In Ontario, a Section 112 assessment is an expert investigation into your family to determine the best parenting arrangement. If the Office of the Children’s Lawyer (OCL) accepts your case, it is fully subsidized by the province. However, if you must hire a private social worker or psychologist, it typically costs between $5,000 and $15,000+ CAD.
When a separation turns hostile, parents often completely disagree on what is best for their children. One parent might accuse the other of alienation, substance abuse, or neglect. A judge sitting in a courtroom in Toronto, Hamilton, or Ottawa cannot possibly know what happens behind the closed doors of your home. 📝
To solve this, a judge can order a clinical investigation under Section 112 of the Courts of Justice Act. An independent expert will interview the parents, the children, and teachers to write a comprehensive report recommending who should have decision-making responsibility (formerly known as custody) and parenting time.
This guide will explain how to request an assessment, the massive cost difference between government-funded and private assessors, and what exactly happens during the investigation. We will also discuss when a local law firm is crucial to help you challenge an unfair report.
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
Whether your case is at the Superior Court of Justice or the Ontario Court of Justice, the process of bringing an independent assessor into your family is highly regulated. You cannot simply hire someone off the street to write a report about your ex-partner. 📍
The assessor must be neutral, highly qualified, and approved by the court. Engaging in this process requires absolute honesty and cooperation.
Step 1: Request an Assessment Order
An assessment cannot begin without a court order. Either you, your ex-partner, or the judge can request it. ❗
Your lawyer will file a motion arguing that there are complex clinical issues (like severe mental health concerns or parental alienation) that the judge cannot decide without expert psychological or social work insight.
Step 2: Submit an Intake Form to the OCL
In most cases, the judge will first order the involvement of the Office of the Children’s Lawyer (OCL). You both must fill out a detailed Intake Form.
The OCL reviews these forms to decide if they will accept your case. They do not accept everyone; they prioritize cases with serious allegations of violence, high conflict, or when children are caught in the middle of severe emotional manipulation.
Step 3: Hire a Private Assessor (If OCL Declines)
If the OCL declines your case, or if you and your ex-partner want a faster timeline, you must agree to hire a private assessor. 💪
This professional is usually a registered social worker or a clinical psychologist. Both parents (and their lawyers) must agree on who to hire and must sign a retainer agreement detailing how the massive costs will be split.
Step 4: The Investigation and Final Report
The assessor will conduct multiple interviews with you, your ex-partner, and the children. They will likely conduct home visits to observe your parenting firsthand and will contact collaterals, such as teachers or paediatricians.
Finally, they will compile a massive Section 112 Report. This document outlines the family dynamics and provides specific recommendations to the judge regarding the final parenting schedule.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
The financial burden of an assessment depends entirely on whether the provincial government steps in or if you are forced into the private sector. 💰
Here is a breakdown of the typical costs you might face for a family assessment:
| Type of Assessor / Expense | Estimated Cost (CAD) | Who Pays? |
|---|---|---|
| Office of the Children’s Lawyer (OCL) | $0 (Fully subsidized) | Government of Ontario |
| Private Registered Social Worker | $5,000 – $10,000+ | Usually split 50/50 by parents |
| Private Clinical Psychologist | $10,000 – $25,000+ | Usually split 50/50 by parents |
| Lawyer (Cross-examining Assessor) | $2,000 – $5,000+ | Paid out of pocket |
If one parent is acting in bad faith, making up completely false allegations just to drag out the court process, the judge might order that abusive parent to pay 100% of the private assessor’s fees at the end of the trial.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Because these reports heavily influence the rest of the child’s life, the investigation is incredibly thorough and takes a significant amount of time. ⏱
If the OCL accepts your case, it often takes 3 to 6 months for the clinician to finish their investigation and file the final report with the court.
If you hire a private assessor, the process is generally faster, often taking 2 to 4 months, depending on how quickly the parents cooperate and submit their documents. While you wait for the report, the judge will usually issue a temporary parenting order to ensure the children are cared for.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does the judge have to follow the assessor’s report?
No. A Section 112 report is a recommendation, not a final order. However, judges give these reports immense weight because they are written by neutral experts. It is extremely difficult to convince a judge to rule against the assessor’s professional recommendation.
What happens if the OCL refuses my case?
The OCL has limited funding and rejects many cases if the dispute is strictly about money or if they believe the parents are just arguing over minor scheduling issues. If rejected, you either have to hire a private assessor or proceed to trial without expert evidence.
Can I refuse to speak to the assessor?
You could technically refuse, but it would be a catastrophic mistake for your case. The assessor will note your lack of cooperation in the report, and the judge will likely interpret your silence as hiding something, severely damaging your chances of securing decision-making responsibility.
Will the assessor ask the children who they want to live with?
Assessors are highly trained not to ask children to choose between their parents, as this causes severe anxiety. Instead, they ask indirect questions and observe the child’s comfort levels to ascertain their true “views and preferences” without making them feel guilty.
Should I hire a law firm if an assessment is ordered?
Yes, absolutely. If the assessor writes a report that unfairly paints you as a bad parent, it will destroy your case. A local family law firm will know how to properly cross-examine the assessor at trial and hire competing experts to challenge flawed psychological findings.
Leave a Reply