In Ontario, the Working for Workers Act generally bans all employee non-compete agreements. However, a strict exception allows businesses to draft non-competes for individuals holding specific C-suite ‘executive’ roles under the Employment Standards Act, provided the geographic and temporal restrictions are highly reasonable and narrowly defined.
Protecting your company’s most sensitive strategic secrets is vital when a top-tier executive decides to leave. Historically, businesses used broad non-compete agreements to prevent any employee from joining a rival. However, Ontario’s labour laws have drastically shifted, making almost all standard non-competes completely illegal and void.
Today, whether your corporate headquarters is in Toronto, Ottawa, or Kitchener, the rules are incredibly strict. 📜 Under Bill 27 (the Working for Workers Act), the province instituted a blanket ban on non-compete clauses for normal workers. Thankfully, the law carved out a narrow, specific exception for C-Suite executives. Navigating this exemption requires careful legal drafting by a skilled business lawyer from our directory to ensure it holds up in court.
Additionally, while Ontario’s Employment Standards Act governs most businesses in the province, federally regulated employers (such as banks, airlines, railways, and telecommunications companies) operate under the Canada Labour Code. Historically, federal employers could rely on common-law non-compete rules. However, under the proposed Bill C-31 (Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 2) introduced in May 2026, the federal government plans to extend a similar ban on non-competes to federally regulated workplaces, while maintaining a narrow carve-out for C-suite executive positions.
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
Drafting an enforceable executive non-compete is a delicate balancing act. Ontario judges heavily favour an individual’s right to earn a living, so courts will aggressively scrutinize your contract. Here is how most law firms handle the drafting process.
Step 1: Verify the Executive Exemption Status
Before writing a single word, you must confirm that the employee legally qualifies for the exception. The Ontario Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) limits the non-compete exemption to specific individuals who hold an ‘executive’ office as defined under section 1(1) of the Act.
This definition explicitly includes nine designated C-suite positions: Chief Executive Officer (CEO), President, Chief Administrative Officer (CAO), Chief Operating Officer (COO), Chief Financial Officer (CFO), Chief Information Officer (CIO), Chief Legal Officer (CLO), Chief Human Resources Officer (CHRO), Chief Corporate Development Officer (CCDO), or any other chief executive position. 💼 Trying to sneak a non-compete onto a standard sales manager by giving them a fake ‘executive’ title will result in the contract being thrown out by a judge.
Step 2: Define a Reasonable Geographic Scope
A non-compete must be geographically limited to the areas where your business actually operates and holds significant market share. You cannot ban an executive from working anywhere in the world just to be safe.
If your company only operates in the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), the restriction should logically be limited to the GTA or Southern Ontario. 📍 Broad terms like ‘all of Canada’ or ‘North America’ are routinely struck down by the Superior Court of Justice as being overly broad and oppressive.
Step 3: Establish a Strict Time Limit
You cannot prevent an executive from competing against you forever. The time limit must represent the exact amount of time your business reasonably needs to secure its vulnerable market position after their departure.
Generally, Ontario courts will accept a temporal limit of 6 to 12 months. 📅 Anything exceeding 12 months becomes increasingly difficult to defend, and limits of 24 months or more are almost universally deemed unenforceable unless it involves the sale of a business.
Step 4: Detail the Restricted Activities
Finally, clearly define what the executive is prohibited from doing. You cannot ban them from working in the entire industry in any capacity.
The clause should only restrict them from taking a competitive executive role, starting a directly competing business, or working for specific, named direct competitors. 📝 The narrower and more precise the restriction, the higher the chance it survives judicial review.
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Executive contracts are high-stakes legal documents. A minor drafting error can invalidate the entire non-compete, leaving your trade secrets exposed. It is highly advisable to budget for top-tier legal advice.
- Lawyer Drafting Fees: Having a senior employment or corporate lawyer draft an executive employment contract typically ranges from $2,000 CAD to $5,000 CAD.
- Negotiation Costs: C-suite executives often hire their own lawyers to review the contract, meaning your legal team may need to negotiate terms. Expect hourly rates between $350 to $700 CAD for this back-and-forth process.
- Enforcement Litigation: If you must sue a departing CEO in the Superior Court of Justice to enforce the clause via an injunction, initial litigation costs can easily exceed $25,000 CAD to $50,000 CAD.
| Legal Restriction Type | Status for Regular Staff | Status for Chief Executives |
|---|---|---|
| Non-Compete Clause | Illegal & Void in Ontario | Legal if strictly reasonable |
| Non-Solicitation Clause | Legal if reasonable | Legal if reasonable |
| Confidentiality Agreement | Highly Enforceable | Highly Enforceable |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Drafting and negotiating a C-Suite executive employment agreement typically takes 2 to 4 weeks. ⌛ Executives rarely sign these documents immediately; they require time to have their own legal counsel review the restrictive covenants. If you are rushing to hire a new CEO, ensure you initiate this legal drafting process before offering them the final job.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What is the Working for Workers Act?
It is a package of Ontario legislation (specifically Bill 27) that updated the Employment Standards Act. Among other things, it outright banned employers from making standard employees sign non-compete agreements, citing that it suppresses wages and workers’ mobility.
Can I use a non-compete if I am selling my business?
Yes. The Ontario law also includes an exception for the sale of a business. If you buy a company, you can legally require the seller to sign a non-compete preventing them from taking your money and immediately opening a rival shop next door.
What happens if the judge thinks my non-compete is too broad?
In Ontario, courts reject the doctrine of ‘notional severance’ for restrictive covenants in employment contracts. Following the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Shafron v. KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc., if a restrictive covenant is too broad, the judge will refuse to ‘read it down’ to make it reasonable. Instead, they will simply strike the entire clause down, leaving you with zero protection.
How is a non-solicit different from a non-compete?
A non-compete stops an individual from working for a competitor altogether. A non-solicitation clause allows them to work for a competitor, but legally prevents them from poaching your clients, vendors, or current employees.
Leave a Reply