If you are falsely served with an Emergency Protection Order (EPO) in Prince Edward Island, do not contact the applicant under any circumstances. You have the right to challenge the order at a mandatory Supreme Court review hearing, but breaching the order beforehand is a criminal offence that can lead to immediate arrest.
Family violence is a serious issue in Prince Edward Island, and the laws are designed to protect vulnerable individuals quickly. 👮 However, during high-conflict separations or intense custody battles, some individuals misuse the system by filing false allegations to gain an unfair advantage in family court. If you have been served with an Emergency Protection Order (EPO) based on exaggerated or fabricated claims, it is a terrifying experience. You might be forced out of your home in Summerside or barred from seeing your children in Charlottetown. Understanding how to legally and calmly defend yourself is critical to protecting your reputation, your freedom, and your parenting time.
Step-by-Step Process to Defend Yourself in PEI
In PEI, Emergency Protection Orders are often granted ex parte, meaning the Justice of the Peace only heard the other person’s side of the story before issuing the order. 🏱 The law, however, requires that all EPOs be reviewed by a judge at the Supreme Court of Prince Edward Island shortly after they are issued. This review hearing is your critical opportunity to present the truth.
Step 1: Obey the Order Completely
The moment you are served with the documents by the police, you must comply with every single condition, even if the allegations are complete lies. 🚫 Do not call, text, email, or send messages through third parties (like friends or family) to the applicant. Breaching an EPO is a separate criminal offence; you can be arrested and criminally charged, which will ruin your credibility in court regardless of whether the original allegations were false.
Step 2: Retain a Local Family Lawyer Immediately
Defending against an EPO is not a do-it-yourself situation. 💼 You need a lawyer who understands both family law and the rules of evidence in PEI. Your lawyer will review the applicant’s Affidavit (the sworn statement where they made their allegations) to identify inconsistencies, exaggerations, and outright falsehoods.
Step 3: Gather Exculpatory Evidence
To prove the allegations are false, you need concrete proof. 📱 Gather all recent text messages, emails, voicemails, and social media interactions between you and the applicant. For example, if they claim they were terrified of you on a Tuesday, but you have text messages from them on Wednesday inviting you over for coffee, this is powerful evidence for your defence. You can also gather GPS data, receipts, or witness statements to prove you were not present when an alleged incident occurred.
Step 4: Prepare Your Sworn Affidavit
You will need to tell your side of the story in a formal, sworn document called an Affidavit. 📝 Your lawyer will help you draft this document carefully. It must remain factual, calm, and objective. Do not use this document to hurl insults at your ex-partner; instead, methodically dismantle their claims using your gathered evidence.
Step 5: Attend the Supreme Court Review Hearing
Within a few days of the EPO being issued, a mandatory review hearing will take place at the Supreme Court. 👤 Your lawyer will present your evidence and argue that the order is unnecessary or based on falsehoods. The judge may decide to cancel (revoke) the order, confirm it, or replace it with a less restrictive civil restraining order or a mutual no-contact agreement.
| Action | Consequence in Court |
|---|---|
| Texting the applicant to ask “Why did you do this?” | Immediate arrest for breaching the protection order. |
| Going to the house to grab your laptop | Arrest, unless you have a police escort approved by the order. |
| Providing GPS data proving you were at work | Strong evidence that the applicant committed perjury. |
| Posting angrily about the situation on Facebook | Used against you by the applicant to show erratic behaviour. |
How Much Does it Cost in Prince Edward Island?
Defending yourself against false allegations is an unexpected financial burden. 💵 Here are the typical costs in CAD:
- Initial Consultation: Many PEI lawyers charge between $200 and $400 CAD for a one-hour consultation to review the EPO.
- Lawyer Fees for the Hearing: Drafting your Affidavit and representing you at the Supreme Court review hearing typically costs between $2,000 and $5,000 CAD, depending on the complexity of the evidence.
- Cost Awards: If the judge determines the applicant intentionally lied and abused the court process, they may order the applicant to reimburse you for a portion of your legal fees.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The system is designed to be fast. ⏱️ After an EPO is granted, the mandatory review hearing at the Supreme Court of Prince Edward Island usually takes place within 5 to 14 working days. Until that hearing occurs, you must endure the restrictions of the order.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What if the applicant invites me over while the order is active?
Do not go. The applicant does not have the power to cancel the order-only a judge can. If you go over, even with their permission, you are breaching the court order and the police can arrest you.
Will this EPO show up on a criminal record check?
An EPO is a civil order, not a criminal conviction. However, it will appear in police databases. If you breach the order, you will be charged criminally, and that conviction will permanently remain on your criminal record.
How does a false EPO affect my parenting time?
An EPO often strictly prohibits contact with the applicant, which severely complicates child exchanges. If the order includes the children, your parenting time is temporarily suspended. Your lawyer must urgently address this at the review hearing to restore your access.
Can I sue my ex for making false allegations?
While it is very difficult to sue for defamation in family law contexts due to legal privilege, a judge can severely penalize the lying spouse by awarding you legal costs and significantly reducing their credibility in future custody disputes.
Do I have to move out if the house is in my name?
Yes. If the EPO grants the applicant temporary exclusive possession of the home, you must leave immediately, regardless of who owns the property or pays the mortgage, until the judge reviews the case.
Leave a Reply