If a crucial witness deliberately ignores a lawful subpoena or flees to avoid testifying in a Canadian federal trial, a judge can issue a “material witness warrant” under Section 705 of the Criminal Code. This compels law enforcement to track down, arrest, and forcibly bring the witness to court, ensuring vital evidence is presented in cases involving a summary conviction or indictable offence.
The Canadian justice system relies heavily on the testimony of witnesses to uncover the truth. 🗣️ Whether it is a complex corporate fraud trial in Toronto or a violent assault case in Edmonton, firsthand accounts are the bedrock of a fair trial. When someone is identified as possessing crucial evidence, the Crown prosecutor or the defence law firm will serve them with a formal subpoena (a command to attend court). However, witnesses are often reluctant. They may fear retaliation, simply want to avoid missing work, or have deep-seated mistrust of the legal system.
While reluctance is understandable, completely ignoring a subpoena is a severe violation of federal law. You cannot simply “opt out” of the justice system. When a vital witness runs away, hides, or stubbornly refuses to show up, the court has powerful tools to ensure compliance. Under the Canadian Criminal Code, a judge can authorize a material witness warrant. This document transforms the witness from an innocent bystander into a fugitive subject to arrest. This guide explains the legal mechanics of how and why witnesses are arrested to compel their testimony in Canada.
Step-by-Step Process for a Material Witness Warrant in Canada
Arresting someone simply because they hold information is an extreme infringement on their liberty. 📍 Therefore, the courts follow a highly strict procedure before signing off on a material witness warrant.
Step 1: Lawful Service of the Subpoena
Before a warrant can be issued, the court must be absolutely certain the witness knew they had to be there. The subpoena must be properly served, usually in person by a process server or a police officer. The document explicitly states the time, date, and location of the court appearance, and carries a clear warning about the legal consequences of failing to attend.
Step 2: The Witness Fails to Appear
On the day of the trial, the court clerk will call the witness’s name. 👥 If they are absent, the lawyer who requested the witness (either the Crown or the defence) must prove to the judge that the subpoena was lawfully served. They must also swear an oath or present an affidavit explaining why this specific person’s testimony is “material” (essential) to the case, and that a summary conviction or indictable offence cannot be fairly tried without them.
Step 3: Judicial Issuance of the Warrant
If the judge is satisfied that the witness was served, has crucial evidence, and is evading the court, they will issue a warrant in “Form 17” under Section 705 of the Criminal Code. This is a nationwide federal order. It authorizes any peace officer in Canada to locate the individual, arrest them, and physically transport them to the presiding courthouse.
Step 4: The Arrest and Detention
Once located, the police will arrest the witness. 🚨 Unlike a standard criminal suspect, the witness is not being arrested for committing the underlying crime, but for evading the court. They will be transported in a police cruiser and placed in a holding cell. They have the immediate right to contact their own law firm for legal advice.
Step 5: Testifying and Release
The witness will be brought directly before the judge. Depending on the trial’s schedule, the judge may order them to testify immediately. Alternatively, if the trial is postponed, the judge may require the witness to sign a recognizance (a financial pledge) promising to return on a new date, or in extreme flight-risk cases, they could be held in custody until they give their testimony on the stand.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Being a witness is generally a public duty, but if you are arrested as a material witness, you may face unexpected legal and financial burdens. 💵 Here is a look at the estimated costs in CAD.
| Witness Conduct Money (Provided to you) | $10 to $50+ (Minimal per diem provided with the subpoena) |
| Retaining a Lawyer (For the Witness) | $1,500 to $5,000+ (To negotiate release from custody) |
| Contempt of Court Fines | Up to $5,000+ (If the judge decides to penalize your absence) |
| Lost Wages | Varies (The court does not reimburse standard lost wages) |
How Long Does the Process Take?
A material witness warrant remains active indefinitely until the witness is found or the underlying trial concludes. ⏱ Once arrested, the police are legally required to bring the witness before a judge without unreasonable delay, usually within 24 hours. If the witness is forced to stay in custody to ensure they testify, it typically lasts only a few days until they take the stand, after which they are immediately released.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I “Plead the Fifth” so I don’t have to testify?
No. The “Fifth Amendment” is an American concept. In Canada, under Section 13 of the Charter and the Canada Evidence Act, a subpoenaed witness is legally forced to answer all questions. However, the law protects you by ensuring your truthful testimony cannot be used against you in future criminal proceedings.
Is ignoring a subpoena an indictable offence?
Ignoring a subpoena is typically handled as “contempt of court” rather than a standalone summary conviction or indictable offence. However, a judge has broad powers to punish contempt, including imposing heavy fines or even brief jail time for defying the court.
What if I missed court by accident or was sick?
If it was a genuine medical emergency, you must immediately contact the Crown prosecutor or the law firm that subpoenaed you and provide a doctor’s note. A judge will usually cancel a warrant if they are convinced the absence was an unavoidable accident rather than intentional evasion.
Can a material witness hire their own lawyer?
Absolutely. If you are arrested on a material witness warrant or feel that your testimony might accidentally incriminate you, you have the constitutional right to retain independent legal counsel to advise you while you are on the stand.
Do I get paid for my time off work?
Unfortunately, no. The justice system pays a very minor travel allowance (conduct money), but it does not reimburse you for lost wages or missed business opportunities while you are testifying. It is considered a mandatory civic duty.
Leave a Reply