In Ontario, you cannot simply convert an existing living (Inter Vivos) trust into a Testamentary trust after death. They are legally distinct entities, and restructuring trust assets generally involves navigating the CRA’s 21-year deemed disposition rule, requiring a tax lawyer and often costing $4,000 to $10,000 CAD.
Trusts are incredible tools for managing family wealth, but they are wrapped in complex terminology that often confuses even savvy investors. Many families in Ontario set up a family trust while they are alive-known legally as an “Inter Vivos” trust-to hold a cottage or corporate shares. When the creator of that trust passes away, a common misconception is that the trust simply “converts” into a Testamentary trust to gain better tax advantages.
This is a legal impossibility in Canada. 📋 An Inter Vivos trust is created while you are alive, and it lives on after you die, subject to extremely strict Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) tax rules. A Testamentary trust is born entirely out of a person’s Last Will and Testament upon their death. You cannot seamlessly transform one into the other. Whether you are consulting a lawyer in Toronto, Kitchener, or Ottawa, understanding how to transition assets safely requires deep tax planning.
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
If your goal is to wind down an existing living trust and funnel those assets into the protective structure of a Testamentary trust upon your death, it requires proactive estate planning. Here is how lawyers structure this complex transition.
Step 1: Understanding the Legal Distinction
First, you must understand the barrier. 📖 An Inter Vivos trust pays taxes at the highest marginal rate on every dollar it earns. A Testamentary trust (like a Graduated Rate Estate) can benefit from lower progressive tax brackets for the first 36 months after death. Because of this massive tax difference, the CRA strictly forbids simply renaming a living trust to steal the death tax benefits.
Step 2: Monitoring the 21-Year Rule
If you keep the Inter Vivos trust alive, you face the CRA’s infamous 21-year deemed disposition rule. Every 21 years, an Inter Vivos trust is forced to pay capital gains tax on all its assets, as if it sold everything. To avoid this massive tax hit, trustees usually must “roll out” the assets to the beneficiaries before the 21-year anniversary arrives.
Step 3: Winding Down the Inter Vivos Trust
If the creator wants the assets to eventually end up in a Testamentary trust, they might choose to wind down the Inter Vivos trust while they are still alive. 💰 A tax lawyer can sometimes roll the assets out of the trust and back to the original creator on a tax-deferred basis, effectively collapsing the living trust.
Step 4: Drafting the Testamentary Trust in the Will
Now that the creator owns the assets personally again, they must draft a complex Last Will and Testament. The lawyer will build specialized Testamentary trusts directly into the Will. These trusts only spring into existence on the exact day the creator dies, ensuring they qualify for proper estate tax treatment.
Step 5: Passing Through Probate
The catch to this strategy is probate. ⚔️ Because the assets are now owned personally again (to funnel them into the Will’s Testamentary trust), they will be subject to Ontario’s Estate Administration Tax, which is roughly 1.5% of the total estate value, payable to the Superior Court of Justice during probate.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Undoing an old trust and drafting new Testamentary trusts is a highly specialized area of law. 💵 You are blending corporate tax law, trust law, and estate planning.
| Tax Lawyer Consultation & Strategy | $1,500 – $3,500 |
| Winding down Inter Vivos Trust | $2,000 – $5,000+ |
| Drafting Will with Testamentary Trusts | $1,500 – $4,000 |
| CRA T3 Trust Filings (Accountant) | $1,000 – $2,500 annually |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Restructuring your family’s entire trust framework is not a weekend project. Winding down an old Inter Vivos trust and transferring titles can take 3 to 6 months. ⏳ Drafting the new Will containing the Testamentary trusts typically takes an additional 4 to 8 weeks of careful planning with your lawyer and accountant.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the 21-year deemed disposition rule?
The CRA forces most Inter Vivos trusts to pretend they have sold all their assets every 21 years. This prevents families from hiding generational wealth in a trust forever without ever paying capital gains tax.
Are Testamentary trusts still taxed at lower rates?
Mostly, no. In 2016, the CRA changed the rules. Now, Testamentary trusts are also taxed at the highest marginal rate, except for a “Graduated Rate Estate” which gets lower tax rates for only the first 36 months after death.
Can an Alter Ego Trust convert into a Testamentary trust?
No. An Alter Ego Trust is a specific type of Inter Vivos trust. It continues to exist after death to distribute assets, but it is never classified by the CRA as a Testamentary trust.
Does a Testamentary trust avoid probate fees?
No. Because a Testamentary trust is created by a Will, the assets funding the trust must generally pass through the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, triggering the Estate Administration Tax first.
Why not just keep the Inter Vivos trust forever?
You can, provided you are prepared to pay the massive capital gains tax bill every 21 years. Many families eventually wind the trust down to avoid this punitive taxation cycle.
Leave a Reply