Transferring a Canadian citizen from a United States federal prison back to a Canadian facility generally takes between 12 to 24 months to fully process. Both the US Department of Justice and Public Safety Canada must approve the application, and retaining a Canadian lawyer to manage the treaty transfer usually costs between $5,000 and $10,000 CAD.
When a Canadian citizen is convicted of a federal crime in the United States, they are usually sent to a Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) facility. 🏬 Serving time far away from your family, in a different legal culture, is incredibly challenging. Fortunately, Canada and the United States have a long-standing bilateral agreement-the Treaty Between Canada and the United States of America on the Execution of Penal Sentences-which allows citizens to serve their sentences in their home country.
While the legal pathway exists, the bureaucracy involved in moving a federal inmate across an international border is immense. 📜 It requires coordinated approvals from the US Department of Justice (DOJ), Public Safety Canada, and the Correctional Service of Canada (CSC). Managing expectations regarding the timeline is crucial for inmates and their families. This guide outlines the specific steps and realistic timeframes involved in bringing a Canadian inmate home from the USA.
Step-by-Step Process in Canada
The transfer process bridges two distinct federal systems. The initial legwork happens entirely in the United States, while the final decisions are made in Ottawa. 🏢 Having a Canadian lawyer oversee the file ensures that the application does not stall in either country’s bureaucratic backlog. Here is how the cross-border transfer process works.
Step 1: Submission to the US Bureau of Prisons (BOP)
The process always starts with the inmate. 📝 The Canadian citizen must contact their BOP case manager in the US prison and request a transfer application packet. The BOP will gather institutional behaviour records, medical files, and the original sentencing documents. They then forward this complete packet to the US Department of Justice’s International Prisoner Transfer Unit.
Step 2: Review by the US Department of Justice (DOJ)
The US DOJ must first agree to release the inmate. 🧐 They review the case to ensure all appeals are exhausted and that the inmate has paid any mandatory US criminal fines or restitution. If the DOJ approves the request, they formally transmit the transfer application to the Canadian government via diplomatic channels.
Step 3: Assessment by Public Safety Canada and CSC
Once the file arrives in Ottawa, Public Safety Canada assigns it to the Correctional Service of Canada (CSC). 🔍 CSC conducts a thorough assessment under the International Transfer of Offenders Act. They must confirm the inmate is a Canadian citizen, ensure the US crime would also be considered an indictable offence or summary conviction in Canada (dual criminality), and evaluate where the inmate will be housed.
Step 4: The Ministerial Decision
CSC provides a recommendation, but the final decision belongs to the Canadian Minister of Public Safety. ⚔ The Minister considers whether the transfer will aid in rehabilitation and whether the offender poses an undue risk to the Canadian public. If approved, the Minister issues a formal consent order, which is relayed back to the United States.
Step 5: The Physical Border Transfer
After both nations have consented, a logistics operation begins. 🚗 The US Marshals Service typically transports the inmate to a designated border crossing or airport. There, custody is officially handed over to the RCMP or Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA), who then transport the individual to a Canadian federal penitentiary reception centre.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Applying for a treaty transfer does not require you to pay government processing fees to either the US or Canada. 💵 However, because the timeline is long and files frequently get delayed, hiring a legal professional is highly recommended to keep the process moving. Here are the typical costs a family should expect.
| Service / Expense | Estimated Cost (CAD) | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Government Processing Fees | $0 | Neither the US DOJ nor Public Safety Canada charges a fee to review a transfer request. |
| Canadian Prison Lawyer | $5,000 – $10,000+ | Retainer for a law firm to track the file, advocate to CSC, and resolve bureaucratic delays. |
| Payment of US Fines | Variable | The US will usually refuse the transfer until all court-ordered restitution or fines are paid in full. |
| Transportation Fees | Variable | The inmate may occasionally be invoiced for portions of their transport costs, depending on policy. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Patience is absolutely required for a US-to-Canada transfer. ⏱ It typically takes the BOP and DOJ about 4 to 8 months to process the file and send it to Ottawa. Once Canada receives it, CSC and the Minister take another 8 to 14 months to conduct their assessment and issue an approval. Ultimately, the entire end-to-step process generally spans 12 to 24 months.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can a transfer be denied because of the nature of the crime?
Yes. Either the United States or Canada can deny the transfer based on the severity of the offence. If the Canadian Minister believes the inmate has deep ties to organized crime or poses a severe threat to the Canadian public, they may refuse to accept the transfer.
What happens to my sentence when I arrive in Canada?
Your US sentence is recalculated to fit the Canadian corrections framework. While the total length of the sentence does not change, you become subject to Canadian laws regarding parole. This means you will likely become eligible for day parole, full parole, or statutory release much sooner than you would have in the US federal system.
Do I need a US lawyer or a Canadian lawyer?
It is generally best to hire a Canadian prison law lawyer. While the US BOP initiates the file, the most rigorous assessments and the final approval happen on the Canadian side with CSC and Public Safety Canada. A Canadian lawyer is best equipped to advocate for you in Ottawa.
Can I appeal if Canada denies my transfer?
If the Canadian Minister of Public Safety denies your transfer, you can apply to the Federal Court of Canada for a judicial review. A federal judge will evaluate whether the Minister’s refusal was reasonable and based on the proper criteria outlined in the International Transfer of Offenders Act.
Leave a Reply