In Canada, suing for defamation over a pardoned record is difficult because “truth” is an absolute defence. However, you may successfully sue a malicious individual under privacy laws, such as the tort of “public disclosure of private facts” or “intrusion upon seclusion,” depending on your province.
Many Canadians wonder, can you sue for defamation if someone publishes details of your pardoned record in Canada? When the Parole Board of Canada grants you a Record Suspension (pardon), your criminal file is sealed within the RCMP database. However, a federal pardon does not magically erase old newspaper articles, nor does it delete the memories of a vindictive ex-partner or a disgruntled former colleague in cities like Vancouver or Toronto.
If someone maliciously posts your past court records on social media to ruin your reputation, your first instinct might be to sue for defamation. 📒 But Canadian law is tricky here. Defamation generally requires the statement to be false. If you actually committed the offence 15 years ago, the statement is technically true. Instead of defamation, a skilled Canadian lawyer will often pivot your case to focus on privacy torts-suing the person for invading your privacy and causing you intentional emotional distress.
Step-by-Step Legal Options When Your Past is Exposed
Dealing with online harassment regarding a pardoned criminal record requires swift and strategic legal action. Here is the general process a law firm will use to protect your reputation and hold the publisher accountable.
Step 1: Understand Defamation vs. Privacy Breach
Your lawyer will first evaluate the exact wording of what was published. 🔍 If the person exaggerated the charges or lied (e.g., saying you were convicted of theft when it was actually a minor mischief charge), you can sue for defamation. If the information is 100% accurate but intensely private and highly offensive to a reasonable person, your lawyer will build a case based on privacy torts, which are legally recognized in provinces like Ontario.
Step 2: Gather Evidence of the Malicious Publication
Before the post gets deleted, you must preserve the evidence. Take screenshots of the social media posts, blog articles, or group chats where your pardoned record was shared. Ensure you capture timestamps, the URL, and the names or profiles of the people sharing the information. Document any financial or emotional damages you suffer, such as losing a job offer or clients.
Step 3: Issue a Formal Cease and Desist Letter
Often, a lawsuit is not necessary if the perpetrator gets scared. 📧 Your lawyer will draft a severe Cease and Desist letter on law firm letterhead. This document warns the individual that publishing sealed federal information constitutes a gross invasion of privacy, and threatens immediate litigation in the Superior Court if the content is not deleted within 24 hours.
Step 4: Filing a Civil Lawsuit
If the person refuses to remove the posts, your lawyer will file a Statement of Claim in civil court. You will sue for damages based on invasion of privacy, intentional infliction of mental suffering, and possibly defamation (if any falsehoods were mixed in). The court can issue an injunction forcing them to take the posts down and ordering them to pay you financial compensation.
How Much Does It Cost to Take Legal Action?
Fighting for your privacy in civil court can be expensive, but taking initial steps is often highly affordable. 💵
- Cease and Desist Letter: A lawyer typically charges between $300 CAD and $800 CAD to draft and serve a formal demand letter.
- Small Claims Court: If your financial damages are under the provincial limit (e.g., $35,000 in Ontario), filing fees are low ($100 – $300 CAD), and legal fees are manageable.
- Superior Court Litigation: A full civil lawsuit with injunctions can cost anywhere from $10,000 CAD to $30,000+ CAD, though you may recover some of these costs if you win.
How Long Does the Legal Process Take?
Stopping the spread of information must happen quickly, while the actual lawsuit takes time.
- Demand Letter Impact: Often resolves the issue within 2 to 7 days as most individuals will delete the post upon receiving a lawyer’s threat.
- Emergency Injunction: A court order to force the removal of content can take 3 to 6 weeks.
- Full Civil Trial: If the person fights back in court, reaching a trial or final settlement can take 1 to 3 years.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is it a crime to share someone’s pardoned record?
For a private citizen, it is generally not a criminal offence under the Criminal Code to share factual history. It is, however, a civil wrong (a tort) that allows you to sue them for money. It is only illegal for federal agencies to share the sealed record.
Can I force a newspaper to delete an old article about my crime?
Generally, no. Canadian courts heavily protect freedom of the press. News outlets are not legally required to unpublish true historical events just because you later received a Record Suspension, though some may do so out of compassion if you ask.
Does Google have a “Right to be Forgotten” in Canada?
The “Right to be Forgotten” is still a highly debated and evolving legal concept in Canada. While you can request Google to de-index certain highly sensitive personal information, it is not an automatic right for past criminal news.
What if my ex created an anonymous fake account to post it?
Your lawyer can apply for a “Norwich Order” from the court. This forces the internet service provider (ISP) or social media platform (like Facebook or X) to hand over the IP address and identity of the anonymous poster.
Can I sue my employer if they reveal my pardoned record?
Yes. If your employer runs a background check before your pardon, keeps that data, and later shares it without authorization, they have violated commercial privacy laws (PIPEDA) and you can take legal action against the company.
Leave a Reply