If an opposing partner or corporation files for bankruptcy in Ontario solely to avoid paying a massive litigation judgment, you can fight back. Under the federal Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, a creditor can ask the Superior Court of Justice to annul the bankruptcy if it was filed in bad faith or constitutes an abuse of process.
Winning a lengthy commercial lawsuit is a moment of immense relief-until the losing party immediately files for bankruptcy. 💰 In Ontario, it is an increasingly common, cynical litigation tactic for a rogue business partner or a shell corporation to declare insolvency the moment a judge orders them to pay a substantial judgment. Their goal is simple: use federal insolvency laws to wipe out the debt and leave you with nothing.
However, the Canadian legal system does not take kindly to debtors who abuse the bankruptcy process. Whether you are fighting a corporate debtor in Toronto, London, or Sudbury, you have the right to intervene. You can challenge the legitimacy of the bankruptcy and fight to preserve your judgment. This guide details how creditors can oppose a bad-faith bankruptcy assignment as of May 2026.
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
Opposing a bankruptcy is a highly technical process governed by the federal Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) and managed through the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (sitting in bankruptcy). 📝 First, an important legal distinction: when a debtor voluntarily declares bankruptcy, the process is legally called making an assignment in bankruptcy under Section 49 of the BIA. An Application for a Bankruptcy Order under Section 43 is used only when a creditor forces an involuntary bankruptcy. If you are a creditor fighting a debtor’s bad-faith voluntary filing, you are seeking to annul their assignment. Here is how you can effectively fight back.
Step 1: Review the Notice of Bankruptcy
When the debtor makes a voluntary assignment in bankruptcy under Section 49, a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) is appointed, and you will receive a formal Notice of Bankruptcy in the mail. At this exact moment, an “automatic stay of proceedings” kicks in, meaning you must immediately halt all collection efforts (like garnishing bank accounts). You must quickly review the debtor’s Statement of Affairs to see what assets and liabilities they are claiming.
Step 2: Consult a Commercial Insolvency Lawyer
Do not attempt to litigate this alone. 💼 You need a lawyer who specializes in commercial litigation and bankruptcy law. They will evaluate whether the debtor is genuinely broke or if the voluntary assignment in bankruptcy is a strategic sham. Proving bad faith requires showing that the debtor has hidden assets, transferred wealth to family members just before the filing, or made the assignment solely to frustrate your specific judgment.
Step 3: File a Motion to Annul the Bankruptcy
If the bankruptcy is a sham, your lawyer will draft a formal motion under Section 181 of the BIA. This section allows the Superior Court of Justice to annul (cancel) a bankruptcy if it is of the opinion that the assignment in bankruptcy ought not to have been filed. The motion will argue that the assignment is an abuse of the judicial process designed exclusively to evade a legitimate creditor.
Step 4: Lift the Stay of Proceedings (Alternative Strategy)
If annulling the bankruptcy is too difficult, your lawyer may instead file a motion under Section 69.4 of the BIA to “lift the stay.” 🚨 This asks the judge for special permission to continue pursuing your specific lawsuit or collection efforts outside of the bankruptcy process, particularly if your judgment involves allegations of fraud or embezzlement, which are generally not dischargeable anyway.
Step 5: Attend the Court Hearing and Examine the Debtor
You have the right to force the debtor to answer questions under oath about their finances. At the motion hearing, your lawyer will present the evidence of the debtor’s bad faith to the bankruptcy judge. If the judge agrees that the assignment was an abuse of process and ought not to have been filed, they will annul the bankruptcy, instantly restoring your right to aggressively collect your judgment.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Fighting a strategic bankruptcy is a serious financial commitment, but it is often the only way to recover a large judgment. 💵 Typical costs include:
- Initial Consultation & Strategy: Reviewing the bankruptcy documents usually costs $1,000 to $2,500 CAD.
- Motion to Annul / Lift the Stay: Drafting the motion, compiling evidence, and arguing it in Superior Court typically ranges from $10,000 CAD to $30,000 CAD.
- Examinations: Conducting a formal examination of the debtor under oath will cost an additional $3,000 to $5,000 CAD in lawyer and court reporter fees.
How Long Does the Process Take?
You must act quickly once you receive the Notice of Bankruptcy. ⏱ Gathering evidence and filing the motion to annul usually takes 3 to 6 weeks. Securing a court date before a bankruptcy judge in Ontario and receiving a final decision can take anywhere from 4 to 8 months, depending on court backlogs in your specific municipality.
| Scenario | Likelihood of Annulling Bankruptcy | Court’s Typical View |
|---|---|---|
| Debtor hides assets and files an assignment to avoid a single large judgment. | High | Viewed as a severe abuse of process and bad faith. |
| Debtor lost the lawsuit, but genuinely has massive debts to multiple other creditors. | Low | Viewed as a legitimate insolvency. Bankruptcy will likely proceed. |
| Judgment was for fraud or embezzlement. | N/A (Stay usually lifted instead) | Fraud debts survive bankruptcy anyway; creditor is usually allowed to proceed. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does bankruptcy erase a judgment for fraud?
Generally, no. Under Section 178 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, debts arising from fraud, embezzlement, or obtaining property by false pretences survive the bankruptcy process. The debtor will still owe you the money even after they are discharged.
Can I sue the directors personally if the corporation goes bankrupt?
Sometimes. While a corporation’s bankruptcy usually halts lawsuits against the company, it may still be possible to “pierce the corporate veil” or use the Oppression Remedy to hold the directors personally liable, especially if they stripped the company of cash right before filing.
What is the role of the Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT)?
The LIT is an officer of the court, not the debtor’s personal lawyer. Their job is to administer the estate fairly for all creditors. If you have proof that the debtor is hiding assets or acting in bad faith, you should provide this evidence directly to the LIT, who is legally obligated to investigate.
Can a debtor transfer assets to their spouse right before filing?
No, this is highly illegal. This is known as a “fraudulent conveyance” or a “transfer at undervalue.” The Ontario courts and the LIT have the power to reverse these transactions and seize the assets back from the spouse to pay the creditors, especially when assessing if the assignment in bankruptcy was filed in bad faith.
Leave a Reply