While federal immigration law technically overrides provincial law, the CBSA generally will not deport an undocumented child who is actively under the care of a provincial child protection agency like the Children’s Aid Society (CAS). Instead, CAS will typically work with legal counsel to file a Humanitarian and Compassionate (H&C) application.
One of the most complex and heartbreaking intersections in Canadian law occurs when a foreign-born child is removed from an abusive or neglectful home and placed into provincial foster care. If the child’s parents were undocumented, failed refugee claimants, or facing deportation, the child often shares that precarious immigration status. 📊 This creates an immediate jurisdictional clash between provincial and federal authorities.
In Ontario, agencies like the Children’s Aid Society (CAS) operate under the provincial Child, Youth and Family Services Act to protect minors. Meanwhile, the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) enforces the federal Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA). ⚖ Understanding how these two powerful systems interact is critical for foster parents, social workers, and legal advocates fighting for the best interests of a vulnerable child.
Step-by-Step Process for Protecting a Child in Care
When an undocumented child enters the foster care system, their lack of status must be addressed immediately to prevent a sudden removal order. Most applicants in this province rely on a specialized refugee and immigration lawyer, often funded by the state, to intervene. 📋 Here is the standard protocol for securing the child’s future in Canada.
Step 1: Provincial Apprehension and Status Check
When CAS (or the Ministry of Children and Family Development in BC) apprehends a child, they conduct a background check. If they discover the child has no legal status, the agency takes on the role of the child’s legal guardian. 🔍 It becomes the provincial agency’s legal duty to resolve the child’s immigration status to ensure they have access to Canadian healthcare and future education.
Step 2: Requesting a CBSA Deferral of Removal
If the CBSA already has an active removal order against the child’s family, the child’s lawyer will immediately contact federal enforcement. The lawyer will request an administrative deferral of removal. ⚠ Because the child is subject to a provincial court order keeping them in Canada for their safety, CBSA will almost universally pause the child’s deportation, respecting the provincial protection mandate.
Step 3: Filing a Humanitarian & Compassionate (H&C) Application
With deportation temporarily halted, the lawyer files a robust H&C application with Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC). Under Section 25(1) of the IRPA, immigration officers must pay strict attention to the “Best Interests of the Child” (BIOC). 📄 The application will argue that deporting a traumatized child to a country they do not know, potentially back into the hands of abusive parents, would be devastating.
Step 4: Federal Court Intervention (If Necessary)
In the exceedingly rare event that CBSA attempts to execute a removal order while a child is in CAS care, the legal team will file for an emergency stay at the Federal Court of Canada. A federal judge will evaluate the harm the child would face. 💬 Courts consistently rule that the best interests of the child must be a primary consideration, and they will block a deportation that puts a child in immediate danger.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Legal battles involving foster care and immigration are complex, but the financial burden rarely falls on the foster family or the child. Because the state is the legal guardian, government resources are utilized. 💸 Here are the standard government and legal fees in CAD:
- H&C Application Fee (IRCC): The processing fee for a dependent minor child included on an application is $180 CAD. (If they apply alone as a principal applicant, they are subject to a $660 CAD fee).
- Federal Court Filing Fee: Seeking an emergency stay or Judicial Review costs $50 CAD in court fees.
- Legal Representation: An experienced immigration lawyer charges between $4,000 and $7,000 CAD for an H&C application.
- Funding: In almost all cases, the provincial CAS agency covers these legal fees directly, or the child qualifies for a certificate through Legal Aid Ontario (LAO).
Foster parents do not need to pay out of pocket to hire a lawyer for a child in their care. The provincial child welfare agency has a dedicated budget and internal legal counsel to facilitate these necessary immigration filings. 💰
How Long Does the Process Take?
Securing permanent residence for a child in the foster system is a painfully slow process due to federal administrative backlogs. Once an H&C application is submitted, IRCC generally takes 18 to 24 months to reach a first-stage decision. ⋱ During this time, the child remains safely in Canada under an “implied” or deferred status, fully protected by the provincial agency.
If the CBSA removal order needs to be formally challenged at the Federal Court, the litigation process can add an additional 6 to 12 months. Thankfully, as long as the child remains a ward of the province, they have access to provincial healthcare and public schooling while the federal paperwork makes its way through the system. ⏳
Provincial CAS vs. Federal CBSA Roles
| Agency Level | Jurisdiction & Goal | Action on Undocumented Child |
|---|---|---|
| CAS (Provincial) | Child Protection / Best Interests | Apprehends child from danger; funds legal action to secure their Canadian status. |
| IRCC (Federal) | Immigration Processing | Evaluates H&C applications specifically looking at the “Best Interests of the Child” principle. |
| CBSA (Federal) | Border Enforcement | Technically authorized to deport, but practically defers removal when a provincial court order exists. |
| Federal Court | Judicial Oversight | Issues emergency stays of removal if CBSA acts unreasonably regarding a minor in care. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can CBSA forcefully take a child from a foster home?
While the IRPA gives CBSA broad powers, they do not storm foster homes to deport children. CBSA officers respect provincial family court orders. They communicate directly with CAS legal counsel to resolve the case administratively.
What happens if the undocumented parents are deported?
If the parents are deemed unfit and CAS has permanent custody, CBSA may deport the parents while the child remains safely in Canada. The child will pursue their own independent H&C application to stay.
Does a child in foster care get free healthcare if they have no status?
Yes. Once a child is in the care of a provincial agency like CAS, the province ensures they receive full medical, dental, and psychological care, regardless of their lack of OHIP or federal health coverage.
Can an undocumented foster child go to public school?
Absolutely. Under provincial education acts (like Ontario’s Education Act), all children under the age of 18 have the right to attend public school without paying international fees, regardless of their immigration status.
Can foster parents adopt an undocumented child?
Yes, but the child’s immigration status must be resolved first or concurrently. Adopting a child without permanent resident status complicates matters, so CAS will typically ensure the H&C application is approved before finalizing an adoption.
Leave a Reply