In Prince Edward Island, it is strictly illegal for an employer to fire or discipline you for refusing work that you genuinely believe is unsafe. If you are terminated for prioritizing your safety, you can file a “discriminatory action” complaint with the Workers Compensation Board (WCB) or pursue a wrongful dismissal claim with an employment lawyer.
Every worker has the fundamental right to return home safely at the end of the day. Under the Prince Edward Island Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHS Act), you have the legally protected right to refuse tasks that pose an unusual danger to your health or the health of others. Unfortunately, some employers care more about deadlines than safety protocols. When an employee speaks up about a hazard, a poorly managed company might respond by terminating their employment, cutting their hours, or suspending them without pay.
This type of retaliation is known as a reprisal or discriminatory action, and the law takes it very seriously. 📍 Whether you work on a busy construction site in Stratford, a manufacturing plant in Summerside, or a restaurant kitchen in Charlottetown, your safety rights are the same. Navigating a sudden job loss is terrifying, but the province has mechanisms to protect your income and your career. Many affected workers seek advice from a local law firm to determine if they should seek reinstatement through the government or sue for severance pay.
Step-by-Step Process in Prince Edward Island
Refusing unsafe work is not just about walking off the job; there is a specific legal procedure you must follow to ensure you remain protected under the law. Here is the step-by-step process most employees in PEI should follow when facing a safety dispute.
Step 1: Identify the Hazard and Refuse the Work
If you encounter a situation that you have reasonable grounds to believe is dangerous-such as missing fall protection, exposed wiring, or a lack of proper safety gear-you must immediately stop the task. You cannot simply go home; you must remain at the workplace in a safe area.
Step 2: Report to Your Supervisor Immediately
You must inform your direct supervisor or employer that you are refusing the work and clearly state the exact safety reason. The employer is legally required to investigate the hazard in your presence, often alongside a workplace health and safety representative. If the employer fixes the issue, you can return to work.
Step 3: Involve a PEI OHS Officer
If the employer insists the work is safe but you still believe it is dangerous, the next step is to call the OHS Division at the Workers Compensation Board of PEI. An OHS inspector will visit the site, investigate, and make a binding, written decision. During this waiting period, your employer can assign you other safe duties, but they cannot send you home without pay.
Step 4: Take Action if You Are Fired
If your employer fires you at any point during this process, it is considered illegal retaliation. You have two main options: you can file a formal complaint with the WCB regarding the discriminatory action, asking for your job back and lost wages, or you can hire an employment lawyer to sue for wrongful dismissal and demand a comprehensive severance package.
How Much Does it Cost in Prince Edward Island?
Fighting back against a wrongful dismissal due to safety concerns involves different costs depending on the route you choose.
- OHS Reprisal Complaint: Filing a discriminatory action complaint with the WCB is completely free. There are no government fees to have an officer investigate your termination.
- Law Firm Consultation: If you choose to sue for wrongful dismissal, an initial consultation with a PEI employment lawyer generally costs between $150 and $350 CAD.
- Contingency Fees: For strong wrongful dismissal cases, many law firms will represent you on a contingency basis, meaning you pay no upfront fees, but the lawyer takes roughly 25% to 33% of your final financial settlement.
| Legal Route Taken | Upfront Cost (CAD) | Potential Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| WCB Discriminatory Action Complaint | $0 | Job reinstatement & lost back-pay |
| Wrongful Dismissal Lawsuit | $0 – $350 (Consult) | Financial severance package |
| Hourly Legal Representation | $250 – $450/hour | Varies based on negotiation |
How Long Does the Process Take?
The timeline depends heavily on the complexity of the investigation. ⏳ An OHS inspector typically responds to an immediate work refusal within 24 to 48 hours. However, if you have already been fired and are filing a complaint for discriminatory action, the investigation and subsequent WCB hearings can take 3 to 6 months. If you choose the civil route and sue your employer in the Supreme Court of Prince Edward Island for wrongful dismissal, negotiating a settlement might take a few months, but a full trial can take 1 to 2 years.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Do I get paid while refusing unsafe work?
Yes. Under PEI law, you are entitled to your regular wages while the work refusal is being investigated. The employer can assign you reasonable alternative work during this time, which you must accept if it is safe.
Can I refuse work because it is unsafe for a co-worker?
Yes. The OHS Act allows you to refuse work if you have reasonable grounds to believe the task is likely to endanger yourself or any other person at the workplace.
What if the OHS officer says the work is safe?
If the provincial inspector formally declares the work safe, you must return to the task. If you continue to refuse after an inspector’s ruling, your employer may have legal grounds to discipline or dismiss you for insubordination.
Should I sign a release if my employer offers severance?
Never sign a release or accept a severance offer on the spot. Employers often offer low amounts hoping you will waive your rights. Always have an employment lawyer review the package to ensure it includes damages for the human rights violation.
Leave a Reply