For charity bingo or casino nights to remain tax-exempt in Canada, the non-profit must maintain total operational control and ensure proceeds strictly fund their mandate. If the CRA’s Charities Directorate threatens to revoke your status or assess GST/HST, filing an immediate Notice of Objection (which has no government fee) is critical to survival.
Across Canada, from local community centres in Manitoba to large halls in Ontario, charity casinos and bingo nights are a massive source of fundraising. Dedicated volunteers spend countless hours running 50/50 draws, pull-tickets, and table games to fund minor hockey leagues, hospitals, and food banks. However, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) keeps a very close eye on these events to ensure they are genuinely charitable and not secret commercial enterprises.
When the CRA’s Charities Directorate launches an audit into your non-profit’s gaming activities, the stakes are incredibly high. 📝 If they determine your charity has ceded too much control to a commercial casino operator, or that your volunteers are secretly being paid, you could face massive retroactive GST/HST liabilities or even the complete revocation of your charitable status. This guide explains how to defend your gaming exemptions and prove your operations comply with federal law.
Step-by-Step Process in Canada for Defending a Charity Gaming Audit
While provincial bodies like the AGCO (Ontario) or AGLC (Alberta) issue your gaming licenses, the CRA governs your tax-exempt status federally. Navigating an audit requires proving that your charity meets both provincial gaming rules and federal tax laws.
Step 1: Establishing Operational Control
The most crucial element of a CRA charity gaming audit is “direction and control.” 🔍 If your charity merely lends its name to a commercial casino in exchange for a cheque, the CRA will strip your exemption. You must provide meeting minutes, contracts, and volunteer schedules to prove that your board of directors makes the actual decisions regarding the event, handles the banking, and oversees the operations.
Step 2: Auditing the Volunteer vs. Paid Staff Records
Under Canadian law, charity gaming events must largely be run by volunteers to maintain their specific GST/HST exemptions. 🤝 If the CRA discovers that you are paying “stipends” or “honorariums” that essentially act as an hourly wage for dealing cards or calling bingo, they will classify it as a commercial business. Gather your volunteer logs and expense reimbursement forms to prove that no one is earning an unauthorized income.
Step 3: Tracking the Flow of Gaming Proceeds
The CRA auditor will trace every dollar from the bingo hall to your bank account. 💵 Registered charities must devote their resources to their charitable purposes. If gaming funds are sitting in general accounts, or worse, being used to pay excessive commercial rent to the bingo hall owner, the CRA will issue severe penalties. You need clean ledgers showing exactly which charitable programs the gaming money funded.
Step 4: Responding to the Administrative Fairness Letter (AFL)
If the CRA finds compliance issues, they will issue an Administrative Fairness Letter (AFL) outlining their intent to penalize your organization or revoke your charitable status. 📬 You typically have 30 to 60 days to respond. This is where a charity tax lawyer must draft a comprehensive legal response, showing how you have corrected administrative errors and why revocation is too harsh a penalty.
Step 5: Filing an Objection or Appeal
If the Charities Directorate finalizes the revocation or issues a massive GST/HST assessment, you must take formal legal action. 🗡 For tax assessments, you file a Notice of Objection with the CRA Appeals branch within 90 days. If they issue a formal Notice of Intention to Revoke your charitable registration, your lawyer must immediately file an appeal with the Federal Court of Appeal to delay the publication of the revocation.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Defending a registered charity against the federal government is a serious legal undertaking, and board members should authorize spending to protect the organization. 💰 Expected costs include:
- Notice of Objection Fees: Submitting a standard Notice of Objection to the CRA for GST/HST reassessments is entirely free.
- Legal and Accounting Fees: Hiring a law firm specializing in non-profit tax law to respond to an AFL or draft an objection typically costs between $5,000 and $15,000 CAD.
- Federal Court Appeals: If the CRA attempts to revoke your charitable status and you must file in the Federal Court of Appeal, litigation costs can quickly escalate beyond $20,000 CAD.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Charity audits are notoriously exhaustive. 🕙 The initial review by the Charities Directorate can last anywhere from 6 to 18 months, as they often demand years of historical records. If you receive an AFL and subsequently file a Notice of Objection, expect another 12 to 24 months of waiting. Maintaining your provincial gaming licenses during this turbulent period is critical to keeping the charity afloat.
| Event Structure | GST/HST Status | CRA View on Charity Status |
|---|---|---|
| 100% Volunteer-run Bingo in a community hall. | Exempt | Fully compliant; proceeds must go to mandate. |
| Charity hires commercial casino to run the event entirely. | Taxable (Commercial) | High Risk; likely considered an unrelated business. |
| Volunteers receive a $200 “stipend” per night. | Subject to audit | Non-compliant; treated as untaxed employment income. |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Do we have to charge GST/HST on charity bingo cards?
Generally, no. Sales of bingo cards, raffle tickets, and lottery tickets by a registered charity or non-profit organization are exempt from GST/HST under the Excise Tax Act, provided the event meets the strict definitions of a charitable gaming event.
Can we reimburse volunteers for their travel to the casino?
Yes. Reimbursing volunteers for reasonable, out-of-pocket expenses (like gas or a modest meal) is completely legal and does not void your volunteer exemption. However, you must keep the original receipts; flat-rate cash payouts are heavily scrutinized by the CRA.
What happens if the CRA revokes our charitable status?
Revocation is a death sentence for a charity. You will lose the ability to issue tax receipts, you must pay a 100% revocation tax on all your remaining assets (essentially transferring everything to the government), and your provincial gaming regulator will immediately cancel your casino licenses.
Can the CRA audit our provincial gaming license?
While the CRA does not enforce provincial rules, they work closely with bodies like the AGCO or AGLC. If you are found to be violating your provincial license (such as misuse of funds), the CRA will use that as grounds to revoke your federal charitable status.
Leave a Reply