In Ontario, a dying person can legally sever a joint tenancy property into a tenancy in common right before passing away, effectively preventing the surviving owner from automatically inheriting the home. For executors, proving this last-minute severance is valid is critical to pushing the deceased’s half into the estate, though legal fees to register and defend the severance often start around $4,000 CAD.
Estate planning often involves difficult family dynamics, and sometimes, drastic decisions are made in the final weeks of a person’s life. One of the most aggressive last-minute strategies in Ontario is the “deathbed severance” of a joint tenancy. When two people-such as an estranged husband and wife-own a home as “joint tenants,” the property carries a “right of survivorship.” This means if one person dies, the surviving owner automatically absorbs the entire property, bypassing the Will entirely. For a dying spouse who desperately wants to leave their half of the house to their children from a previous marriage, this automatic transfer is a disaster. 📝
To stop this, the dying individual can sever the joint ownership, converting it into a “tenancy in common.” In a tenancy in common, there is no right of survivorship. Each owner holds a distinct 50% share, and when one dies, their share flows directly into their estate to be distributed according to their Will. As an executor, you may inherit a situation where this severance was executed just days before death. Your job is to prove it was done legally, secure the property, and navigate the inevitable conflict with the surviving owner. This guide explains how executors must handle this highly contested scenario. 🔍
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
Dealing with a deathbed severance requires immediate action. Whether the property is located in Brampton, Markham, or Ottawa, the surviving owner may rush to claim full ownership, assuming the right of survivorship applies. As the executor, you must secure the legal paperwork instantly. 📍
Step 1: Understand the Legal Test for Severance
In Ontario, a joint tenancy can be severed unilaterally-meaning the dying person does not need the permission or signature of the other owner. However, the severance must be legally complete before the person breathes their last breath. You cannot retroactively sever a property after death.
Severance is usually achieved by registering a Transfer/Deed on the property title to oneself, effectively breaking the joint ownership. Alternatively, it can be severed through a clear, written course of dealing that demonstrates both parties treated their shares as separate. Most applicants in this province rely on a registered deed, as it provides the most undeniable proof. 📝
Step 2: Locate the Registered Transfer Documents
Your first task as executor is to verify the paperwork. Contact the real estate lawyer who assisted the deceased in their final days. Ask for a copy of the registered Transfer/Deed.
You should also order a Parcel Register from the Ontario Land Registry Office. This official document will show exactly when the severance was registered. If it was successfully registered at 2:00 PM and the deceased passed away at 8:00 PM that same evening, the severance is legally binding, and the estate now owns 50% of the property. ⏱
Step 3: Secure the Estate’s Share of the Property
Once you confirm the estate owns half the home as a tenant in common, you must protect that asset. Notify the surviving owner immediately, preferably through your estate lawyer. Inform them that the joint tenancy was severed and the estate is now a co-owner.
You must also ensure the property remains insured. If the surviving owner lives in the home, you will need to negotiate terms regarding property taxes, utility payments, and potential “occupation rent”-where the surviving owner pays the estate rent for living in the estate’s half of the house. 💵
Step 4: Defend Against Legal Challenges
A deathbed severance almost always sparks outrage from the surviving owner, who expected to inherit a free house. They will likely hire a lawyer to challenge the validity of the severance at the Superior Court of Justice.
The most common attack is claiming the deceased lacked the “mental capacity” to sign legal documents on their deathbed, or that they were “unduly influenced” by whoever inherits under the Will. To defend against this, your lawyer will need to call upon the deceased’s real estate lawyer and medical staff to testify that the deceased was lucid and fully understood their actions when they severed the title. 👨
Step 5: Include the Asset in the Probate Application
Because the right of survivorship was broken, the 50% share of the property now forms part of the deceased’s estate. You must include the fair market value of that 50% share on your Application for a Certificate of Appointment of Estate Trustee (probate).
This means the estate is now responsible for paying the Ontario Estate Administration Tax on that real estate value. Once probate is granted, you can either sell the estate’s half to the surviving owner or force the sale of the entire property to liquidate the asset. 💰
How Much Does it Cost in Ontario?
Managing and defending a deathbed severance is an expensive ordeal, as it touches on both real estate law and estate litigation. Here are the expected costs in Canadian dollars:
- Land Registry Fees: The cost to pull title searches and verify the Parcel Register is minimal, usually around $40 to $80 CAD.
- Executor Legal Fees (Non-Litigation): Hiring a lawyer to navigate the co-ownership agreement and file for probate typically costs $3,000 to $6,000 CAD.
- Estate Administration Tax: You must pay roughly 1.5% on the value of the estate’s 50% share of the home to the provincial government.
- Litigation Defence Costs: If the surviving owner sues the estate claiming the deceased lacked mental capacity, defending the severance in court can cost the estate $20,000 to $50,000+ CAD.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The actual act of severing the joint tenancy is incredibly fast and can be registered by a real estate lawyer in a single afternoon.
However, the aftermath takes much longer. Securing a Grant of Probate in Ontario currently takes about 6 to 10 months. If the surviving owner refuses to sell the home or buy out the estate’s share, you will have to file an application under the Partition Act to force a sale, which adds another 6 to 12 months. If they sue for lack of capacity, expect a 2 to 3-year delay. 📅
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does the other owner have to be notified before the severance?
No. In Ontario, one joint tenant can unilaterally sever the joint tenancy without the permission, signature, or even advance knowledge of the other owner. The surviving owner often only finds out after the death occurs.
What if the severance documents were signed but not registered in time?
This is a highly complex legal grey area. Generally, if the documents were signed and delivered to the lawyer with clear, irrevocable instructions to register them before the person died, courts may rule that the severance was effective in equity, even if the Land Registry Office was closed.
Can a Power of Attorney sever a joint tenancy?
Usually, no. A Power of Attorney for Property cannot generally be used to change a person’s estate plan or sever a joint tenancy just to benefit the PoA holder, unless the document contains incredibly specific language authorizing it.
How is the house sold if the surviving owner refuses to move?
As an executor, if you own 50% as a tenant in common, you can apply to the Superior Court under the Ontario Partition Act. The judge will issue a court order forcing the listing and sale of the property, and the proceeds will be split evenly.
Will the CRA charge capital gains on the severance?
If the property was the deceased’s principal residence, the severance and subsequent death will not trigger capital gains tax. However, if it was an investment property or a family cottage, there will be a deemed disposition at death, triggering tax liabilities for the estate.
Leave a Reply