Ontario follows a “loser pays” system in civil lawsuits. If you win your wrongful dismissal case at the Superior Court of Justice, the judge will typically order your former employer to reimburse you for 50% to 70% of your legal fees. This “costs award” makes fighting a stubborn employer highly financially viable.
One of the biggest reasons fired employees accept unfair severance packages is the fear of expensive legal bills. Companies count on the fact that the average worker in Toronto, Brampton, or Kitchener cannot afford to pay a law firm thousands of dollars upfront to fight a corporate legal department.
However, the Ontario legal system is designed to level the playing field. To discourage employers from dragging out frivolous defenses, the court uses “costs awards.” Simply put, if your former employer forces you to go to trial to get your proper common law severance, and you win, they have to pay a massive chunk of your lawyer’s invoice.
Understanding how legal costs are awarded is critical to building a strong legal strategy. Below, we explain how the “loser pays” rule works and how strategic settlement offers can force an employer to pay almost all of your legal expenses. 📍
Step-by-Step Process for Recovering Legal Costs in Ontario
Litigation is a strategic game of risk. Here is how an employment lawyer will use the rules of the Superior Court of Justice to maximize your financial recovery and minimize your out-of-pocket expenses.
Step 1: Understanding “Partial Indemnity” Costs
In standard wrongful dismissal victories, the winning party is usually awarded costs on a “partial indemnity” basis. This means the judge will order the losing company to pay approximately 50% to 70% of your total legal fees.
This money is awarded in addition to your actual severance pay. So, if your severance award is $80,000 CAD and your lawyer’s bill was $20,000 CAD, the judge might order the employer to pay you the $80,000 plus an extra $12,000 to help cover your legal fees.
Step 2: Using “Rule 49” Offers to Settle
Rule 49 of the Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure is a powerful tool. It rewards people who make reasonable settlement offers and heavily punishes those who refuse them. 📝
For example, if your lawyer officially offers to settle the case early for $50,000 CAD, and the employer refuses, the case goes to trial. If the judge ultimately awards you $50,000 CAD or more, the court will severely penalize the employer. Because the company stubbornly refused your fair offer, the judge may award you “substantial indemnity” costs-forcing the employer to pay up to 90% of your legal fees from the date the offer was made.
Step 3: Winning the Wrongful Dismissal Trial
To get a costs award, you must be the successful party. In employment law, “winning” generally means the judge rules that the employer breached your contract and failed to provide adequate common law notice.
Once the judge delivers the final verdict on your severance pay, the trial transitions to the “costs phase.”
Step 4: The Costs Submission Hearing
After winning, your law firm will submit a detailed “Bill of Costs” to the judge. This document outlines every hour spent on your case, the hourly rates of the lawyers, and expenses like court filing fees and printing costs.
The judge will review the bill, look at the employer’s behavior during the lawsuit, and issue a final Costs Order detailing exactly how much extra money the company must pay you.
Types of Costs Awards in Ontario
| Type of Costs Award | What It Means for You |
|---|---|
| Partial Indemnity | The standard award for the winning party. Usually covers 50% to 70% of your actual legal fees. |
| Substantial Indemnity | A penalty award against a party that rejected a fair Rule 49 offer or acted terribly. Covers up to 90% of your legal fees. |
| Full Indemnity | Extremely rare. Covers 100% of legal fees. Usually only awarded for severe fraud or malicious conduct by the employer during litigation. |
How Much Does it Cost to Sue in Ontario?
While the goal is to have the employer pay your costs, you must understand the initial financial structure. As of May 2026, the basic costs are:
- Initial Strategy Session: Expect to pay $300 to $500 CAD for a lawyer to evaluate the strength of your wrongful dismissal case.
- Court Filing Fees: Starting a claim at the Superior Court of Justice carries a standard filing fee of roughly $242 CAD.
- Contingency Fees vs. Hourly: If you hire a lawyer on a 30% contingency fee, the costs awarded by the judge are usually factored into the final calculation so that you keep the maximum amount of your core severance.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The timeline heavily influences how high the legal costs will climb.
- Early Settlement: If the case settles via demand letter in 1 to 2 months, legal costs are low and usually wrapped into the final settlement package.
- Mediation Resolution: Resolving the dispute at formal mediation generally takes 6 to 9 months, completely avoiding a judge’s costs award.
- Full Civil Trial: Going to trial to win a formal costs order from a judge takes approximately 1.5 to 2 years.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What happens if I lose the trial?
The loser pays rule works both ways. If the judge completely dismisses your case, ruling that the employer gave you fair severance or had “just cause” to fire you, you may be ordered to pay 50% to 70% of the company’s legal fees.
Does the employer pay my lawyer directly?
Usually, the employer writes one large settlement cheque made out “in trust” to your law firm. Your lawyer will then deduct their agreed-upon fees and transfer the remaining balance of the severance and costs to you.
Can I get a costs award at the Ministry of Labour?
No. If you file an Employment Standards Act (ESA) claim through the Ministry of Labour rather than suing in civil court, there is no mechanism to have the employer pay your legal fees.
Does a contingency agreement change the costs award?
No. Even if you are not paying your lawyer upfront hourly fees, the court will still calculate the “costs award” based on the standard hourly rates of the lawyers who worked on your case, ensuring the employer still pays their share.
Leave a Reply