In British Columbia, you cannot easily disinherit a spouse or child. Under the Wills, Estates and Succession Act (WESA), a disinherited spouse or child can apply to the Supreme Court of British Columbia to vary (rewrite) your Will if it fails to make “adequate provision” for their proper maintenance and support.
Drafting a Will is usually a straightforward process, but complex family dynamics can make things incredibly difficult. You may have an estranged adult child, or you may be in a second marriage and want to leave everything to your biological children. While the law generally respects your “testamentary autonomy” (your right to choose who gets your money), British Columbia has some of the strictest estate laws in Canada when it comes to protecting immediate family members.
Unlike other provinces where you can often leave an independent adult child out of your Will completely, BC operates under the Wills, Estates and Succession Act (WESA). ⚠️ WESA gives judges the extraordinary power to step in and rewrite your Will after your death. If your spouse (including a common-law partner) or your biological or adopted children feel they were unfairly left out, they can launch a wills variation claim to demand a fairer share of the estate.
Step-by-Step Process in British Columbia: WESA Variation Claims
Whether your estate is located in Vancouver, Victoria, or Kelowna, the rules under WESA apply uniformly across the province. Attempting to disinherit a close family member requires meticulous legal planning. Here is how the process of disinheritance and a potential WESA challenge generally unfolds.
Step 1: Drafting the Will and Memorandum of Wishes
If you intend to leave a spouse or child out of your Will, you must work with a local Law Firm. Simply leaving their name out is a massive mistake. 📝 Your Lawyer will typically draft a detailed “Memorandum of Wishes.” This is a separate, confidential document kept with your Will that explains your exact, rational reasons for the disinheritance (such as a 20-year estrangement or the fact that you already gifted them a house during your lifetime).
Step 2: The Grant of Probate
After your passing, your appointed executor must apply to the Supreme Court of British Columbia for a Grant of Probate. During this process, the executor is legally required to notify all your children and your spouse, even if they were completely disinherited in the Will. This notice alerts them to their legal right to challenge the estate.
Step 3: Filing the Wills Variation Claim
Once probate is granted, the disinherited spouse or child has a strict 180-day limitation period to file a civil lawsuit against the estate. 💵 They will argue that you failed your “moral duty” or “legal duty” to provide for them. The executor must freeze the estate assets and cannot distribute the money to your chosen beneficiaries while the lawsuit is active.
Step 4: The Court’s Decision
If the dispute is not settled out of court through mediation, a judge will review the case. The court will look at the size of the estate, the financial need of the person suing, and your written reasons for disinheriting them. If the judge finds your reasons were inaccurate, unfair, or vindictive, they will issue a court order rewriting the Will to grant a portion of the estate to the challenger.
How Much Does it Cost in British Columbia?
Attempting to disinherit someone, and the inevitable WESA challenge, carries significant financial costs for the estate and the challenger:
- Estate Planning: Having a Law Firm draft a complex Will and a Memorandum of Wishes typically costs between $800 and $2,500 CAD.
- Probate Fees: The BC government charges roughly 1.4% on the gross value of the estate exceeding $50,000 CAD.
- WESA Litigation (Challenger): Hiring an estate litigation Lawyer to challenge a Will often requires an initial retainer of $5,000 to $10,000 CAD, with total trial costs frequently exceeding $50,000 CAD.
- Estate Defence Costs: The executor’s legal fees to defend the Will are usually paid out of the estate funds, severely depleting the inheritance left for your chosen beneficiaries.
How Long Does the Process Take?
Drafting a Will with disinheritance clauses usually takes 2 to 4 weeks. After death, obtaining the Grant of Probate in BC takes approximately 3 to 6 months. The disinherited family member then has exactly 180 days from the date probate is issued to commence a WESA variation claim. If a lawsuit is filed, estate litigation in the BC Supreme Court is notoriously slow, typically taking 1 to 3 years to reach a settlement or trial judgment.
| Disinherited Party | Court’s View of Legal / Moral Duty | Likelihood of Successful Challenge |
|---|---|---|
| Spouse / Common-Law Partner | Highest duty. Analogous to Spousal Support obligations upon separation. | Very High (Unless heavily compensated outside the Will). |
| Minor or Disabled Child | Extremely high legal duty to provide necessities of life. | Very High (Courts almost always intervene). |
| Independent Adult Child | Moral duty exists, but it can be negated by valid, rational reasons. | Moderate (Depends heavily on the Memorandum of Wishes). |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I just leave my child $1 so they cannot sue me?
No. Leaving a token amount like $1 CAD is a common myth and provides zero legal protection in British Columbia. If the court determines that $1 is not “adequate provision” for their proper maintenance, they will still rewrite the Will under WESA.
Does a prenuptial agreement stop my spouse from challenging my Will?
A valid marriage agreement (prenup) is a strong piece of evidence, but it does not completely eliminate a spouse’s right to challenge a Will under WESA. The court will consider the agreement, but if it is extremely unfair, the judge may still alter the estate distribution.
How can I transfer assets without them going through WESA?
Assets that pass outside of your estate do not go through probate and are generally safe from WESA variation claims. This includes naming a direct beneficiary on your RRSPs, TFSAs, and life insurance, or holding property in joint tenancy (though joint tenancy with adult children carries its own legal risks).
Can my step-children challenge my Will?
Generally, no. Under WESA, only biological and legally adopted children have the standing to apply for a wills variation. Unadopted step-children do not have an automatic right to challenge the Will for adequate provision.
Leave a Reply