Hiding, transferring, or selling your assets to avoid paying debt is not just a civil dispute; under Section 392 of the Criminal Code of Canada, disposing of property to defraud creditors is a serious offence that can lead to up to two years in prison.
When an individual or a corporation in Canada falls into severe financial distress, the pressure from creditors can be overwhelming. 💳 In a panic, some debtors attempt to protect their hard-earned assets by quietly transferring a house to a spouse, selling a luxury vehicle to a friend for one dollar, or moving cash to an offshore account right before filing for bankruptcy. While they might view this as a clever survival tactic, the federal government views it as outright fraud.
Under Section 392 of the Criminal Code of Canada, any person who destroys, gives away, conceals, or disposes of their property with the intent to defraud their creditors is committing a crime. This goes far beyond the civil remedies available in bankruptcy court. If the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), a bank, or a Licensed Insolvency Trustee discovers that you have purposefully hidden assets to avoid paying your legal debts, you could be facing either a summary conviction or an indictable offence. Navigating these allegations generally requires the immediate expertise of a seasoned criminal defence lawyer.
Step-by-Step Process: How Asset Concealment Becomes a Criminal Matter
Most insolvency disputes are handled quietly in civil courts across provinces like Ontario, Manitoba, and British Columbia. However, when blatant fraud is detected, the process escalates to the criminal justice system. Here is how that transition occurs.
Step 1: The Trigger—Insolvency and Trustee Audits
The journey to criminal charges often begins when a debtor files for a consumer proposal or bankruptcy. 📋 By law, a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) must review your financial history for the past several years. They look closely at “reviewable transactions”—assets sold for less than fair market value or sudden transfers to family members. If the LIT uncovers a blatant scheme to hide wealth, they are legally obligated to report this to the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) and the RCMP.
Step 2: Proving the “Intent to Defraud”
It is not a crime to simply sell your car to pay rent. To secure a conviction under Section 392, the Crown prosecutor must prove that your intent was specifically to cheat your creditors. Police investigators will subpoena bank records, text messages, and emails. If they find evidence that you said, “Let’s put the cottage in your name so the bank can’t take it,” they have clear proof of your criminal intent (mens rea).
Step 3: Reversing the Civil Conveyance
Before or alongside the criminal trial, creditors or your LIT will usually utilize provincial Fraudulent Conveyance Acts to reverse the transfer. 🔁 This means civil court judges will void the sale, seize the hidden property from your friend or family member, and sell it to pay down your debts. The person who helped you hide the asset may also face severe legal consequences for participating in the scheme.
Step 4: Facing Federal Criminal Prosecution
Once the RCMP lays charges under Section 392 of the Criminal Code, you will be required to appear in a provincial Superior Court. ⚖️ The Crown can choose to proceed by summary conviction for smaller offences, or by indictment for major, calculated frauds. Having a top-tier law firm by your side is essential, as the defence often hinges on proving that the property transfer was a legitimate, good-faith transaction made during a difficult business restructuring, not a malicious fraud.
How Much Does it Cost to Defend a Fraudulent Disposal Charge?
Attempting to save money by hiding assets usually results in catastrophic financial losses. Here are the potential costs in Canadian dollars (CAD) if you are caught:
- Criminal Penalties: If convicted of an indictable offence, you face up to 2 years in prison. A summary conviction can still result in severe fines and a permanent criminal record.
- Loss of the Asset: Civil courts will seize the property, meaning you lose both the asset and the money you thought you saved.
- Criminal Defence Fees: Retaining a lawyer for a white-collar fraud trial is expensive, typically ranging from $15,000 to $50,000+ CAD depending on the complexity of the paper trail.
- Bankruptcy Denial: If you commit fraud, your discharge from bankruptcy will be opposed, leaving you permanently stuck with your original debts.
| Offence Route | Maximum Prison Sentence | Statute of Limitations |
|---|---|---|
| Summary Conviction | Up to 2 years less a day | 12 months from the offence |
| Indictable Offence | Up to 2 years | No limit |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Investigating and prosecuting financial fraud is a lengthy endeavour. A forensic audit by a bankruptcy trustee and the RCMP can take 1 to 2 years to gather sufficient evidence. ⌛ Once formal charges are laid, progressing through the criminal courts can take an additional 18 to 30 months. During this stressful, multi-year period, your assets may be completely frozen by court order, heavily restricting your personal and business finances.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What if I sold my car to my brother for $1 just to help him out?
If you were insolvent or knew creditors were about to sue you when you made the sale, it will be heavily scrutinized as a fraudulent transfer. Even if your primary goal was to help your brother, effectively depriving your creditors of an asset they could seize is illegal.
Can a corporation be charged under Section 392?
Yes. If corporate directors empty the company bank accounts and transfer the funds to a newly created “numbered company” right before defaulting on commercial loans, both the directors and the corporation itself can face severe criminal charges.
Does a consumer proposal stop this investigation?
No. While a consumer proposal stops civil collection actions (like wage garnishments), it does not halt a federal criminal investigation. If the trustee discovers fraud while administrating your proposal, they must report it.
What is the difference between this and tax evasion?
Tax evasion involves lying on your tax returns to avoid paying the CRA. Disposing of property to defraud creditors applies to hiding physical assets or cash to avoid paying any legitimate creditor, whether it is a bank, a supplier, or the government.
Leave a Reply