When you settle a wrongful dismissal claim in Newfoundland and Labrador, your lawyer can often negotiate to have your former employer pay a portion of your legal fees directly. This strategy can save you thousands of dollars and provides significant tax advantages under CRA rules.
Understanding Settlement Structures in Newfoundland and Labrador
Winning a wrongful dismissal negotiation is a huge relief, but many employees immediately worry about the cost of the victory. If your lawyer successfully negotiates a larger severance package for you in Grand Falls-Windsor, Conception Bay South, or St. John’s, you will owe them legal fees for their hard work. Whether you hired them on an hourly basis or through a contingency fee agreement (where they take a percentage), you might wonder how those funds actually change hands at the end of the dispute.
In standard litigation, each side usually pays their own lawyer. 📝 However, employment law settlements are unique. During the final negotiations, your lawyer will almost always ask the employer to contribute a specific sum of money directly toward your legal bill. Employers are often agreeable to this because it helps bridge the gap to reach a final deal. For example, instead of offering you $50,000 in taxable severance, they might offer you $45,000 in severance and $5,000 paid directly to your law firm to cover your fees.
This structure is highly beneficial due to Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) rules. Severance pay is taxable income. If your employer pays you the full amount, they must withhold a large chunk for taxes, leaving you with less money to pay your lawyer. By allocating a portion of the settlement specifically as “legal fees,” that specific amount is paid directly to your lawyer without any income tax being deducted by the employer, making the settlement far more tax-efficient for you.
Step-by-Step Process in Newfoundland and Labrador
Finalizing a severance negotiation requires careful legal drafting. The way the money is divided must be clearly documented to protect you from future tax audits. Here is the step-by-step process of how legal fees are handled when a deal is reached.
Step 1: Reaching an Agreement in Principle
After weeks of back-and-forth negotiations, your lawyer and the employer’s lawyer will finally agree on a total global settlement amount. 💰 For example, they agree to settle your wrongful dismissal claim for $60,000 CAD. At this stage, it is just a handshake deal. The next crucial step is deciding exactly how that $60,000 pie will be sliced up into different categories.
Step 2: Allocating the Funds
Your lawyer will instruct the employer on how to divide the funds. A portion will be designated as a “Retiring Allowance” (severance pay), which is subject to CRA tax withholdings. Another portion will be specifically designated as a “contribution to legal fees.” If you have unused vacation pay or regular wages owed, those will be categorized separately as regular employment income. Proper allocation ensures you keep as much of the money as legally possible.
Step 3: Drafting the Minutes of Settlement
Once the math is agreed upon, the employer’s legal team will draft a binding contract usually called the “Minutes of Settlement” or a “Full and Final Release.” 📄 This document outlines the exact payment structure. It will state that the employer is issuing one cheque payable to you (minus taxes) and a second cheque payable directly to your law firm “in trust” for the agreed-upon legal fees.
Step 4: Signing the Release
You and your lawyer will review the release carefully. By signing this document, you are formally agreeing to drop any existing complaints with the Labour Standards Division or the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador, and you promise never to sue the company again regarding your employment. Once signed, the employer has a legal obligation to send the funds.
Step 5: The Trust Account and Final Cheque
The employer will mail the cheques to your lawyer’s trust account. Your lawyer will deposit the funds, deduct any remaining fees or disbursements you owe them (if the employer’s contribution didn’t cover the entire contingency percentage), and then issue you a final cheque from the law firm for the remainder of your settlement.
How Much Does it Cost in Newfoundland and Labrador?
While the employer may pay a portion of your fees, you are still ultimately responsible for your lawyer’s total bill. 💵 If you agreed to a 30% contingency fee on a $50,000 settlement, your total legal bill is $15,000. Here is an example of how an employer contribution helps in CAD:
| Settlement Allocation Example | Amount (CAD) |
|---|---|
| Total Global Settlement Reached | $50,000 |
| Employer Pays Directly to Your Legal Fees | $5,000 (Tax-free to lawyer) |
| Your Severance Pay (Before taxes) | $45,000 |
| Remaining Legal Fees You Owe from Your Cut | $10,000 |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Once you verbally agree to a settlement, you still have to wait for the paperwork and the money. Drafting and signing the Release usually takes 1 to 2 weeks. After the document is signed, the employer generally has 14 to 30 days to process the payroll, cut the cheques, and mail them to your lawyer. Your lawyer will then issue your final funds within a few business days of the cheques clearing the trust account.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can my lawyer just take their fee out of my severance pay?
Yes. If the employer refuses to allocate a separate cheque for legal fees, the employer will pay the entire settlement to your lawyer in trust. Your lawyer will simply deduct their contingency fee percentage from the total amount before sending you the rest.
Will the employer pay 100% of my legal fees?
In a settlement negotiation, it is extremely rare for an employer to cover 100% of your legal fees. They usually only agree to contribute a small portion (often $2,000 to $5,000) as an incentive to get you to sign the final release.
Are the legal fees I pay out-of-pocket tax deductible?
According to the CRA, you can generally deduct legal fees paid to collect or establish a right to a retiring allowance (severance pay). You should request a detailed invoice from your lawyer and consult a tax accountant when filing your taxes the following spring.
What happens if the employer doesn’t send the cheque?
If you have a signed Minutes of Settlement and the employer fails to pay by the agreed deadline, they are in breach of contract. Your lawyer can quickly file an application with the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador to enforce the settlement and demand extra penalties.
Why is the cheque made out “in trust” to my lawyer?
A law firm’s trust account is a highly regulated, secure bank account where client money is held safely. The employer sends the funds there so the lawyer can ensure the legal fees are paid and that your portion is securely transferred to you without issue.
Leave a Reply