If you discover that a foreign worker submitted forged documents to secure a Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA) or Permanent Residence (PR) support, you generally have the legal right to terminate their employment for just cause. You must immediately notify Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC) and Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) to cancel your corporate sponsorship and avoid severe federal compliance penalties.
Hiring global talent is essential for many Canadian businesses, but the immigration process relies heavily on honesty. 🔒 When an employer in Toronto, Calgary, or Vancouver discovers that a foreign worker lied about their work experience, education, or identity to secure a job offer, the situation becomes legally explosive. LMIA fraud is a serious federal offence under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA). If your company unknowingly supported a fraudulent application, your corporate reputation and ability to hire future foreign workers are at immediate risk.
As an employer, you must navigate both federal immigration compliance and provincial employment laws simultaneously. 💼 You cannot simply ignore the fraud once you discover it, as Service Canada holds employers strictly accountable for the accuracy of LMIA applications. However, firing an employee in Canada requires following correct provincial protocols to avoid wrongful dismissal lawsuits. Generally, consulting with a dual-specialized corporate immigration and employment lawyer is the safest way to terminate the fraudulent employee while shielding your business from Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) investigations.
Step-by-Step Process in Canada
Whether your business operates in a busy hub like Halifax or a smaller town in Alberta, the federal rules for reporting LMIA fraud remain the same. 📈 Following this structured process ensures you protect your company from crippling administrative penalties.
Step 1: Secure the Fraudulent Evidence
Before taking any action, you must gather undisputed proof of the misrepresentation. 🔍 This might include forged university degrees, fake reference letters from previous employers, or altered language test results. Secure these documents digitally and restrict the employee’s access to company servers to prevent them from deleting evidence.
Step 2: Suspend the Employee Pending Investigation
Under most provincial employment standards, you should temporarily suspend the worker with pay while you conduct a formal internal investigation. ⏸️ This prevents them from continuing to work in a safety-sensitive role while giving you time to consult your legal counsel without triggering a constructive dismissal claim.
Step 3: Consult an Employment Lawyer
Terminating someone for “just cause” is a very high legal bar in Canada. ⚖️ Your employment lawyer will review the evidence of the immigration fraud. Because lying on a federal immigration document fundamentally breaches the bond of trust between employer and employee, courts generally agree this constitutes just cause for immediate dismissal.
Step 4: Terminate Employment for Just Cause
Draft a formal termination letter stating clearly that the dismissal is for just cause due to severe misrepresentation and fraud related to their employment credentials and immigration status. 📄 When terminating for just cause, you generally do not owe the employee statutory notice pay or severance pay.
Step 5: Notify Service Canada (ESDC)
If the worker was hired through an LMIA, you are legally obligated to inform ESDC that the employment has ended. 📣 You must submit a formal notification through the LMIA Employer Portal, explicitly stating that you discovered fraudulent credentials. This absolves your company of ongoing responsibility for the worker.
Step 6: Report the Fraud to IRCC and CBSA
To fully protect your business from accusations of complicity, your lawyer should draft a disclosure letter to Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) and the CBSA. 🚨 By proactively reporting the Section 40 misrepresentation, you demonstrate that your company is a victim of the fraud, ensuring your corporate compliance record remains clean.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Dealing with employee fraud involves immediate legal costs to prevent massive federal fines later. 💰
- Employment Lawyer Fees: Retaining counsel to guide a just cause termination and draft IRCC disclosures usually costs between $2,000 and $5,000 CAD.
- Severance Pay: Generally $0 CAD. If fraud is proven, the termination is with just cause, eliminating standard severance obligations.
- Employer Compliance Penalties: If you hide the fraud and Service Canada discovers it later, your business could face Administrative Monetary Penalties (AMPs) of up to $100,000 CAD per violation and a permanent ban from the Temporary Foreign Worker Program.
| Employer Action | Legal Consequence for Business | Financial Risk (CAD) |
|---|---|---|
| Proactively Report to ESDC/IRCC | Viewed as a compliant victim of fraud | Low (Only legal consultation fees) |
| Fire Employee but Do Not Report | Non-compliance with LMIA reporting rules | Moderate (Fines for failing to update ESDC) |
| Keep Employee Despite Fraud | Complicity in federal immigration fraud | Severe (Massive AMPs and program bans) |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Addressing LMIA fraud must be done urgently. ⏱️ A thorough internal investigation and legal consultation should be completed within 1 to 2 weeks. Once the termination occurs, you must notify Service Canada and IRCC immediately. The CBSA may take several months to officially investigate the worker and issue a removal order, but your corporate responsibility ends the moment you submit your formal legal disclosure.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Will the fraudulent employee be deported?
Yes, it is highly likely. Under Section 40 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, submitting fraudulent documents constitutes misrepresentation. If the CBSA investigates and proves the fraud, the worker will face a 5-year ban from Canada and an immediate removal order.
Can the employee sue my company for wrongful dismissal?
Anyone can file a lawsuit, but if you have documented proof of their fraud, their case for wrongful dismissal will likely fail. Lying about core credentials that were required to secure the LMIA fundamentally destroys the employment contract, giving you rock-solid grounds for a just cause termination.
Do I have to pay for their flight back to their home country?
If you hired them under the Low-Wage stream of the Temporary Foreign Worker Program, you initially signed an agreement to pay for their return flight. However, if the termination is due to criminal fraud or just cause, you can generally petition Service Canada to be released from this financial obligation.
Will my company be audited by the CRA or CBSA?
Reporting an employee for fraud may trigger a standard Service Canada Employer Compliance Inspection to ensure your HR practices are sound. As long as you followed all wage and payroll rules and proactively reported the fraud, your company will pass the inspection without issue.
Leave a Reply