If you are unionized in Ontario and face workplace discrimination, your union must file a grievance on your behalf. If the union acts in bad faith, discriminates against you, or is entirely arbitrary in dropping your case, you can file a “Duty of Fair Representation” (DFR) complaint against the union at the Ontario Labour Relations Board (OLRB).
Working in a unionized environment in Ontario generally provides excellent job security and clear grievance procedures. Whether you are a nurse in London, a factory worker in Oshawa, or a municipal employee in Toronto, your collective agreement dictates how workplace disputes are handled. When it comes to human rights violations-such as racism, sexual harassment, or failure to accommodate a disability-your union is your exclusive legal representative. You cannot simply bypass the union and sue your employer in civil court.
But what happens when the union refuses to fight for you? ⚠ Sometimes, union stewards dismiss valid discrimination complaints because they are “too busy,” because they are protecting another union member who is the harasser, or due to sheer incompetence. When the entity designed to protect you leaves you stranded, the situation can feel utterly hopeless.
Under the Ontario Labour Relations Act, unions have a strict “Duty of Fair Representation” (DFR). They do not have to take every single grievance to arbitration, but they are legally forbidden from dropping your human rights case in a manner that is arbitrary, discriminatory, or in bad faith. Below is a step-by-step guide on how to hold your union accountable through the provincial labour board.
Step-by-Step Process for Filing a DFR Complaint in Ontario
Challenging your own union is a complex and highly procedural battle. You are essentially fighting two giants: your employer and your union leadership. 🔍 Follow these strict steps to ensure your complaint is heard at the Ontario Labour Relations Board.
Step 1: Exhaust the Internal Grievance Process
When you experience discrimination, immediately report it to your union steward and request that a grievance be filed under both the collective agreement and the Ontario Human Rights Code. Provide them with all your evidence, emails, and medical notes if seeking an accommodation.
If the local steward refuses to file the grievance, escalate the issue. 📞 Appeal the decision to the union president or the regional executive board. You must prove to the OLRB later that you actively tried to use the union’s internal appeal mechanisms before bringing a legal claim against them.
Step 2: File a Section 74 Complaint with the OLRB
If the union officially drops your grievance or refuses to take it to an arbitrator without a valid reason, you must file a Duty of Fair Representation complaint under Section 74 of the Labour Relations Act. This application is filed directly with the Ontario Labour Relations Board (OLRB) using Form A-29 (Application Regarding Union’s Duty of Fair Representation).
In your OLRB application, you must clearly articulate how the union’s decision was arbitrary (they didn’t even investigate), discriminatory (they ignored you because of your race/gender), or in bad faith (they dropped it for political reasons). 📋 Simply proving the union made a minor mistake or a poor judgment call is not enough to win a DFR claim.
Step 3: Understand the HRTO Deferral Rule
Many workers attempt to file a Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario (HRTO) application directly against the employer at the same time. Under Section 45 of the Human Rights Code, if a union grievance is already dealing with the human rights issue, the HRTO will “defer” (pause) your application.
However, if the union completely abandons your grievance, the HRTO may lift the deferral and allow you to proceed directly against the employer for the human rights violation, even while your OLRB case against the union is pending. ⌛ Consulting a specialized labour lawyer at this stage is crucial to manage these concurrent tribunals.
Step 4: Attend OLRB Mediation and Hearing
Once your DFR complaint is filed, the OLRB will schedule a mediation session involving you, the union, and the employer. The mediator will attempt to find a resolution, which often results in the union agreeing to re-open the grievance or the employer offering a modest settlement.
If mediation fails, a formal hearing will occur. If the OLRB vice-chair determines the union breached its duty, they can order the union to take your human rights grievance to arbitration and even order the union to pay for your independent legal counsel at that arbitration.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Taking legal action against a massive union requires strategic thinking and, often, independent legal funding. Here is a breakdown of costs for DFR complaints in Ontario:
| Service / Proceeding | Estimated Cost (CAD) |
|---|---|
| Internal Union Appeals | $0 (Covered by union dues) |
| Filing the DFR Complaint at OLRB | $0 (Free to file) |
| Independent Labour Lawyer (Consultation) | $350 – $600 |
| Lawyer Representation at OLRB Hearing | $5,000 – $15,000+ (Hourly billing) |
Unlike personal injury or standard employment law, it is very difficult to find a lawyer to take a DFR case on contingency, meaning you will likely have to pay hourly retainers to fight your union. 💵
How Long Does the Process Take?
You must act incredibly fast. The OLRB expects Duty of Fair Representation complaints to be filed promptly. If you wait more than 6 months after the union abandoned your grievance, the OLRB will likely dismiss your case for unreasonable delay.
Once filed, the OLRB process is relatively efficient. Mediation is usually scheduled within 2 to 3 months of the application. 📅 If the case goes to a full hearing, expect a final written decision from the labour board within 6 to 9 months of your initial filing.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I sue my union in a regular civil court?
No. In Ontario, civil courts (like the Superior Court of Justice) generally do not have jurisdiction over collective agreement disputes or union representation issues. You must use the Ontario Labour Relations Board for DFR complaints.
What if the union got a legal opinion saying my grievance is weak?
If the union genuinely investigated your claim, sought a legal opinion from union counsel, and determined the grievance would fail at arbitration, the OLRB will usually protect the union. A union is legally allowed to drop a weak case; they just cannot drop a case arbitrarily.
Can I name the union in my HRTO application?
Yes. If the union actively participated in the discrimination (e.g., they negotiated a discriminatory policy with the employer, or a union official harassed you), you can name the union as a co-respondent in your human rights application at the HRTO.
Can the OLRB award me money directly?
The primary remedy of a successful DFR complaint is ordering the union to process the grievance. However, in rare cases where the union’s delay caused you concrete financial harm, the OLRB can order the union to pay a portion of your lost wages or compensation.
Do I still have to pay union dues while fighting them?
Yes. As long as you remain employed in the bargaining unit, you are legally required to continue paying union dues under the Rand Formula, regardless of whether you have an active legal dispute against the union leadership.
Leave a Reply