employment law, if an employer knows about a specific behaviour and does nothing to stop it or discipline the employee, they have legally “condoned” it. Once behaviour is condoned, the employer loses the right to use it as a sudden justification for a just cause dismissal, meaning they must either give the employee clear, formal warnings to change or pay them full wrongful dismissal severance.
Step-by-Step Process if You Were Fired for Condoned Behaviour
If you have been abruptly terminated without severance for doing something everyone in the office does, you need to act strategically. 📍 Your employer is hoping you will quietly accept their narrative and walk away empty-handed. Here is how to fight back and claim your rightful compensation in Ontario.
Step 1: Do Not Agree with the Accusations
During the termination meeting, remain calm but do not admit fault. 📧 Do not sign any documents acknowledging that your behaviour was “misconduct” or that you broke company policy. Politely inform them that you will be taking the termination letter home to review with a legal professional.
Step 2: Document the Condonation
As soon as possible, write down everything that proves your employer accepted this behaviour. 📄 Gather evidence such as past performance reviews where the issue was never mentioned, emails from your boss approving your modified schedule, or proof that other coworkers engage in the exact same behaviour without punishment. This evidence is gold for proving condonation.
Step 3: Hire an Ontario Employment Lawyer
Consult a local law firm that specializes in wrongful dismissal. 💼 A lawyer will assess whether condonation applies to your case. They will draft a powerful demand letter outlining how the employer implicitly approved of your actions and demanding your full common law severance package.
Step 4: Pursue a Settlement or Litigation
Once the demand letter is sent, your former employer will usually realize their legal mistake. 💰 Most condonation cases in cities like Toronto, Ottawa, and Kitchener settle out of court. If they refuse, your lawyer will file a Statement of Claim at the Superior Court of Justice to enforce your rights before a judge.
How Much Does a Lawyer Cost for Wrongful Dismissal?
Fighting a false “just cause” termination is affordable because of flexible legal billing. 💳 Most Ontario residents do not pay out-of-pocket to challenge their dismissal.
| Cost Category | Average Cost in Ontario (CAD) | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Contingency Fee Agreement | 25% to 35% | The law firm takes a percentage of your final settlement. No upfront legal fees. |
| Hourly Legal Consultation | $250 to $800 / hour | An alternative option for workers wanting to pay for direct legal advice and document review. |
| Superior Court Filing Fees | $228 to Issue Claim | Standard provincial government fee to start the lawsuit officially. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Condonation cases often resolve faster than expected because the employer’s HR department quickly realizes their exposure. 🕎 A well-drafted demand letter can result in a severance payout within 4 to 8 weeks. However, if the employer digs their heels in, the mandatory mediation process and eventual trial at the Superior Court of Justice can extend the timeline from 12 to 24 months.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What if a new manager takes over and fires me?
A new manager cannot immediately fire you for cause for behaviour the previous manager allowed. To change a condoned rule, the new manager must provide clear, written expectations moving forward and give you a reasonable opportunity to adjust to the newly enforced policies.
Does condonation apply to serious offences like theft?
No. Condonation generally applies to minor infractions like lateness, dress code violations, or taking long breaks. Serious misconduct, such as workplace violence, fraud, or theft, is rarely considered “condoned” and can justify immediate termination for cause.
Do written warnings erase condonation?
Yes. If your employer formally warns you in writing that a previously ignored behaviour is no longer acceptable, the condonation is effectively reset. If you continue the behaviour after the clear warning, they may build a valid case for a “just cause” dismissal.
Will I be able to collect EI while fighting the dismissal?
If your Record of Employment (ROE) says you were fired for “dismissal/cause,” Service Canada may initially delay your EI benefits. However, you can appeal this decision and explain the situation. Often, providing your lawyer’s demand letter helps secure your EI while your case is pending.
You cannot be punished simply because your employer decided to change the rules retroactively. If you have been fired for a habit your workplace previously accepted, browse our directory to consult an employment lawyer in Ontario and secure the severance compensation you deserve.
Leave a Reply