In Ontario, if an independent contractor takes your money and fails to deliver, you can sue them in Small Claims Court for disputes up to $35,000 CAD. For larger amounts, you must file a Statement of Claim at the Superior Court of Justice, where the basic filing fee is $229 CAD.
Hiring an independent contractor is a great way to grow your business without taking on full-time employees. However, it can quickly become a nightmare if the freelancer takes a hefty deposit and simply disappears. When a crucial corporate project is abandoned, your business loses both time and money. Knowing how to sue a freelancer or independent contractor for failure to deliver in Ontario is an essential skill for any business owner.
Whether your business operates in Toronto, Ottawa, or Mississauga, ignoring a breach of contract is not a good strategy. 📍 Many companies feel that taking a contractor to court is too complicated, but the process is actually highly structured. By relying on the Ontario civil justice system, you may be entitled to recover your deposit and potentially other financial damages caused by the delay.
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
Taking legal action against a freelancer requires organization and clear evidence. The courts want to see that you had a valid agreement and that the contractor failed to meet their obligations. Here is the generally recommended path.
Step 1: Gather Your Contract and Evidence
Before contacting a law firm, you need to compile every piece of communication you have with the freelancer. The most critical document is your written contract or Statement of Work. 📄 Even if you only agreed via email or text messages, these written exchanges can still form a legally binding contract in Ontario.
You also need proof of payment. Gather your bank statements, e-transfer receipts, or cleared cheques showing exactly how much the contractor was paid. Next, document the incomplete work to prove that the independent contractor failed to deliver the final product.
Step 2: Send a Formal Demand Letter
Courts expect you to try to resolve the issue before filing a lawsuit. You or your lawyer should send a formal Demand Letter to the contractor. 📧 This letter should outline what they promised, how much they were paid, and give them a strict deadline (often 10 to 14 days) to either finish the work or refund the money.
Sending this letter by registered mail provides proof of delivery. Often, receiving a professional demand letter on a law firm’s letterhead is enough to scare a non-responsive freelancer into returning your deposit.
Step 3: Choose the Correct Court
If the freelancer ignores the letter, you must decide where to file your lawsuit based on the amount of money you are owed. 💰 In Ontario, your choice of court is strictly determined by the financial value of your claim.
| Court Name | Financial Limit | Legal Representation |
|---|---|---|
| Small Claims Court | Up to $35,000 CAD | You can represent yourself, or hire a paralegal or lawyer. |
| Superior Court of Justice | Over $35,000 CAD | Hiring a lawyer is highly recommended due to complex rules. |
Step 4: File and Serve the Claim
Once you select the court, you will file either a Plaintiff’s Claim (Small Claims) or a Statement of Claim (Superior Court). You must accurately describe the breach of contract and list the exact damages you are seeking. After the court issues the document, you must officially “serve” it to the freelancer, meaning you must deliver it to them personally or via an approved alternative method.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Pursuing legal action involves various upfront costs. You need to weigh these expenses against the amount the freelancer owes you. 💵 As of May 2026, here are the standard fees in CAD:
- Small Claims Filing Fees: Filing a Plaintiff’s Claim costs roughly $108 CAD. If you go to a settlement conference, it is free, but requesting a trial costs an additional $308 CAD.
- Superior Court Filing Fees: Filing a Statement of Claim requires a court fee of $229 CAD.
- Paralegal Fees: For Small Claims Court, hiring a licensed Ontario paralegal generally costs between $1,500 and $3,500 CAD for the entire process.
- Lawyer Fees: For larger cases in the Superior Court, business litigation lawyers typically charge between $350 and $700+ CAD per hour.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The civil justice system moves slowly, and timelines vary significantly depending on the court’s backlog in your specific city. If you sue in an Ontario Small Claims Court, expect the process to take 8 to 18 months from filing the claim to getting a trial date. If you must use the Superior Court of Justice, litigating a breach of contract can take anywhere from 2 to 4 years to fully resolve.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I sue if we only had an oral agreement?
Yes, verbal contracts are legally binding in Ontario. However, they are much harder to prove. You will need to rely heavily on emails, text messages, and bank transfers that show the intent and payment terms of the agreement.
What happens if the freelancer ignores the lawsuit?
If the independent contractor fails to file a Defence within 20 days of being served, you can ask the court to note them in default. The judge may then grant you a default judgment, which means you win the case automatically.
How do I collect my money after winning?
Winning the case does not magically put money in your bank. If the freelancer still refuses to pay, you must enforce the judgment. You can do this by garnishing their bank accounts or putting a lien on their property in Ontario.
Can I make the freelancer pay my legal fees?
If you win your case, Ontario judges will generally order the losing party to pay a portion of your legal costs. However, it is rarely 100%. Usually, you might recover 40% to 60% of your actual legal expenses.
Leave a Reply