In Ontario, you can legally appoint two or more people to act as your Attorney for Personal Care. However, if siblings disagree on critical health decisions-such as whether to take you off life support-it can create a medical and legal nightmare. Drafting a strict “tie-breaker” clause is mandatory to ensure doctors can act swiftly during an emergency.
Planning for incapacitation is arguably more important than planning for death. In Ontario, a Power of Attorney for Personal Care (POAPC) is the legal document that appoints someone to make health, nutrition, and shelter decisions for you if you suffer a severe stroke, dementia, or an accident. It is entirely common for aging parents in Mississauga, London, or Kingston to feel guilty about choosing one child over another, leading them to appoint both of their children jointly. While this seems fair on the surface, it frequently creates catastrophic bottlenecks in hospital waiting rooms.
Under the Substitute Decisions Act, if you appoint two people “jointly,” they must agree on every single medical decision. 📍 If one child wants to pursue aggressive, experimental medical treatments and the other child wants to transition you to palliative hospice care, the doctors are legally paralyzed. They cannot take instructions until the attorneys reach a consensus, which often forces the family into emergency mediation or a bitter dispute at the Consent and Capacity Board. To avoid tearing your family apart, your law firm must draft a highly specific POAPC that outlines exactly how disagreements will be resolved.
Step-by-Step Process for Drafting a Multi-Person POA in Ontario
Creating a functional Power of Attorney with multiple decision-makers requires looking past family politics and focusing purely on medical logistics. Here is how a lawyer will structure your document.
Step 1: Understand the Role of an Attorney for Personal Care
First, you must understand what this role entails. 🔍 Your Attorney for Personal Care does not handle your bank accounts (that is a Continuing Power of Attorney for Property). They handle consent for surgeries, placement in long-term care facilities, and daily hygiene decisions. You must carefully assess if the two people you want to appoint have a history of healthy communication and the emotional fortitude to make life-or-death choices.
Step 2: Choose “Joint” vs. “Joint and Several”
If you appoint two people, you must legally define how they act. “Joint” means they must agree unanimously on every decision. “Joint and Several” means they can make decisions together, but if one is unreachable (e.g., travelling out of the country), the other can legally make a binding decision alone. Most Ontario lawyers strongly recommend “Joint and Several” so that emergency surgeries are not delayed waiting for a second signature.
Step 3: Draft a Clear Tie-Breaker Clause
If they are acting jointly and they disagree, a tie-breaker clause is your ultimate safety net. 📝 Your lawyer can draft several options. You can state that in the event of a dispute, the decision of your eldest child shall prevail. Alternatively, you can appoint three people and state that “majority rules.” Some parents even insert a clause requiring the attorneys to consult with a specific family doctor or a neutral third-party mediator whose decision becomes final.
Step 4: Include Specific Medical Directives (Living Will)
The best way to prevent your attorneys from fighting is to make the decision yourself in advance. You can embed a “Living Will” or medical directives directly into your POAPC. You can explicitly state: “If I am in a terminal coma with no reasonable chance of recovery, I direct my Attorneys to refuse life-sustaining treatment.” Clear instructions remove the emotional burden from your children, making it much harder for them to disagree on your care.
Step 5: Appoint an Alternate Attorney
Life is unpredictable. ⌛ Even if you appoint two people perfectly, they might both be involved in the same car accident as you, or one may simply refuse to act due to overwhelming stress. Your document must always name an “Alternate” or “Substitute” Attorney who can immediately step into the role if your primary choices are unwilling or unable to serve.
Step 6: Execution and Witnessing
To be legally valid in Ontario, a POAPC must be signed by you in the physical (or virtual) presence of two valid witnesses. The witnesses cannot be your spouse, the attorneys you are appointing, or their spouses. Once properly signed and witnessed, the document is legally binding, though it only comes into effect if you are officially deemed mentally incapable of making your own health decisions.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Drafting a custom POA with tie-breaker clauses costs slightly more than a basic template, but it saves your family from devastating legal battles later.
| Legal / Medical Expense | Estimated Cost (CAD) | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Drafting a Custom POAPC | $250 – $600 CAD | The typical lawyer fee to draft a Power of Attorney for Personal Care with custom tie-breaker clauses. |
| Capacity Assessment | $500 – $1,500 CAD | If your capacity is questioned, a Designated Capacity Assessor must evaluate you before the POA is triggered. |
| Consent and Capacity Board | $5,000 – $15,000+ CAD | The devastating legal fees if your children disagree and must litigate your care at the provincial board. |
| Professional Care Manager | $100 – $200 / hour | Hiring a neutral medical social worker to act as the tie-breaker if embedded in your document. |
Most Ontario law firms offer “Estate Packages” that bundle your Will, Property POA, and Personal Care POA together for a reduced overall rate (typically around $800 – $1,500 CAD total). 💰
How Long Does the Process Take?
Setting up your protective documents is a very quick process compared to resolving a dispute in court. Once you provide your instructions to an estate lawyer, the draft POAPC is usually ready to sign within 1 to 2 weeks.
If you fail to draft a POAPC and you become incapacitated, your family must apply to the court to be appointed as your legal Guardian of the Person. 📅 This guardianship application process is incredibly intrusive, requires massive amounts of paperwork, and typically takes 4 to 8 months to complete in Ontario, leaving your medical decisions in limbo in the meantime.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I appoint my doctor as my Attorney?
No. Under the Substitute Decisions Act, you cannot appoint someone who provides you with health care or residential, social, or support services for compensation, unless they are your spouse or a blood relative. This ensures your medical team remains objective.
Who decides if I have no POA in Ontario?
If you are incapacitated without a POAPC, the Health Care Consent Act provides a strict hierarchy of substitute decision-makers. The doctors will look first to a legally appointed Guardian, then your spouse/partner, then your children (all children equally), then a parent, and so on.
Can my Attorney override my Living Will?
Legally, your Attorney is required to follow the prior capable wishes you expressed (like a Living Will) unless it is completely impossible to do so. They cannot simply ignore your written directives just because they personally disagree with your end-of-life choices.
What if they disagree and there is no tie-breaker?
If two joint attorneys are hopelessly deadlocked over a medical decision and you did not provide a tie-breaker, the dispute must be escalated. The doctors or the family must apply to the Consent and Capacity Board (CCB) of Ontario, or ultimately the Public Guardian and Trustee will step in to make the decision.
Do they get paid for making these decisions?
Unlike an Attorney for Property (who has a statutory right to claim a percentage of your estate), an Attorney for Personal Care does not generally have a legal right to claim compensation for making health decisions, unless you explicitly state in your POAPC that they should be paid.
Leave a Reply