In Ontario, you cannot legally run a background or police check on a candidate without their explicit, written consent. Under the Police Record Checks Reform Act, you must wait until you have extended a conditional offer of employment before requesting a check, ensuring you do not violate the Ontario Human Rights Code. Running a standard background check through a third-party service usually costs between $30 and $100 CAD.
Hiring the right talent is critical for any growing business, but protecting your company’s assets, clients, and current staff is equally important. From retail chains in Toronto hiring cashiers to tech firms in Waterloo bringing on senior developers with access to sensitive data, conducting background checks has become a standard part of the recruitment process. However, many small business owners and new HR managers make the dangerous mistake of aggressively snooping into an applicant’s past without understanding the strict legal boundaries in place.
Running a background check in Ontario is heavily regulated to balance a company’s safety needs with an individual’s right to privacy and fair employment. 📍 The Ontario Human Rights Code strictly prohibits employers from discriminating against candidates based on race, age, and crucially, unconvicted criminal charges or pardoned offences. Furthermore, the Police Record Checks Reform Act sets firm rules on what local police services are actually allowed to disclose to you. If you randomly run credit checks or demand social media passwords without a clear, job-related reason, you could be hit with massive privacy complaints and human rights lawsuits. In this compliance guide, we will walk you through the step-by-step process of legally vetting your next hire.
Step-by-Step Process for Running Pre-Employment Checks in Ontario
To avoid severe legal penalties, your hiring process must be transparent, strictly documented, and highly consistent for all applicants. You cannot single out specific candidates for background checks based on “gut feelings.” Here is the step-by-step method to safely conduct a background check.
Step 1: Extend a Conditional Offer of Employment
The biggest legal mistake employers make is demanding police checks during the initial interview phase. 💼 Best practice in Ontario dictates that you should only request a background check after you have chosen the best candidate based on their skills and merits. You must extend a “Conditional Offer of Employment.” The written contract should clearly state: “This offer is conditional upon the successful completion and satisfactory results of a criminal background check.” This proves you did not discriminate against them early in the process.
Step 2: Obtain Explicit Written Consent
You absolutely cannot run a check behind an applicant’s back. Under federal and provincial privacy laws (like PIPEDA), you must present the candidate with a standalone consent form. This document must explicitly state what specific type of check you are running (e.g., criminal, credit, or educational verification), who will be conducting it, and how the sensitive data will be securely stored and eventually destroyed. The candidate must sign and date this form.
Step 3: Choose the Correct Type of Check
Not all background checks are the same. ⚖️ You must choose the level that is legally justified for the specific job role. A Criminal Record Check (CRC) is the basic level, showing actual criminal convictions. A Criminal Record and Judicial Matters Check (CRJMC) shows convictions plus outstanding warrants and certain absolute discharges. A Vulnerable Sector Check (VSC) is highly restricted and can only be requested if the employee will be in a position of trust over children or vulnerable adults (like working in a school or nursing home).
Step 4: Use a Certified Third-Party Provider
While a candidate can physically go to their local police station (like the Toronto Police Service or OPP) to get a paper record, it is much faster for a business to use an accredited third-party background screening company. Ensure the vendor you choose is fully RCMP-accredited to conduct Canadian checks using the CPIC database. Using a verified vendor ensures the data is transmitted securely and complies with all Canadian privacy standards.
Step 5: Assess the Results Against Human Rights Laws
If the background check comes back with a “hit,” you cannot automatically revoke the job offer. You must assess if the criminal conviction is a “Bona Fide Occupational Requirement” (BFOR) risk. For example, if the person was convicted of a minor DUI ten years ago but is applying to be a remote graphic designer, revoking the offer is illegal discrimination. However, if they were convicted of severe financial fraud and are applying to be your Chief Financial Officer, you have a solid, legally defensible reason to withdraw the conditional offer.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Ensuring your workplace is safe is a necessary business expense, and passing these costs onto the applicant is generally considered poor practice. Here is what an employer can expect to pay for proper background checks in Ontario as of May 2026:
- Basic Criminal Record Check (CRC): Requesting this directly through local Ontario police services typically costs between $30 and $60 CAD.
- Third-Party Digital Check: Using a fast, RCMP-accredited online service (like Sterling Backcheck or Triton) generally costs between $50 and $100 CAD per candidate.
- Credit Bureau Check: If hiring a finance professional, running an employment credit check via Equifax or TransUnion usually costs $15 to $30 CAD.
- Legal Compliance Review: Having an employment lawyer draft your conditional offer letter and standard consent forms typically costs a one-time fee of $300 to $600 CAD.
| Type of Check | Estimated Cost (CAD) | When to Use |
|---|---|---|
| Third-Party CRC | $50 – $100 CAD | Standard office and retail hiring |
| Vulnerable Sector (VSC) | $20 – $60 CAD | Strictly for roles involving kids or seniors |
| Credit History Check | $15 – $30 CAD | Strictly for high-level financial positions |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Modern technology has drastically sped up the hiring pipeline. ⏱ If you use an accredited online third-party provider, a basic name-and-date-of-birth Canadian criminal record check is incredibly fast, often returning results to your HR dashboard within 1 to 3 business days.
However, if the digital search triggers a “hit” due to a matching name in the database, the candidate must submit digital or physical fingerprints to the RCMP for absolute verification. This manual verification process can cause significant delays, easily taking anywhere from 2 to 4 weeks to clear, which may impact your immediate onboarding schedule.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I legally ask for a candidate’s social media passwords?
Absolutely not. While you can look at public social media profiles (like a public LinkedIn or Instagram page), demanding a candidate’s private passwords or forcing them to accept a friend request to bypass privacy settings is a severe violation of privacy laws.
Can I fire an employee if I find out they lied on their resume?
Yes. Discovering that an employee actively falsified their educational credentials, fake references, or lied about past employment usually constitutes “just cause” for immediate dismissal due to a fundamental breach of trust and honesty.
Are employers allowed to run random credit checks?
No. Credit checks are highly invasive. You can only request an employment credit check if it is highly relevant to the specific job duties, such as a bank teller, an accountant handling massive corporate funds, or an executive with financial signing authority.
Do background checks reveal pardoned offences?
Under the Police Record Checks Reform Act, standard Criminal Record Checks will not reveal offences for which the individual has received a formal record suspension (a pardon). Only highly restricted Vulnerable Sector Checks can flag certain pardoned offences.
How long must I keep a background check on file?
You must securely store the record in a locked, confidential HR file. However, under privacy principles, you should only retain it for as long as it is actively necessary for the employment relationship, and it must be securely shredded upon termination.
Leave a Reply