Decanting a trust in Ontario involves a trustee transferring or “pouring” assets from an old trust into a new one with more favourable terms. This advanced estate planning strategy is often used to protect a beneficiary from creditors or to update administrative rules, provided the original trust deed allows it or the Superior Court of Justice grants approval.
Trusts are incredibly useful tools for managing wealth and protecting beneficiaries in cities like Toronto, Ottawa, and London. 🏦 However, life changes, and a trust drafted twenty years ago might no longer serve the best interests of the people it was meant to protect. For example, a beneficiary might develop a disability requiring provincial support, or they might face severe creditor issues. In these situations, trustees often look for a way to modify the trust without breaking their fiduciary duties.
This is where the concept of “decanting” comes into play. Just as you would pour wine from an old bottle into a new decanter to leave the bitter sediment behind, a trustee can “pour” the assets of an outdated trust into a newly created trust. The new trust will have updated terms that better serve the beneficiaries. However, because Ontario uses the Common Law system, decanting is a complex legal manoeuvre that requires strict adherence to the original trust document and provincial trust laws.
Step-by-Step Process for Decanting in Ontario
Executing a decanting strategy is not something a trustee should attempt on their own. 📝 The process generally follows these careful steps to ensure no legal or tax boundaries are crossed.
Step 1: Review the Original Trust Deed
The first step is to carefully read the original trust document. Unlike some jurisdictions that have specific “decanting statutes,” Ontario relies heavily on the terms explicitly written in the trust itself. You are looking for a “power of appointment” or a specific decanting clause that gives the trustee absolute discretion to advance capital to a beneficiary or create new trusts for their benefit.
Step 2: Determine the Purpose of the New Trust
Why are you decanting? 🔍 You must have a clear, justifiable reason that aligns with your fiduciary duty to the beneficiaries. Common reasons include protecting assets from a beneficiary’s impending bankruptcy, changing administrative provisions (like updating investment powers), or separating a single family trust into multiple individual trusts for different siblings in Mississauga or Hamilton.
Step 3: Consult an Ontario Law Firm and a Tax Professional
Before moving any money, you must seek professional advice. An experienced trust lawyer will confirm if you have the legal authority to decant. Equally important, a tax professional must review the plan to ensure that moving the assets does not trigger an unexpected “deemed disposition” by the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), which could result in a massive capital gains tax bill.
Step 4: Draft the New Trust Document
If you have the green light, your lawyer will draft the new trust deed. 📄 This new document will hold the updated rules, but it generally cannot add new beneficiaries who were not part of the original trust. It must also usually maintain the same “perpetuity period” (the maximum legal lifespan) of the original trust.
Step 5: Execute a Deed of Appointment
To officially move the funds, the trustee executes a legal document known as a “Deed of Appointment.” This document formally exercises the trustee’s power to take assets from Trust A and appoint them to Trust B. It creates a paper trail proving that the trustee acted properly.
Step 6: Seek Court Approval (If Necessary)
If the original trust deed does not explicitly allow for decanting, you cannot simply do it anyway. 🏛 In such cases, the trustee must file an application with the Superior Court of Justice to vary the trust under the Variation of Trusts Act. This requires the consent of adult beneficiaries and the involvement of the Office of the Children’s Lawyer if minors are involved.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Decanting is an advanced legal strategy, and the costs reflect the high level of professional expertise required. 💰
- Lawyer Fees: Having a law firm review the original trust and draft the new trust and Deed of Appointment generally costs between $5,000 and $15,000 CAD, depending on complexity.
- Tax Advisory Fees: A CPA specializing in trusts will typically charge $2,000 to $5,000 CAD for a tax opinion.
- Court Application Fees: If you must apply to the Superior Court of Justice to vary the trust, the initial filing fee for a Notice of Application is currently $243 CAD (set by O. Reg. 293/92), but the associated lawyer fees for litigation can easily exceed $15,000 to $30,000 CAD.
| Requirement | Decanting via Trust Deed | Decanting via Court Approval |
|---|---|---|
| Legal Authority | Granted by original trust document | Granted by Superior Court of Justice |
| Beneficiary Consent | Usually not required | Mandatory for adult beneficiaries |
| Timeline | Fast (1-3 months) | Slow (1-2 years) |
How Long Does the Process Take?
If the original trust contains a broad power of appointment, the entire decanting process can be completed in 1 to 3 months. ⌛ However, if the trust is restrictive and you must apply to the Superior Court of Justice in Ontario, the process can drag on for 12 to 24 months due to court backlogs and the time required to gather beneficiary consents.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does decanting trigger capital gains tax with the CRA?
Generally, if done correctly under specific rules in the Income Tax Act (such as ensuring the transfer does not result in a change of beneficial ownership), assets can be rolled over to the new trust on a tax-deferred basis. However, if the new trust fundamentally changes who benefits from the assets, the CRA may treat it as a taxable sale.
Can I use decanting to remove a beneficiary I do not like?
Usually, no. A trustee has a fiduciary duty to all beneficiaries. Decanting is generally used to protect beneficiaries or improve trust administration, not to disinherit someone out of spite. Removing a beneficiary through decanting could expose the trustee to a severe lawsuit for breach of trust.
What happens to the old trust after decanting?
If you transfer all the assets out of the original trust, it effectively becomes an “empty” trust. Your lawyer will advise on the proper steps to formally wind up and close the old trust, including filing a final T3 trust tax return with the CRA.
Can a beneficiary force a trustee to decant the trust?
No. Decanting relies on the discretionary power of the trustee. A beneficiary can request that the trustee explore this option, but they cannot force it unless they successfully petition the Superior Court of Justice to intervene or vary the trust under the Variation of Trusts Act.
Leave a Reply