If you are injured in a car crash while working in Ontario, and the at-fault driver was also working for a Schedule 1 employer, you generally cannot sue them in civil court. A Section 31 Application at the WSIAT determines this statutory bar, leaving you to rely solely on WSIB benefits.
Driving for work is inherently risky. 🚚 Whether you are a delivery driver navigating the busy streets of Toronto, a sales representative commuting to a client in Ottawa, or a tradesperson driving a company truck in Hamilton, motor vehicle accidents happen daily. In a standard Ontario car crash, the injured party usually sues the at-fault driver’s auto insurance company for pain, suffering, and economic losses. However, when both drivers are “in the course of their employment” at the time of the collision, the legal landscape changes dramatically.
Under the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act (WSIA), workers employed by Schedule 1 businesses are shielded from civil liability if they injure another Schedule 1 worker during employment. This is known as the statutory bar. If you attempt to file a personal injury lawsuit against the at-fault commercial driver, their insurance defense lawyers will almost certainly file a “Section 31 Application” with the Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal (WSIAT). The tribunal will then rule on whether your right to sue is taken away. If it is, your only recourse for financial survival is to claim Loss of Earnings and medical benefits through the WSIB.
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
Navigating the intersection of Ontario auto insurance laws and WSIB regulations requires careful strategic planning. 📝 Taking the wrong step early on can severely impact your financial recovery.
Step 1: Report the Collision to Police and WSIB
Immediately after a workplace car accident, ensure your safety and call 911. You must report the collision to the local police so an official Motor Vehicle Accident (MVA) report is generated. Because you were working, you also have a strict legal duty to inform your employer immediately so they can file a Form 7 with the WSIB. Do not attempt to hide the accident from the workers’ compensation board, even if you intend to sue.
Step 2: Investigate the At-Fault Driver’s Status
This is the most critical investigative step. 🔍 You need to find out exactly what the other driver was doing when they hit you. Were they driving a commercial delivery van? Were they on the clock for a Schedule 1 construction company? Finding this out quickly is vital. If they were simply a private citizen running personal errands, your right to sue them remains fully intact.
Step 3: Make Your Election (If Applicable)
If you discover that the at-fault driver is NOT a Schedule 1 worker, Ontario law requires you to make a formal “Election.” You must choose to either claim standard WSIB benefits (which are guaranteed but limited) OR launch a civil lawsuit against the at-fault driver (which can potentially award higher damages for pain and suffering but carries litigation risk). It is strongly advised to browse our directory to consult a personal injury lawyer before signing this election form.
Step 4: The WSIAT Section 31 Hearing
If the at-fault driver claims they were working for a Schedule 1 employer, they will file a Section 31 Application to stop your lawsuit. 💼 Your lawyer will represent you at the WSIAT hearing. The tribunal will intensely analyze whether both parties were strictly “in the course of employment.” If the WSIAT agrees with the defendant, your lawsuit is dismissed, and you must revert to the WSIB system for all your compensation.
| Accident Scenario | Are You Working? | Is At-Fault Driver Working? | Can You Sue in Ontario? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial Truck hits Company Van | Yes (Schedule 1) | Yes (Schedule 1) | No. Barred by Section 31. WSIB only. |
| Private Car hits Company Van | Yes (Schedule 1) | No (Off-duty) | Yes. You must choose WSIB or Sue. |
| Company Van hits you on weekend | No (Off-duty) | Yes (Schedule 1) | Yes. You are a private citizen. |
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Dealing with a motor vehicle accident that overlaps with WSIB can be financially complex.
- WSIAT Section 31 Application: The tribunal charges $0 CAD for this administrative filing.
- WSIB Election Form: Submitting your election to the board is completely free.
- Legal Fees: Whether you proceed with a civil lawsuit or end up pursuing a complex WSIB claim after a WSIAT defeat, most Ontario injury lawyers work on a contingency basis. They typically charge 25% to 33% of your civil settlement, or a similar percentage of your WSIB arrears.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The timeline heavily depends on whether your claim stays within WSIB or heads to the civil courts. 📅
- WSIB Route: If your lawsuit is barred and you claim WSIB benefits, you can start receiving Loss of Earnings payments within 2 to 4 weeks of filing your Form 6.
- WSIAT Challenge Route: If a Section 31 application is filed, it will freeze your lawsuit for 12 to 18 months while you wait for the tribunal’s final decision.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What if I was just commuting to work when the accident happened?
Generally, standard commuting to and from your regular workplace is not considered being “in the course of employment” under the WSIA. Therefore, if you are rear-ended on your morning commute, Section 31 usually will not bar you from suing the at-fault driver.
Can I claim WSIB and then sue later if my injuries get worse?
No. If you have the right to sue but officially elect to take WSIB benefits by signing the board’s Election Form, you permanently subrogate (transfer) your right to sue to the WSIB. You cannot change your mind months later if you discover your injuries are catastrophic.
What if the at-fault commercial driver was driving recklessly?
Even if the at-fault Schedule 1 driver was speeding, texting, or driving recklessly, the WSIA statutory immunity generally still applies. Gross negligence does not automatically void the Schedule 1 protection in Ontario motor vehicle accidents.
Does my own auto insurance company get involved?
Yes, but it is complicated. If you are restricted to WSIB benefits, your auto insurer will generally step back. However, if your WSIB benefits do not fully cover certain items, you may sometimes claim top-up Statutory Accident Benefits (SABS) from your auto insurer, but WSIB is always the primary payer.
Leave a Reply