In Ontario, you can still successfully pursue a wrongful death claim even if your deceased loved one was partially responsible for the accident. Under the province’s Negligence Act, your final financial settlement will simply be reduced by the exact percentage of fault assigned to your loved one (known as contributory negligence).
When a tragic fatal accident occurs, commercial insurance companies are incredibly quick to point fingers. If your loved one was killed while jaywalking in Scarborough, or if they were riding a motorcycle in North York slightly above the speed limit when a massive truck struck them, the defence lawyers will aggressively argue that it was their own fault.
Many grieving families mistakenly believe that if their loved one made a minor mistake, they have absolutely no right to seek justice. 🚫 Fortunately, Ontario law is much fairer than that. The civil justice system recognizes shared blame, allowing your family to still recover massive financial support for your devastating loss. Because fighting these complex liability disputes requires highly aggressive legal tactics, we suggest browsing our directory to connect with a fierce local trial lawyer.
Step-by-Step Process for Partial Fault Claims in Toronto
Overcoming the insurance company’s “blame the victim” strategy is the hardest part of these specific lawsuits. Your legal team will actively build a formidable wall of evidence using the following structured approach.
Step 1: Securing Independent Accident Reconstruction
You cannot simply rely on the initial Toronto Police Service collision report, as they sometimes make strict assumptions about a deceased victim who cannot speak for themselves. 🔍 Your lawyer will urgently hire independent forensic traffic reconstruction engineers. These experts will physically measure the crash site, analyze the vehicle’s black box data, and scientifically prove exactly how much the other driver was actually at fault.
Step 2: Applying the Ontario Negligence Act
Your lawyer will heavily utilize the strict rules of the Ontario Negligence Act. This provincial law explicitly states that fault can be divided. For example, a judge might rule that the commercial truck driver was 70% at fault for running a red light, but your loved one was 30% at fault for not wearing a seatbelt. Your lawyer’s primary goal is to minimize your loved one’s legal percentage of fault as much as mathematically possible.
Step 3: Calculating Family Law Act Damages
Before any final percentages are applied, your legal team must accurately calculate the total value of your family’s tragic loss. 💻 They will evaluate the total loss of shared household income, the cost of future care, and the deep emotional loss of guidance and companionship under the Family Law Act. If the total calculated damages are $1,000,000 CAD, and the deceased was 30% at fault, your grieving family is still legally entitled to $700,000 CAD.
Step 4: Aggressive Settlement Negotiations
Armed with highly scientific engineering reports, your lawyer will enter into intense negotiations with the at-fault party’s massive insurance company. Because going to trial is highly risky and expensive for everyone, most partial-fault wrongful death claims are eventually settled fairly out of court, often during a formal mediation session in downtown Toronto.
How Much Does it Cost to Fight Liability in Toronto?
Proving the other party was truly at fault requires highly expensive expert witnesses. 💵 Fortunately, reputable wrongful death lawyers fund these massive disbursements entirely out of their own pockets, strictly operating on a contingency fee basis.
| Lawyer’s Upfront Retainer Fee | $0 (Contingency Agreement) |
| Superior Court Filing Fee | $343 (Paid by your law firm) |
| Independent Traffic Engineers / Experts | $5,000 – $15,000+ (Funded by your law firm) |
| Contingency Legal Fee | Typically 30% to 33% of the final payout |
How Long Does the Process Take?
When the commercial insurance company fiercely argues that your deceased loved one was completely at fault, they will intentionally drag out the legal process. ⏳ In Toronto, you can generally expect a heavily disputed partial-fault wrongful death lawsuit to take between 3 to 5 years before a final financial settlement or trial verdict is formally reached at the Superior Court of Justice.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What happens if my loved one is found to be 60% at fault?
In Ontario, there is absolutely no bar to recovery even if the victim was mostly at fault. If your loved one was legally determined to be 60% responsible for the fatal accident, your grieving family is still fully entitled to collect the remaining 40% of the total calculated financial damages from the other negligent party.
Does this contributory negligence rule apply to pedestrian accidents?
Yes, absolutely. Even if a pedestrian was technically jaywalking or crossing against a red light in Toronto, drivers still have a strict legal duty to keep a proper lookout. A judge will often split the liability, allowing the pedestrian’s surviving family to successfully recover substantial compensation.
Will the insurance company unfairly try to blame my loved one?
Yes, almost always. Insurance adjusters are trained to protect their corporate profits. They will routinely search for any minor reason—such as arguing the deceased was wearing dark clothing at night or driving slightly over the limit—to artificially inflate their percentage of fault. You need a strong lawyer to aggressively fight back.
Are the Statutory Accident Benefits (SABS) also reduced by fault?
No. The immediate Statutory Accident Benefits, which importantly include the immediate funeral death benefit and spousal income replacement, are considered strictly “no-fault” under Ontario law. Your family will receive these crucial funds in full, regardless of who caused the tragic accident.
Leave a Reply