In complex Canadian consumer proposals, major creditors can appoint up to three ‘inspectors’ to oversee the Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT). This ensures transparency, giving creditors a voice in how the debtor’s estate is administered, especially in high-debt B2B scenarios.
When an individual or small business owner files a consumer proposal in Canada, they are making a legal offer to settle their debts for less than what is owed. While most simple proposals are administered solely by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) without much creditor interference, complex cases-especially those involving significant tax debt or business loans-often trigger a higher level of scrutiny. Under the federal Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), creditors have the legal right to appoint an ‘inspector’ to monitor the process.
An inspector is essentially a representative chosen by the creditors to look over the LIT’s shoulder. 👤 Whether the debtor operates a local shop in Mississauga, Ontario, or a consulting firm in Halifax, Nova Scotia, the rules remain the same. The inspector’s job is not to punish the debtor, but to ensure the estate is administered fairly, assets are properly evaluated, and the LIT’s fees are justified. This process is particularly common when the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) is the majority creditor.
Step-by-Step Process of Appointing an Inspector
The appointment of an inspector does not happen automatically. It requires a formal process during the initial stages of the consumer proposal. Here is how the process generally unfolds across Canada.
Step 1: Calling the First Meeting of Creditors
A meeting is not automatic. However, if the Official Receiver or creditors representing at least 25% of the value of proven claims submit a request within 45 days of the proposal being filed, the LIT must call a First Meeting of Creditors. 📄 This meeting is scheduled and held within 21 days after it has been called, rather than immediately upon receiving the request. At this meeting, creditors gather (often virtually or at a local government centre) to discuss the terms, ask questions, and vote on the offer.
Step 2: Nominating Potential Inspectors
During this meeting, any eligible creditor can nominate themselves or a third party to act as an inspector. It is common for large institutional creditors, such as major Canadian banks or the CRA, to nominate their own internal recovery officers. Under Section 66.21 of the BIA, the number of inspectors in a consumer proposal is strictly limited to a maximum of three.
Step 3: Voting on the Appointment
Once nominations are made, the creditors vote. ⏱ Voting power is directly proportional to the amount of money owed (e.g., a creditor owed $50,000 has more voting weight than one owed $5,000). A simple majority in the dollar value of the votes cast is required to officially appoint the inspector.
Step 4: The Inspector Assumes Their Duties
Once appointed, the inspector must formally accept the role. They are legally bound to act in the best interests of all creditors, not just the company that nominated them. Their duties include reviewing the LIT’s administrative accounts, approving the sale of any specific assets (if applicable in a division I proposal or complex consumer proposal), and authorizing the LIT to engage in legal action if fraudulent activity is suspected.
How Much Does it Cost in Canada?
Debtors often worry that appointing an inspector will increase the overall cost of their consumer proposal. Here is the reality of the financial structure:
- No Salary from the Estate: Inspectors are not paid a salary or hourly wage out of the debtor’s estate. They usually act as part of their standard employment duties for the creditor (e.g., a bank employee).
- Out-of-Pocket Expenses: Inspectors are entitled to be reimbursed for reasonable out-of-pocket expenses (such as travelling to a meeting), which are paid out of the proposal funds before the final dividend is distributed to creditors.
- LIT Fees: The LIT’s fees are strictly regulated by the federal government and do not increase simply because an inspector is appointed, though complex files may require more administrative work.
How Long Does the Process Take?
The actual appointment takes place entirely during the First Meeting of Creditors, which usually lasts between 1 to 2 hours. ⏱ However, the inspector’s role continues for the entire duration of the consumer proposal. In Canada, a consumer proposal can last anywhere from a few months up to a legal maximum of 5 years (60 months). The inspector remains active until the LIT receive their final discharge and the file is officially closed.
Comparison: Role of the LIT vs. Inspector
| Duty / Responsibility | Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) | Appointed Inspector |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Role | Administers the proposal, handles funds | Oversees the LIT, represents creditors |
| Who do they represent? | Officers of the Court (Neutral) | The collective unsecured creditors |
| Approving Fees | Submits fees based on federal tariffs | Reviews and approves the final statement |
| Legal Action | Executes lawsuits if authorized | Provides the authorization to sue |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can a family member be appointed as an inspector?
While close relatives of the debtor (such as a spouse, parent, or sibling) are strictly barred from voting on the appointment of inspectors under the BIA, the law does not explicitly forbid them from serving as inspectors. However, due to the high risk of conflict of interest, such an appointment is extremely unlikely in practice.
Can the debtor refuse the appointment of an inspector?
No. The appointment of an inspector is entirely the legal right of the creditors. If the creditors vote to appoint one, the debtor must cooperate fully with both the LIT and the inspector throughout the proposal.
What happens if an inspector acts unfairly?
Inspectors have a fiduciary duty to all creditors. If an inspector acts maliciously or in bad faith, the LIT or other creditors can apply to the local bankruptcy court (such as the Supreme Court of British Columbia) to have the inspector removed or replaced.
Is an inspector common in personal consumer proposals?
It is relatively rare in standard, straightforward personal consumer proposals. Inspectors are usually only appointed in complex cases, high-net-worth files, or scenarios involving significant business debts and tax arrears with the CRA.
Leave a Reply