In Ontario, if your employer fires you in a cruel, humiliating, or bad-faith manner-such as loudly escorting you out with security or lying about your conduct-you may be entitled to aggravated damages. These can add tens of thousands of dollars (CAD) on top of your standard severance package at the Superior Court of Justice.
Understanding Bad Faith Terminations in Ontario
Losing your livelihood is an inherently upsetting experience. 😢 However, under Ontario employment law, employers have a strict legal duty of good faith and fair dealing during the termination process. This means that while a company in Toronto, Ottawa, or Mississauga is legally allowed to fire you without cause, they are absolutely not allowed to be unduly insensitive, untruthful, or unnecessarily harsh when doing so.
When an employer breaches this duty-perhaps by firing you immediately after you return from a medical leave, humiliating you in front of colleagues, or making false allegations of “just cause” to bully you into accepting zero severance-it causes profound psychological harm. 📍 To compensate for this specific mental distress, the Superior Court of Justice can award “aggravated damages” (historically known in Canadian law as Wallace damages or Honda v. Keays damages). These damages are awarded as a distinct financial penalty paid directly to the employee.
Step-by-Step Process for Claiming Aggravated Damages in Ontario
Proving mental distress requires more than just showing that you were sad about losing your job. 📝 You must prove that the employer’s conduct was exceptionally poor and that it caused verifiable psychological harm. If you have experienced a traumatic dismissal, follow these steps to build a strong legal case.
Step 1: Document the Humiliating Conduct Immediately
Write down a detailed account of the termination meeting as soon as you get home. 📄 Did they march you out of the building with security guards while your coworkers watched? Did they falsely accuse you of theft? Gather any insensitive emails or witness statements from sympathetic colleagues who saw the humiliating display.
Step 2: Seek Medical Attention
Aggravated damages require evidence of actual mental distress that goes beyond normal grief. 👨 You must visit your family doctor or a registered psychologist in Ontario. If the firing caused clinical depression, severe anxiety, or insomnia, your doctor will need to provide medical records or a specialized report to substantiate your claim in court.
Step 3: Do Not Sign a Release
Employers who act in bad faith often shove a lowball severance offer across the table and demand you sign it instantly. 🚫 Never sign a release under extreme emotional duress. Doing so will legally bar you from ever suing for aggravated damages or your proper common law severance package.
Step 4: File a Lawsuit at the Superior Court of Justice
Hire a dedicated employment law firm. ⚖ Your lawyer will combine your claim for standard wrongful dismissal severance with a specialized claim for aggravated damages. They will issue a Statement of Claim at the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, which often forces abusive employers to the mediation table to avoid a public trial.
How Much Does it Cost to Sue for Mental Distress?
Victims of bad faith terminations are often financially and emotionally depleted. 💰 Fortunately, accessing justice in Ontario does not require massive upfront wealth.
| Cost Component | Average Cost in Ontario (CAD) | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Lawyer Contingency Fee | 25% to 35% of the total award | No upfront hourly fees. The law firm takes a percentage only if they successfully recover your damages. |
| Medical Reports | $500 to $2,500 CAD | Fees paid to your doctor or psychologist to draft an expert report proving your mental distress. |
| Court Filing Fees | $228 CAD | Mandatory provincial fee to have the registrar issue your Statement of Claim. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Seeking aggravated damages can sometimes extend the litigation timeline. 🕎 Because employers rarely want to admit they acted cruelly, they may aggressively defend their actions. While a standard severance claim might settle in 2 to 3 months, cases involving extensive medical evidence of mental distress often proceed through discoveries and mediation, typically taking 1.5 to 2.5 years to reach a settlement or trial.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is crying during termination enough to claim mental distress?
No. It is normal to cry or feel upset when fired. To win aggravated damages in Ontario, you must prove that the employer acted in bad faith (e.g., lying, malicious behaviour) AND that their conduct caused a compensable psychological injury beyond standard upset, usually backed by medical evidence.
Are punitive damages the same as aggravated damages?
No. Aggravated damages compensate the employee for their actual mental suffering. Punitive damages are extremely rare and are meant purely to punish the employer for conduct that is malicious, oppressive, and high-handed, acting as a deterrent against future bad behaviour.
What if they fired me while I was on sick leave?
Firing an employee who is on an approved medical leave or disability is highly scrutinized by Ontario courts. It is often viewed as a bad faith termination that warrants aggravated damages, and it may also violate the Ontario Human Rights Code, entitling you to additional human rights damages.
Will my severance be taxed if it includes aggravated damages?
Standard severance pay is considered a “retiring allowance” and is taxable by the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). However, damages awarded specifically for mental distress or personal injury (like aggravated damages) are generally tax-free. Your lawyer can structure the settlement to optimize your tax position.
You do not have to accept abusive or humiliating treatment from a former employer. If you suffered a traumatic dismissal in Ontario that caused serious mental distress, use our directory to find a compassionate employment lawyer who can hold your employer accountable and secure the damages you deserve.
Leave a Reply