In Ontario, it is legally prohibited for an employer to ask a job applicant about their past salary or compensation history. This critical pay transparency rule is designed to prevent past wage discrimination from following workers into their new jobs, ensuring you are paid based on your skills, not your previous paycheque.
We have all experienced the intense pressure of a job interview in competitive job markets like Ottawa, Brampton, and Windsor . Just when the conversation is going well, the hiring manager leans in and asks: “So, what are you currently making at your job?” Historically, employers used this sneaky question to lowball candidates. If they knew you were underpaid at your last job, they could offer you slightly more, but still far below the actual market value of the position. This practice disproportionately harmed women and minorities, trapping them in a cycle of lower wages. To combat this, Ontario has firmly banned employers from asking about your salary history during the hiring process. Understanding how to handle this illegal question puts the negotiating power back in your hands.
Step-by-Step Process: Navigating the Salary Question
Even though the law has changed, some hiring managers and recruiters are either unaware of the rules or actively choose to ignore them. Here is how you can handle the situation if you are asked about your past pay.
Step 1: Recognize the Illegal Question
Listen carefully to how the question is phrased 👂. An employer is legally allowed to ask, “What are your salary expectations for this role?” However, they are strictly forbidden from asking, “What was your base salary at your last company?” or requesting to see your old T4 tax slips or previous pay stubs as proof of income.
Step 2: Pivot the Conversation Professionally
If you are asked the illegal question, you do not need to aggressively quote the law and ruin the interview . Instead, politely pivot the conversation back to your expectations. A great professional response is: “While I prefer to keep my past compensation confidential, I am looking for a salary in the range of $70,000 to $80,000 CAD for this position, based on the responsibilities we have discussed.”
Step 3: Report Persistent Violations
If an employer aggressively demands your salary history and refuses to move forward with the interview unless you provide it, they are breaking Ontario labour laws. You can file a formal complaint with the Ontario Ministry of Labour. If you suspect you were denied the job purely because you refused to answer, you may also have grounds to consult an employment lawyer regarding discriminatory hiring practices.
How Much Should You Be Paid?
Because employers can no longer rely on your past salary to dictate your future pay, the focus is now heavily on market data and public salary ranges.
| Information Type | Is the Employer Allowed to Ask/Do This? | Notes for Job Seekers |
|---|---|---|
| Your Past Salary | Absolutely Not | Banned to protect you from systemic wage anchoring. |
| Your Salary Expectations | Yes, completely legal | Always research industry standards before answering. |
| Posting Salary Ranges | Mandatory for Employers | Recent Ontario laws require expected pay ranges in public job ads. |
How Long Does Wage Disparity Last?
The entire point of banning salary history questions is to break the cycle of underpayment quickly ⏱. If a worker was underpaid by $10,000 a year at their first job, and employers kept basing new offers on that old salary, that worker could lose hundreds of thousands of dollars over a 20 to 30-year career. By forcing employers to pay the actual value of the role today, workers can correct their earning trajectory instantly with a single job change.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What if I want to volunteer my past salary?
You are completely free to voluntarily disclose your past compensation if you think it will help you negotiate a higher offer. The law prevents the employer from forcing or requiring you to answer, but it does not gag you from sharing your own financial information.
Can an employer ask my former boss how much I made?
No. Under Ontario’s pay transparency regulations, an employer is legally barred from seeking your compensation history from any source. This includes asking your previous employer during a background reference check.
Do employers have to post the salary in the job description?
Yes. Under recent updates to the Employment Standards Act in Ontario, employers are legally required to include the expected salary or a specific pay range in all publicly advertised job postings, providing much-needed transparency before you even apply.
Does this law apply to internal promotions?
If you are applying for a promotion within your current company, the employer obviously already knows your current salary. However, they are still legally required to ensure that your new pay rate is based on the value of the new role and complies with equal pay for equal work provisions.
Leave a Reply