If you are fired for just cause in New Brunswick over a false accusation, the burden of proof rests entirely on your employer. To prove wrongful dismissal, you must gather your own evidence, demand your personnel file, and potentially file a claim at the Court of King’s Bench to force the employer to either prove the misconduct or pay your full severance.
Being fired is hard enough, but being fired for something you did not do is infuriating and damaging to your reputation. 🚨 When an employer accuses you of theft, harassment, or severe insubordination, they will often use it as an excuse to fire you for “just cause.” Firing someone for just cause means the employer does not have to pay you a single dime in severance.
However, the legal threshold for just cause in Canada is incredibly high. Whether you work in Saint John, Fredericton, or Bathurst, an employer cannot simply take another employee’s word for it or make a hasty assumption. They must have concrete proof. This guide outlines how you can fight back, clear your name, and secure the financial compensation you deserve.
Step-by-Step Process in New Brunswick
Fighting a false accusation requires a strategic and calm approach. Do not let anger dictate your actions. ⏳ Here are the critical steps to proving a wrongful dismissal.
Step 1: Do Not Confess or Sign Anything
In the meeting where you are accused and fired, your employer might pressure you to sign a document admitting fault or accepting a tiny payout. Do not sign anything. Take your termination letter, pack up your personal belongings, and leave quietly. Any angry outbursts can actually be used against you later to justify the firing.
Step 2: Preserve All Relevant Evidence
Before your access to the company systems is completely revoked (if possible), or immediately when you get home, write down everything you remember. 📞 Save text messages, voicemails, and contact information for coworkers who can act as witnesses. If you were accused of being late or stealing time, gather your Google Maps location history or personal transit records to prove your whereabouts.
Step 3: Demand Your Personnel File
Under New Brunswick privacy laws, you generally have a right to request access to your personal information held by the company. Send a formal, written request to HR asking for a complete copy of your personnel file, including performance reviews and the specific investigation report regarding the accusation. Often, employers fail to properly investigate, which strengthens your wrongful dismissal case.
Step 4: Have a Lawyer Send a Demand Letter
Hire an employment lawyer to formally dispute the “just cause” termination. Your lawyer will send a demand letter stating that the accusation is false, the employer failed to meet the legal burden of proof, and that you are therefore entitled to full common law reasonable notice. 💰 Often, facing a lawsuit causes the employer to back down and offer a settlement.
Step 5: File a Claim at the Court of King’s Bench
If the employer stubbornly refuses to pay, you will file a Statement of Claim for wrongful dismissal at the Court of King’s Bench. During the legal process of “discovery,” your employer will be legally forced to hand over their internal emails and prove their accusations under oath. If they cannot, the judge will order them to pay your severance, and potentially extra aggravated damages for ruining your reputation.
How Much Does it Cost in New Brunswick?
Taking legal action against a former employer is an investment in clearing your name and securing your financial future. 💵
- Initial Consultation: Many employment lawyers in Moncton or Saint John will review your termination letter and the accusations for a flat fee of $300 to $500 CAD.
- Contingency Agreements: If your case is strong, a lawyer may take it on contingency. You pay $0 upfront, and they take 25% to 35% of the settlement they force the employer to pay.
- Court Costs: Filing a formal lawsuit costs around $100 to $200 CAD in provincial court fees. If you win, the judge usually orders the employer to reimburse you for a large portion of your legal expenses.
| Demand Letter | $500 – $1,500 CAD | Often resolves the issue without court. |
| Contingency Fee | 25% – 35% of payout | No win, no fee structure. |
| Aggravated Damages | Varies widely | Extra money awarded if the employer acted maliciously. |
How Long Does the Process Take?
Resolving a wrongful dismissal based on a false accusation takes time. ⌛ If your lawyer sends a strong demand letter highlighting the lack of evidence, the employer might agree to a settlement within 4 to 8 weeks.
However, if the employer truly believes their false accusation or wants to make things difficult, litigation is required. Taking a wrongful dismissal case through the Court of King’s Bench to a full trial can take anywhere from 1 to 2 years.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can I get Employment Insurance (EI) if I was fired for cause?
Service Canada usually denies EI if your Record of Employment (ROE) says you were fired for misconduct. However, you can appeal this decision, explain the accusation is false, and ask Service Canada to do their own fact-finding.
Does poor performance count as just cause?
Almost never. To fire you for poor performance without severance, the employer must have given you multiple clear warnings, training, and a reasonable chance to improve. True just cause is usually reserved for theft, fraud, or violence.
Can I sue for defamation as well?
Yes. If the employer spread the false accusation to your coworkers or to other businesses in your industry, you can potentially sue for defamation alongside your wrongful dismissal claim.
What if my employer asks to do a workplace investigation after firing me?
An employer is supposed to investigate thoroughly before firing you, not after. If they are investigating after the fact, they are likely trying to build a case retroactively. Speak to a lawyer before participating.
Leave a Reply