If your ex-spouse maliciously damages the matrimonial home, you can urgently apply to the Superior Court of Justice for a Preservation Order or Exclusive Possession. Under Section 5(6) of the Ontario Family Law Act, you can also claim an unequal division of property to financially recover the exact cost of the damages.
Selling a house during a divorce is already an incredibly stressful endeavor. When tensions boil over, one spouse might act out destructively-smashing drywall, destroying fixtures, neglecting critical repairs, or deliberately vandalizing the property before an open house. In Ontario, this is not just a frustrating inconvenience; it is a serious legal issue known as the “intentional depletion of net family property.”
Whether your home is a condo in downtown Toronto or a detached house in London, the matrimonial home is often a family’s largest financial asset. 💰 When an ex-partner damages it, they are directly stealing money out of your pocket by lowering the market value of the property. The Ontario family justice system has strict mechanisms in place to punish this behavior and protect the innocent spouse. If you are facing this nightmare scenario, reaching out to a tough family lawyer from our directory immediately is your best course of action.
Step-by-Step Process for Handling Property Damage by an Ex
You do not have to sit back and watch your investment be destroyed. The legal steps you take will depend on whether the damage is an ongoing emergency or something you discovered after the fact. Here is the general path to holding a destructive ex accountable in Ontario.
Step 1: Document Everything and Call the Police (If Necessary)
If you catch your ex actively destroying the home or if you feel physically unsafe, dial 911 immediately. 🚨 While police often view minor property disputes between married spouses as a “civil matter,” severe destruction of property can lead to criminal charges such as Mischief under the Criminal Code of Canada. Even if charges are not laid, ensure you take date-stamped photos and videos of all the damage for your family court file.
Step 2: Apply for a Preservation Order
If your ex is threatening to cause more damage or is actively stripping the house of valuable fixtures, your lawyer can file an urgent motion for a Preservation Order (often called a Non-Depletion Order). Issued by the Superior Court of Justice, this order legally prohibits your spouse from damaging, selling, or altering any family property until the divorce is finalized. Breaching this order can result in severe financial penalties or contempt of court.
Step 3: Seek Exclusive Possession of the Matrimonial Home
To stop the damage permanently, you may need to kick the destructive spouse out. 🚪 Under Section 24 of the Family Law Act, you can apply for an Order for Exclusive Possession. If granted, you will be the only one legally allowed to live in the home pending its sale, and your ex-spouse’s keys must be surrendered. Judges will consider any history of violence or malicious property damage when granting this order.
Step 4: Claim Unequal Division of Property (Section 5(6) of the FLA)
Ontario law usually mandates a 50/50 split of the financial growth during the marriage. However, Section 5(6) of the Family Law Act allows a judge to award an “unequal division” if an equal split would be “unconscionable.” If your ex intentionally damaged the home, your lawyer will ask the judge to deduct the repair costs directly from your ex-spouse’s share of the equalization payment.
Step 5: Execute the Sale and Repair Costs
When the house is finally sold, the real estate lawyer handling the transaction can be directed (via your Separation Agreement or a court order) to hold the sale proceeds in trust. 💵 The funds required to repair the damage or compensate you for the lowered sale price will be paid out to you first, before the remaining equity is divided between you and your ex.
How Much Does it Cost to Fight This in Court?
Taking urgent legal action to protect a house requires filing emergency motions, which can be expensive. 💲 However, ignoring the damage could cost you tens of thousands of dollars in lost home equity. Here are the typical costs associated with these legal remedies in Ontario:
| Legal Action | Estimated Cost (CAD) | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Urgent Motion Filing Fee | $167 | Court fee to file a Notice of Motion (Form 14) at the Superior Court. |
| Lawyer for Urgent Motion | $3,500 – $7,000+ | Legal fees to rapidly draft affidavits and argue for Exclusive Possession in court. |
| Home Repair Estimates | $0 – $200 | Costs to get professional contractors to provide written quotes for the damages. |
| Property Appraisal | $400 – $800 | To prove how much market value was lost due to the intentional vandalism. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
The timeline for relief depends on the urgency of the situation. If your ex is actively taking a sledgehammer to the walls, an emergency ex parte motion (without notice to the other side) can be heard by a judge within 24 to 48 hours.
If the damage is already done and your goal is simply to get your money back through an unequal division of property, this will become part of your overall divorce settlement. Reaching a final resolution on property division through negotiation or trial typically takes anywhere from 6 months to 2 years.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I change the locks if my ex damages the house?
No, not without a court order or a signed agreement. Both legally married spouses have an equal right to possess the matrimonial home under Ontario law. If you change the locks without an Exclusive Possession Order, your ex can call a locksmith or the police to regain entry.
Should I fix the damage before we list the house for sale?
Generally, yes, to ensure you get the best possible sale price. However, you must document all the damage meticulously with photos, videos, and professional contractor invoices before making any repairs. You will need this evidence to claim the money back in family court.
What if my ex didn’t destroy it, but just let it fall into ruin?
Intentional neglect (like turning off the heat in winter causing pipes to burst, or refusing to fix a leaking roof) can also be considered a reckless depletion of net family property under Section 5(6) of the Family Law Act. You can still seek financial compensation.
Will home insurance cover damage caused by my spouse?
Usually, no. Most Canadian home insurance policies have an “intentional acts” exclusion clause. If a named insured on the policy (your spouse) intentionally damages the property, the insurance company will likely deny the claim, forcing you to seek remedy through family court.
Can I sue them in small claims court instead?
No. When you are legally married and undergoing a separation, property disputes must be handled through the Superior Court of Justice under the Family Law Act, rather than pursuing a separate civil lawsuit in small claims court.
Leave a Reply