In Ontario, the legal duty to mitigate does not force you to accept just any job offer. You are generally completely within your rights to reject a job that is not considered “comparable”-meaning it involves a massive pay cut, a severe demotion in status, or an unreasonable commute-without jeopardizing your common law severance claim.
After being wrongfully dismissed, the race to find a new job can feel overwhelming. 💼 Your former employer’s legal counsel will constantly remind you that you have a strict “duty to mitigate” your financial losses. This often leads to severe anxiety when you receive a job offer that is simply terrible compared to your old career.
Many employees incorrectly assume that turning down any job offer will automatically void their right to a severance package. However, Ontario employment law applies a test of reasonableness. Judges at the Superior Court of Justice clearly understand that you should not be forced to derail your career or accept degrading work simply to save your former employer money.
Step-by-Step Process in Ontario
Whether you are a senior executive in Toronto, a warehouse manager in Hamilton, or a software developer in Markham, evaluating new job offers strategically is critical. 📈 Follow these steps to safely reject a bad offer while protecting your severance.
Step 1: Objectively Evaluate ‘Comparability’
When an offer arrives, compare it meticulously against your old job. Courts look at several factors: base salary, bonus structures, health benefits, seniority level, managerial authority, and commuting distance. If a Director of Marketing is offered a role as a junior copywriter at a 40% pay cut, it is objectively not comparable, and rejecting it is legally safe.
Step 2: Document Your Exact Reasons for Refusal
Never simply ignore a recruiter or verbally decline an offer without proof. 🗒 Send a polite email declining the position, and internally document exactly why the job was unsuitable. If you turned it down because it required a two-hour commute each way or lacked the health benefits you need for your family, having a contemporaneous written record is vital evidence for your lawyer.
Step 3: Continue Your Meticulous Job Search
Rejecting one unsuitable job offer is fine, but completely stopping your job hunt is not. You must immediately resume applying for genuinely comparable roles. Keep your “mitigation log” updated with every application, networking email, and interview. This proves to the court that you are genuinely trying to re-enter the workforce, not simply resting on your laurels waiting for a massive severance cheque.
Step 4: Have Your Lawyer Defend Your Decision
Your former employer will almost certainly weaponize your rejection, claiming you “failed to mitigate.” An experienced employment law firm will push back aggressively, citing established Ontario case law to demonstrate that the rejected offer was fundamentally inferior and that your decision to hold out for a proper role was legally justified.
How Much Does It Cost in Ontario?
Defending your right to wait for the right career opportunity involves standard legal fees associated with wrongful dismissal claims.
| Legal Action | Estimated Cost in CAD (As of May 2026) |
|---|---|
| Reviewing a Job Offer | Having a lawyer review a new contract to see if it is ‘comparable’ generally costs a flat fee of $350 to $700 CAD. |
| Court Filing Fee | Filing a Statement of Claim for wrongful dismissal at an Ontario courthouse costs roughly $339 CAD. |
| Lawyer Contingency Fee | Most employment lawyers take 25% to 35% of the total severance payout only if they successfully win or settle your case. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Proving that you reasonably mitigated your damages can influence the timeline of your case. 🕐 If you quickly find a genuinely comparable job after rejecting a bad one, your lawyer can mathematically finalize your exact damages and negotiate a rapid settlement in 2 to 4 months. If the former employer refuses to pay and insists you failed to mitigate by rejecting the first offer, reaching a trial or formal mediation at the Superior Court can take 1.5 to 2.5 years.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What if my old employer offers me my old job back?
This is a highly complex legal scenario. If the relationship is entirely poisoned, or they are offering it at a lower salary, you can usually reject it. However, if it is the exact same job, same pay, and the workplace is not toxic, Ontario courts may rule that refusing to return is a failure to mitigate.
Can I reject a job because it requires 100% in-office work?
If your previous role was entirely remote, and the new offer requires a massive daily commute, you generally have a strong argument that it is not comparable. However, if the commute is standard for your city (like a typical 45-minute drive in Toronto), a judge might view rejecting it as unreasonable.
Do I have to switch careers if my industry is dying?
Initially, you are only expected to search within your own field. However, if a judge determines that comparable work in your specific niche is genuinely non-existent, the law expects you to gradually broaden your search to related industries as the months drag on.
Will rejecting a job cut off my EI benefits?
Service Canada rules are strictly separate from common law severance rules. If Service Canada believes you rejected suitable employment without a valid reason, they may temporarily suspend or fully terminate your Employment Insurance (EI) payments.
Leave a Reply