Under Canadian law, you can absolutely be charged with an attempted crime if you go beyond “mere preparation” and take a direct, actionable step toward committing an offence. The penalties for an attempted indictable offence can be extremely severe, sometimes resulting in up to life in prison depending on the nature of the crime.
When most people think of the criminal justice system, they picture someone being arrested after successfully stealing a car, committing an assault, or breaking into a home. However, what happens if you plan a crime, gather the tools, and get caught right before you actually do it? 🕵 In Canada, the law does not require you to successfully finish a crime to be held legally accountable. The Criminal Code of Canada contains strict provisions regarding “attempts,” meaning your intentions combined with your physical actions can land you in serious legal trouble.
The crucial legal battle in these cases always revolves around the fine line between “mere preparation” and an actual “attempt.” Simply thinking about a crime or casually researching it online is generally not enough for a conviction. But if you purchase a weapon and drive to the target location in Toronto, Ontario, or Vancouver, British Columbia, the police will likely argue you crossed that line. Navigating this highly complex area of federal criminal law requires an experienced local Canadian lawyer from our directory to build a robust defence and protect your future.
Step-by-Step Process of an Attempt Charge in Canada
Whether you are facing accusations in Calgary, Alberta, or Halifax, Nova Scotia, the federal criminal process for an attempt charge follows a very specific pathway. 📍
Step 1: The Police Investigation of Intent
The process begins when local police or the RCMP intercept a suspected crime before it concludes. Officers will look for physical evidence of your intent. For example, buying a ski mask is considered mere preparation. However, putting that mask on and walking toward a bank door transitions into a criminal attempt. The police will gather surveillance footage, text messages, and witness statements to prove you intended to carry out the specific indictable offence.
Step 2: Crown Prosecutor’s Assessment
Once arrested, the police hand the file to the Crown prosecutor. The Crown must strictly evaluate if they have enough evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you had the specific intent to commit the crime and that you took a direct step toward its execution. 📁 If the Crown feels the evidence only proves you were “preparing” but hadn’t actually attempted it yet, they may drop the charge or pivot to a different offence, such as conspiracy or possession of break-in instruments.
Step 3: The Bail Hearing
If the Crown proceeds with a serious charge like Attempted Murder or Attempted Robbery, you will be held for a bail hearing. Depending on the severity of the intended crime and your prior criminal record, securing bail can be highly difficult. Your lawyer will generally propose a strict release plan, which may include house arrest, a large financial surety from family members, or mandatory GPS ankle monitoring to ensure public safety while awaiting trial.
Step 4: Trial and Defending the “Mere Preparation” Argument
At trial, your defence lawyer will fiercely challenge the Crown’s narrative. The most common and effective legal defence is arguing that your actions were purely preparatory and that you had not yet committed to the final act. 👮 Furthermore, a lawyer might argue that you voluntarily abandoned the plan before any real attempt was made. Because the legal definition of an attempt is heavily based on complex common law precedents, professional legal representation is absolutely essential.
How Much Does a Criminal Defence Lawyer Cost?
Defending an attempt charge is just as legally intensive as defending a completed crime. Lawyer fees in CAD vary drastically based on the severity of the offence (summary conviction vs indictable offence) and the length of the trial. 💰
| Legal Service / Stage | Estimated Lawyer Fees (CAD) |
|---|---|
| Initial Bail Hearing | $1,500 – $4,000 Flat Fee |
| Summary Conviction Trial (e.g., Attempted Theft) | $3,000 – $7,500 Flat Fee |
| Indictable Offence Trial (e.g., Attempted Robbery) | $10,000 – $25,000+ |
| Attempted Murder Defence | $30,000 – $100,000+ (Hourly or Flat) |
How Long Does the Process Take?
The Canadian justice system aims to process criminal charges within strict time limits to respect your Charter rights. Generally, a less severe summary conviction attempt must be brought to trial within 18 months. For highly complex indictable offences proceeding in a superior court, the trial must realistically conclude within 30 months from the date the charges were laid. Delays caused by the defence (such as changing lawyers) are not counted against this strict federal timeline.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is the punishment for an attempted crime the same as the completed crime?
Generally, the maximum penalty for an attempt is half the maximum penalty of the completed crime. However, if the completed crime carries a mandatory life sentence (like murder), an attempted murder conviction can still result in a maximum of life in prison.
What if it was physically impossible to commit the crime?
In Canada, “factual impossibility” is not a legal defence. If you attempt to pick a pocket, but the victim’s pocket is completely empty, you can still be fully charged and convicted of attempted theft because your criminal intent and actions were present.
Does changing my mind right before the crime save me from charges?
This is known as the defence of “abandonment.” If your lawyer can successfully prove that you voluntarily completely abandoned your criminal intent before crossing the line from preparation to attempt, you may avoid a conviction.
Can I be charged with attempted assault?
Yes. If you swing a baseball bat at someone’s head and completely miss, you have attempted to apply intentional force. The police will charge you with assault, or potentially assault with a weapon, based on the attempted application of force.
Will an attempted crime show up on a Canadian criminal record check?
Yes. If you are formally convicted of an attempt, it will permanently appear on your RCMP CPIC criminal record, just as if you had completed the crime. It will heavily impact your employment and cross-border travel.
Leave a Reply